Questions about neutrinos compared to the nature of light

  • #1
961
46

Main Question or Discussion Point

First question:

Within experimental error all measurements of neutrino and light speed in vacuum are consistent with c,
but one way speed measurement of light is well proscribed,
so is a one way speed measurement of neutrinos also proscribed?

I have more questions, but maybe just clarify this one first.
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
Nugatory
Mentor
12,620
5,171
so is a one way speed measurement of neutrinos also proscribed?
There's no problem measuring the one-way speed of neutrinos or anything else (including light) if we're allowed to assume that the one-way speed of light is equal to the two-way speed.

The "proscription" against measuring the one-way speed of light is just saying that the one-way speed of light is something that we have to assume, not something that we can prove experimentally. Any experiment that purports to measure the one-way speed of light will turn out to be somehow based on this assumption.
 
  • #3
961
46
Additional questions:

Of the neutrino and light, can speed of both be measured two way, or just light?
(I'm wondering how to make a neutrino reflect or bounce back to obtain a two way path measure of speed)

Does the two way speed measure of light categorically theoretically extend to everything that moves at c?
(or does each type of thing that moves at c require an independent two way speed measure?)
 
  • #4
1,701
237
The "proscription" against measuring the one-way speed of light is just saying that the one-way speed of light is something that we have to assume, not something that we can prove experimentally. Any experiment that purports to measure the one-way speed of light will turn out to be somehow based on this assumption.
It doesn't need to be based on this assumption. It is sufficient if it is based on an equivalent assumption.
 
  • #5
jbriggs444
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
2019 Award
8,343
3,180
(I'm wondering how to make a neutrino reflect or bounce back to obtain a two way path measure of speed)
In principle, it is easy. You send a friend to stand over there with a neutrino detector and a neutrino gun. You fire a neutrino at him. When he detects it, he shoots one back. You measure the time delay between when you fired your neutrino and when you detected the one from your friend you also measure the distance to where your friend is standing. Compute two times distance over time and you have the two-way speed.
 
  • #6
961
46
The local flux is about 65 billion per square centimeter per second, so I might have trouble distinguishing which one was shot by my friend. :)

Another question:

If I label a group "c travelers" to include all particles that travel at c and their attributes with respect to c (e.g., relative speed between source and detector not effecting measured speed, no reference frame, etc.), are neutrinos categorically/theoretically "c travelers" yet?
 
  • #7
jtbell
Mentor
15,523
3,370
are neutrinos categorically/theoretically "c travelers"
No. It's well established via neutrino oscillations that neutrinos have mass. Therefore they cannot travel at exactly c.
 
  • #8
961
46
No. It's well established via neutrino oscillations that neutrinos have mass. Therefore they cannot travel at exactly c.
This suggests to me neutrino travel speed range of 0 to approaching c but all measures are consistent with c. Why no "slow" neutrinos?
 
  • #9
ZapperZ
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Education Advisor
Insights Author
35,546
4,322
This suggests to me neutrino travel speed range of 0 to approaching c but all measures are consistent with c. Why no "slow" neutrinos?
1. Because there's nothing to slow it down, since it has such a weak interaction with matter

2. You need to be coincidentally, and via very low odds, in exactly the same frame of reference to one of these neutrinos to be able to see it with speed 0.

Neutrinos may have a range of kinetic energies. However, because it has such a minuscule mass, even such a wide range of energies barely deviates significantly from being practically at ~c.

Zz.
 
  • #10
jtbell
Mentor
15,523
3,370
Also, calculate the energy of a "slow" neutrino, using whatever speed you consider to be "slow." What kind of processes might produce such "slow" neutrinos?
 

Related Threads on Questions about neutrinos compared to the nature of light

  • Last Post
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Last Post
2
Replies
25
Views
4K
Replies
6
Views
4K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
16
Views
10K
Replies
7
Views
3K
Top