- #1
brmath
- 329
- 34
Right now all the material about complex functions is in the general math section. Complex analysis comes up a lot and probably deserves a section of its own, or at least to be put in the analysis section.
The description of the "Topology & Analysis" forum says:brmath said:Complex analysis comes up a lot and probably deserves a section of its own, or at least to be put in the analysis section.
I.e., complex analysis is already there.Point-set topology. Real, complex, harmonic and functional analysis. Measure and integration theory
strangerep said:The description of the "Topology & Analysis" forum says:
I.e., complex analysis is already there.
brmath said:Of course, trying to categorize mathematical topics is very difficult because math is very intertwined and no matter what category you choose, something from some other category will pop up there.
Surely you jest? You do realize that there is a limit to pointless pedanticism don't you? If you're being serious then boy...just boy.jackmell said:And in my opinion, we're doing a dis-service both to the field and to students wishing to learn about it by placing it there.
strangerep said:Micromass did a fantastic job of reorganizing the math forums some time ago. Imho, the new organization is a considerable improvement over the old, although there was inevitably some nitpicking. You can't please everybody.
A couple of remarks:
"Complex analysis" is a much larger (and more advanced) subject than mere calculus of complex variables.
"Harmonic analysis" is likewise a much larger and advanced subject than you seem to realize.
For "complex variables" to justify its own forum there would have to be a sufficient number of threads on that subject such that it dominated the existing forum(s). What is the current creation rate of new threads on that subject in the existing forum(s)?
OTOH, I think a case could be made for augmenting the description of the "Calculus" forum to say
"Real & complex elementary functions"...
WannabeNewton said:Surely you jest? You do realize that there is a limit to pointless pedanticism don't you? If you're being serious then boy...just boy.
brmath said:Actually I'm looking to answer questions or see answers, not so much to post them. When I go to the analysis section I then have to troll through numerous questions that would not interest me. So it would be easier if the complex analysis were in a separate section.
Complex variables refer to mathematical quantities that have both a real and imaginary component. They are often represented in the form of a + bi, where a is the real part and bi is the imaginary part.
Complex variables can be quite complex and involve advanced mathematical concepts. By putting them into a separate forum, it allows for a more focused and organized discussion for those who are interested in this topic.
Scientists, mathematicians, and anyone who is interested in learning more about complex variables would benefit from a separate forum. It allows for a dedicated space for experts and enthusiasts to share knowledge and discuss ideas.
In a forum for complex variables, you can find discussions about various applications of complex variables, techniques for solving complex equations, and debates about the nature of complex numbers and their properties.
There is no specific format for discussing complex variables in a forum. However, it is important to use clear and concise language, provide background information, and use proper mathematical notation to facilitate effective communication and understanding among forum members.