Seeking the truth behind existence of charge: An Intricasy

[Neelesh]

According to Klein Kaluza theory of fifth dimension (followed by string theory),
there is an elecromagnetic dimension in which every particle of Universe (in Dirac Vacuum) perform translatory and rotational motion due to which they drag the e-m dimension. Thus if any two particles are placed quite distance apart due to spinning of both, they attract or repel each other depending on their spinning. If they've spins in same direction they repel each other and vice versa which is nothing but we can say it as charge.

 

[shanu_bhaiya]

I don't think so:

1. If, spin is the reason of the "real charge", then why neutrinos don't have charge even they've spin.

2. Photons also have spin but noc harge and also have a sinusoidally varying e-m field.

3. Charge is not a relative quantity. Consider a condition- a light particle(A) is
revolving around a heavy particle(B), B has a spin and same angular velocity
as that of revolution of A. Now, from the respective of A, B isn't spinning,
does it mean that from respective of A there's no chargeon B?

 

[Entropia]

it is important to approach theories and ideas with a critical and analytical mindset. While the Klein Kaluza theory and string theory may offer interesting explanations for the existence of charge, it is important to note that these are still just theories and have not been definitively proven.

It is also important to consider the limitations of these theories and the need for further evidence and experimentation to fully understand the intricacies of charge. While the concept of an electromagnetic dimension and the role of particle spinning may provide a plausible explanation, it is important to continue exploring and testing these ideas in order to gain a deeper understanding of the truth behind the existence of charge.

In addition, it is important to acknowledge that there may be other factors at play in the phenomenon of charge, and that the concept of charge itself may continue to evolve and be better understood as we continue to advance in our scientific knowledge and understanding. Therefore, while the Klein Kaluza theory and string theory offer interesting perspectives, it is important to approach them with an open and critical mind and continue to seek further evidence and experimentation to truly uncover the truth behind the existence of charge.