Can you see a pattern in the range and time of flight of mortar shells?

  • Thread starter Lukeblackhill
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Range
In summary: I think I see what he was looking for. There seems to be a trend of longer ranges for shells fired at a slower speed, and shorter ranges for shells fired at a faster speed.
  • #1
Lukeblackhill
39
3
Poster reminded to use the standard Template for schoolwork
Morning Mates,

This problem of Berkeley Physics Course, Vol.1 - Chap. 3, says,

"Range of mortar shells. The following are experimental data on the range and muzzle velocity of mortar shells, all fired at 4.5 0 to the horizontal. The time of flight is also included. Compare these ranges and times with the simple theory. Can you see any regularity? (Data from U.S. Department of Army, Firing Tables FT4.2-F-I, December 19.54.) Use g = 32 ft/s².

Range, (yd) Muzzle velocity, (ft/s) Time (s)
1063 334 14.4
1268 368 15.7
1475 400 17.0
1683 431 18.2 ".My doubt is not much about how to do it, but about the question in bold. It sounds somewhat vague to me. What does he really want to know? If the information fits in the equations of motion for a body falling in the uniformly constant gravitational field of the earth?

Thank you for help!
Cheers,
Luke.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Lukeblackhill said:
What does he really want to know? If the information fits in the equations of motion for a body falling in the uniformly constant gravitational field of the earth?
Yes. For example, what would you calculate for the range and time of flight of a projectile fired at 45 degrees with an initial speed of 334 ft/s? How do your calculated values compare to the actual data? You might compare them by calculating the percent difference between your calculated values and the actual data values. After doing this for all four cases, do you see any regularity or trend? How do you account for it?
 
  • Like
Likes Lukeblackhill
  • #3
TSny said:
Yes. For example, what would you calculate for the range and time of flight of a projectile fired at 45 degrees with an initial speed of 334 ft/s? How do your calculated values compare to the actual data? You might compare them by calculating the percent difference between your calculated values and the actual data values. After doing this for all four cases, do you see any regularity or trend? How do you account for it?

Thank you @TSny, that was rather helpful.
 

1. What is the range of a mortar shell?

The range of a mortar shell depends on a variety of factors, including the size and weight of the shell, the angle at which it is fired, and environmental factors such as wind and altitude. Generally, the maximum range of a mortar shell can be between 2-6 kilometers.

2. How do you calculate the range of a mortar shell?

The range of a mortar shell can be calculated using mathematical formulas that take into account variables such as the initial velocity, angle of elevation, and gravitational pull. These calculations are typically done using specialized software or by trained personnel.

3. Can a mortar shell be fired accurately over long distances?

Mortar shells are designed to be fired over relatively short distances, usually within a few kilometers. While it is possible for a skilled operator to achieve some accuracy over longer distances, the further the shell travels, the more difficult it becomes to control its trajectory and hit a specific target.

4. How does the range of a mortar shell compare to other types of artillery?

The range of a mortar shell is generally shorter than that of other types of artillery, such as howitzers or cannons. This is because mortars are designed for shorter-range, high-arcing shots, while other artillery is intended for longer-range, flatter trajectories.

5. Can the range of a mortar shell be increased?

Various methods have been used to increase the range of mortar shells, such as using larger charges, modifying the design of the shell or barrel, or using specialized launch platforms. However, these methods may also affect the accuracy and effectiveness of the shell, so they must be carefully evaluated and tested before implementation.

Similar threads

  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • Engineering and Comp Sci Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
1K
Back
Top