- 42,808
- 10,496
There's an error in the first line. The f(a/2) terms are k=1 in the sum, so only get a factor 3, not 9. When you correct that your last line will be much more useful.
The forum discussion centers on proving that the function f: R -> R is constant under the constraint of the inequality |Σ (from k=1 to n) 3^k [f(x+ky) - f(x-ky)]| ≤ 1 for all real x and y. Participants explore various approaches, including differentiation and the Mean Value Theorem, to establish that the derivative f'(c) must equal zero for some value c. The conversation concludes that as n increases, the bounds on |f(a) - f(-a)| tighten, ultimately leading to the conclusion that f must be constant.
PREREQUISITESMathematics students, educators, and researchers interested in real analysis, particularly those focused on function properties and proofs of constancy in mathematical functions.
Right. Again, a can be any value. In post #20 you showed ##|f(a)-f(-a)|\le \frac 13##, and using that you've improved it to ##\frac 29##. Can you see how to turn this process into an induction, or maybe a reductio ad absurdum, to show it must be zero?AdityaDev said:Sorry for the delay.
$$3|f(a/2)-f(-a/2)|+9|f(a)-f(-a)|\le 1$$
$$9|f(a)-f(-a)|\le 3|f(a)-f(-a)|+1$$
And ##f(t)-f(-t)\le 1/3 ## from post #21
Hence $$|f(a)-f(-a)|\le 2/9$$
AdityaDev said:Yes. For n=3, y=a/3, you get ##|f(a)-f(-a)|\le 5/27##
So it keeps decreasing.
I have two responses to that.AdityaDev said:In the original expression, the summation is only upto n.