Quantum field theory and the hydrogen atom

7 replies · 4K views · last reply
arupel
Messages
45
Reaction score
2
Quantum mechanics does a good job in describing the hydrogen atom. Are there any views either mathematically or conceptually in describing the hydrogen atom?
 
Could you check if you forgot some words in your question? Your question title suggests that maybe you meant to ask whether quantum field theory has anything to say regarding the hydrogen atom on top of what quantum mechanics has to say?

If so, the answer is Yes! The first such QFT effect on the hydrogen atom is called the Lamb shift.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vanhees71, bhobba and Demystifier
The first calculation you should do in this context (but the question is a bit blurry, as Urs stated) is to calculate the Compton wavelength of the electron in Hydrogen and compare this to the size of the hydrogen atom. This should give you a good understanding why "ordinary" QM is so succesfull in explaining the spectrum of hydrogen.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vanhees71
This is well within Standard Model, nothing beyond. A moderator could move it to the quantum one, if the OP sticks to the title.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vanhees71
dextercioby said:
This is well within Standard Model, nothing beyond. A moderator could move it to the quantum one, if the OP sticks to the title.
Moved.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vanhees71
I have a general idea about QFT, but not much more. I see QFT as dealing with fields. I was surprised that a QFT effect is the Lamb shift. Could someone give a general basic description how this works.

Thanks,
Arthur Rupel

PS I thought QM had one up on QFT. Evidently I was wrong.

Thanks, Arthur Rupel
 
arupel said:
Could someone give a general basic description how this works.

The Lamb shift is a tiny shift in the energy spectrum of excitations of the electron orbits in the hydrogen atom.

Energy level diagram of low-lying hydrogen levels: 1S1/2 splits into F=1 and F=0 hyperfine levels 1420 MHz apart; 2S1/2 splits by 178 MHz; 2P1/2 by 59 MHz; 2P3/2 by 24 MHz; with 243 nm, 2466 THz, 1058 MHz and 9910 MHz intervals and 8173 MHz to 1S1/2 from Dirac theory.


This is a “fine structure” effect not seen by the quantum mechanics of the electron, but resulting from radiative corrections involving photon emission/absorption only seen by regarding the electron in [URL='https://www.physicsforums.com/insights/paqft-idea-references/']perturbative quantum field theory[/URL], here in quantum electrodynamics.

The Lamb shift may be attributed to 1-loop Feynman diagrams contributions giving “radiative corrections” to the basic tree level vertex that describes the basic interaction of the electron with the background electromagnetic field, hence called vertex corrections.

Six Feynman diagrams labeled a to f, each showing electron lines and a wavy photon line meeting a dot. a and b show self-energy loops, c a vertex correction, d and e electron mass counterterms, f a photon self-energy loop. Caption lists them as higher-order graphs contributing to the Lamb shift.


(Here the dot on the right is the external vertex for the background electromagnetic field.)

The main contribution (often referred to as the vertex correction) is due to the radiative correction induced by the electron emitting a virtual photon, then interacting with the background electromagnetic field, and and re-absorbing the virtual photon; described by this Feynman diagram:

Feynman diagram of a one-loop electron vertex correction: two fermion lines meet a wavy internal photon line, with an external wavy photon leaving on the right and a dot marking the external vertex, labeled c.


Historically, the observation of the Lamb shift in experiment catalyzed the theoretic development of quantum electrodynamics specifically and of perturbative quantum field theory generally.
 
Attachments
  • Energy level diagram of low-lying hydrogen levels: 1S1/2 splits into F=1 and F=0 hyperfine levels 1420 MHz apart; 2S1/2 splits by 178 MHz; 2P1/2 by 59 MHz; 2P3/2 by 24 MHz; with 243 nm, 2466 THz, 1058 MHz and 9910 MHz intervals and 8173 MHz to 1S1/2 from Dirac theory.
    LambShift.png
    18.8 KB · Views: 1,231
  • Six Feynman diagrams labeled a to f, each showing electron lines and a wavy photon line meeting a dot. a and b show self-energy loops, c a vertex correction, d and e electron mass counterterms, f a photon self-energy loop. Caption lists them as higher-order graphs contributing to the Lamb shift.
    LambShiftVertexCorrections.png
    8.3 KB · Views: 1,213
  • Feynman diagram of a one-loop electron vertex correction: two fermion lines meet a wavy internal photon line, with an external wavy photon leaving on the right and a dot marking the external vertex, labeled c.
    LambShiftMainVertexCorrection.png
    988 bytes · Views: 1,025
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vanhees71, dextercioby and DrClaude