Recargeable batteries/charger compatibility

  • Thread starter Thread starter Danger
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the compatibility of Energizer rechargeable batteries with a Duracell charger that specifies using only Duracell batteries. Users confirm that as long as the batteries share the same chemistry (NiMH), it is safe to use the Energizers in the Duracell charger, despite potential warranty issues. The charger also features a USB port intended for charging devices like mobile headsets, but it is not suitable for charging devices like cameras that lack built-in charging circuitry. Users are advised to check their device manuals for specific charging capabilities. Overall, the conversation highlights concerns about battery compatibility and the functionality of the charger’s USB port.
Danger
Gold Member
Messages
9,793
Reaction score
251
Berkeman, I figure that you'll be the first one in on this. I would have just PM'd you about it, but my box is full and the topic might be of interest to others.
With the number of things around our place that run on AA or AAA batteries, from my toy helicopter to W's... toothbrush :rolleyes:... I just shelled out about a hundred bucks for a bunch of rechargeable NiMH cells in those sizes.
When reading the package for the charger, it said that recharging times would be dependent upon the type and brand of battery. Once I got home and opened the package, the instructions inside say that I can use only Duracell batteries in the charger. That seems contradictory to the package. Since there were no Duracell rechargeables for sale other than the 4 in the charger pack, I bought Energizers to go with it. Is there any reason, other than trying to sell more Duracells, that I shouldn't use them?
Available specs are:

Charger: Duracell model CEF21/1.6 VDC 400 mA for each of 4 AA slots/1.6 VDC 175 mA for each of 4 AAA slots/5 VDC 500 mA on the USB port
Duracell Batteries: AA/HR6/DC1500 NiMH/1,2V/1700mAh
Energizer AA's: 2000 mAh
Energizer AAA's: 900 mAh

Those are the only figures that I could find, and are directly quoted from the printing (including the comma rather than period in the '1,2V' spec).

Is it safe to use the Energizers with the Duracell charger? And, by the way, what the hell is that 5V USB port for? :confused:
 
Last edited:
Engineering news on Phys.org
Danger said:
Is there any reason, other than trying to sell more Duracells, that I shouldn't use them?
Apart from the image of poor starving Duracell executives..

And, by the way, what the hell is that 5V USB port for? :confused:
Lots of stuff charges from USB (my mobile bluetooth headset) so they put a spare USB socket on the charger because it already has the regulated dv supply.
 
As long as you're using the same battery chemistry (NiMH), it'll work fine. They may have some cheap-out clause where they won't warranty the product unless you use their branded batteries, but it makes absolutely no difference.

The USB port is for charging devices (like iPods) which usually charge via a USB port. It's a convenience.

- Warren
 
Thanks, guys. I figured it would be safe, but since we don't have fire insurance on our place...
More about the USB thing, though. The only battery operated device that I own with a USB port is my camera. It draws power from the computer when uploading pictures. Does this mean that I can recharge the batteries in the camera by plugging the upload cable into the charger USB port?
 
That would depend on the camera. Most small form-factor cameras purposefully do not include built-in charging circuitry because it would make the camera larger. Instead, they put the charging circuitry into a separate wall-wart type unit separate from the camera.

Even if the camera can run using the 5V from the USB port, I'd put the odds at below 50/50 that it can actually charge its battery that way. Check your manual.

- Warren
 
The manual wouldn't cover it, Chroot. The thing just uses disposable batteries, and doesn't have it's own charger. It's a little Vivitar that I got in a package deal with a Lexmark printer (which I've never used) about 4 years ago. I'm going to start using the rechargeables in it (if I ever again see anything worth taking a picture of), so I thought that the USB might be a short-cut to loading them up. Thanks again for the info.
 
If it's intended to use disposable batteries, then it's certain that it contains no charging circuitry. After all, there are many different rechargeable battery chemistries available in the AA standard size, and each requires a different charging profile.

- Warren
 
Yeah, I'm not sure why I missed that aspect of it. Maybe I should start having just 3 or 4 beers for breakfast instead of 10... :redface:
I've got to face it... I'm a child of the 50's. I still think of Aerosmith as a new band. This tech stuff just keeps me off balance.
 
Back
Top