Rotational Motion Clarification

[Moose352]

I got a little confused thinking about this. Consider a ball attatched to a (massless) rod. This system is to be accelerate about the free end of the rod. From what I know, the moment of inertia for this system would simply be the mr^2, since this is the same case as a free ball being accelerated at the same rate. However, it seems to me that the ball is also rotating around its own axis (since it is fixed on the rod), and thus wouldn't the force necessary for the same rate of acceleration be greater?

 

[Moose352]

Is this question too dumb for anyone to even answer?

 

[Doc Al]

Originally posted by Moose352
Is this question too dumb for anyone to even answer?

No, it's an excellent question.

Originally posted by Moose352
However, it seems to me that the ball is also rotating around its own axis (since it is fixed on the rod), and thus wouldn't the force necessary for the same rate of acceleration be greater?

I would say that the answer is yes. Using I = mL² (L is length of stick) is just an approximation: it assumes the radius of the ball can be neglected.

A more realistic value for rotational inertia must include that of the ball as well:

I = I_{ball} + mL^2 = \frac{2}{5}mR^2 + mL^2

 

[Moose352]

Thanks Doc. My physics instructor (and the book) was saying otherwise and wouldn't concede to my view.