Reduction of Order no independent or dependent variable

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a second-order differential equation of the form y'' + (y')^2 = 6(y') - 9. Participants are exploring methods to reduce the order of the equation and manipulate it into a solvable form.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Mathematical reasoning, Problem interpretation

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants attempt to transform the original equation by substituting u = y' and rewriting the equation in terms of u. There are discussions on integrating the resulting expressions and addressing the constant of integration. Some participants express confusion about separating variables and the correct manipulation of terms.

Discussion Status

There is an ongoing exploration of different approaches to the problem. Some participants have provided guidance on correcting earlier mistakes, such as addressing typos and the omission of constants. Multiple interpretations of the steps involved are being discussed, with no clear consensus yet on the best path forward.

Contextual Notes

Participants note the challenge of the problem, with some expressing frustration over the time spent on it. There is an acknowledgment that others in class may have found a more straightforward solution.

gremmie
Messages
4
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



y'' +(y')^2 = 6(y') -9

Homework Equations


u = y'
u' = y''


The Attempt at a Solution



equation from 1 becomes

u' + U^2 = 6u - 9

du/dx + u ^2 = 6u-9

du/dx = -u^2 + 6u -9

du/dx = -(u^2 +6u - 9)

du/dx = -(u-3)^2

du/(u-3)^2 = - dx

integrate both sides

1/(u-3) = x

sub in dy/dx

1/(dy/dx -3) = x

from this point I've tried multiple ways to get dy and dx separated but I am not doing something right... thanks for the help
 
Physics news on Phys.org
gremmie said:

Homework Statement



y'' +(y')^2 = 6(y') -9

Homework Equations


u = y'
u' = y''


The Attempt at a Solution



equation from 1 becomes

u' + U^2 = 6u - 9

du/dx + u ^2 = 6u-9

du/dx = -u^2 + 6u -9

du/dx = -(u^2 +6u - 9)
Typo above. It should be -(u^2 - 6u + 9)
gremmie said:
du/dx = -(u-3)^2

du/(u-3)^2 = - dx

integrate both sides

1/(u-3) = x
You're missing the constant of integration. Also, instead of substituting dy/dx as you're doing in the next step, solve for u, then substitute.
gremmie said:
sub in dy/dx

1/(dy/dx -3) = x

from this point I've tried multiple ways to get dy and dx separated but I am not doing something right... thanks for the help
 
Ah yep sure did have a typo ...thanks ...sorry first time posting...yep i left my constant of integration off as well..

Ok so picking up where i left off but this time solving for u
1/(u-3) = x +C

1 = (u-3)(x+C)
ux+uc = 1 + 3C +3x
u(x+C) = 1+3C +3x

u = (1+3C +3x)/(x+C)
sub for u
dy/dx = (1+3C +3x)/(x+C)

dy = (1+3C +3x)/(x+C) dx

u sub u = x+c
du = dx

Integral (3u+1)/u

s sub
s = 3u+1
ds = 3du

integral s/(s-1)

integral 1 + 1/(s-1)

integral 1 +integral 1/(s-1)

p sub for 1/(s-1)

thus integral dp/p

evaluate integrals

s +lnp + C2(2nd constant of integration)

sub back

s + ln(s-1) +C2

3u + 1 +ln(3u+1-1) +C2
3u + 1 +ln(3u) +C2

3(x+C) +1 +ln(3x +3C) +C2
so
y= 3x + 3C +1 +ln(3x+ 3C) +C2

the answer listed is : y = 3x +ln(x+C) +C2
So i see that I am on the right track ... but I am still missing something again .. thanks
 
gremmie said:
Ah yep sure did have a typo ...thanks ...sorry first time posting...yep i left my constant of integration off as well..

Ok so picking up where i left off but this time solving for u
1/(u-3) = x +C

1 = (u-3)(x+C)
ux+uc = 1 + 3C +3x
u(x+C) = 1+3C +3x
You sure took the long way around. Starting from your first equation,
1/(u-3) = x +C
==> u - 3 = 1/(x + C)
==> u = 3 + 1/(x + C)

Undoing the substitution,
dy/dx = 3 + 1/(x + C)
==> dy = [3 + 1/(x + C)]dx
==> y = 3x + ln|x + C| + D

gremmie said:
u = (1+3C +3x)/(x+C)
sub for u
dy/dx = (1+3C +3x)/(x+C)

dy = (1+3C +3x)/(x+C) dx

u sub u = x+c
du = dx

Integral (3u+1)/u

s sub
s = 3u+1
ds = 3du

integral s/(s-1)

integral 1 + 1/(s-1)

integral 1 +integral 1/(s-1)

p sub for 1/(s-1)

thus integral dp/p

evaluate integrals

s +lnp + C2(2nd constant of integration)

sub back

s + ln(s-1) +C2

3u + 1 +ln(3u+1-1) +C2
3u + 1 +ln(3u) +C2

3(x+C) +1 +ln(3x +3C) +C2
so
y= 3x + 3C +1 +ln(3x+ 3C) +C2

the answer listed is : y = 3x +ln(x+C) +C2
So i see that I am on the right track ... but I am still missing something again .. thanks

[/quote]
 
ah man i sure did... Well thanks for your help! I knew there had to be an easier way! everyone in class got this problem done in class an I've been messing with it for about 2 weeks! Again, Thank You.
 

Similar threads

Replies
19
Views
3K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
21
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 18 ·
Replies
18
Views
3K