Should Inmates Be Given Internet Access?

  • Thread starter Thread starter eNtRopY
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Internet
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on whether inmates should be granted internet access. Participants largely oppose the idea, arguing that inmates should not have such privileges as it could distract them from reflecting on their actions and potentially lead to harmful behavior. Some suggest that if internet access were allowed, it should be restricted to educational content to help inmates reintegrate into society. Others express concerns about security risks, such as inmates misusing the internet or hacking systems. There is also a sentiment that prisons should not resemble holiday camps, emphasizing that incarceration is a punishment. Suggestions for alternative rehabilitation methods include educational programs and physical labor, with some humorously proposing extreme measures like using inmates to generate electricity. Overall, the consensus leans towards denying internet access to maintain the integrity of the prison system.

Should inmates be given internet access?

  • Yes

    Votes: 1 25.0%
  • No

    Votes: 3 75.0%

  • Total voters
    4
eNtRopY
[SOLVED] Should Inmates Be Given Internet Access?

I think Mr. Robin Parsons has already answered this question for us.

eNtRopY
 
Physics news on Phys.org
i think they should earn it...just like everyone else, they earn it as well...
 
I don't think that they could be trusted with the internet. Too quick to monitor information.
 
Greetings !

The whole point is that people spend time with themselves
and think of their actions and how long they've got to indure
this boredom and lack of freedom more. If they have access to the
Internet they'll be distracted from this important aspect
and they could potentialy cause more harm directly or through
causing others to do it as well as prepare to do so once they
can get out.

In conclusion - NO !

Live long and prosper.
 
the idea of being inside is that you are kept out of society, so no. but if i was an inmate i would say yes, obviously.
 
Good post Entropy, i voted no because they don't deserve it.
 
Depends on what they want to use it for...don't we want criminals to come out more informed than they were when they went it, so maybe they can contribute to society?
 
Ok but maybe the use of the internet should be limited so that they can only view educational websites.
 
Originally posted by Andy
Ok but maybe the use of the internet should be limited so that they can only view educational websites.

Yes, I agree, and also they should only be allowed to eat American potato salad only German potato salad... and non-alcholic beer.

eNtRopY
 
  • #10
They get steak dinners in minimum security prisons so my answer is NO! Thats all i need is a too bit hacker inmate crashing my system.
Anyways...I believe they should be subjected to education (Nothing about legal) and tortured with positive reinforcement (ie., classical music, arts and crafts without the weapons, basically anything that will refine them back to society). Oh yeah, I think they should repay back to society what they took this is why I believe in the chain gang system. Break the law and pay for it. An eye for an eye!
PEACE OUT!
Dx
 
  • #11
Originally posted by Dx
Oh yeah, I think they should repay back to society what they took this is why I believe in the chain gang system. Break the law and pay for it. An eye for an eye!
PEACE OUT!
Dx

That's a damn good idea! But let's solve the energy crisis while we're at it. Let's make inmates ride exercise bikes connected to electrical generators all day long.

So much for Cruel and Unusual Punishment laws.

eNtRopY
 
  • #12
Prisoners shouldn't be allowed any such luxuries.

They went to prison because they committed a crime. They deserve to be in prison!

Too many prisons (in this country at least) are literally holiday camps. I should think the prisoners have a good relaxing time most days. Which obviously isn't the point.
 
  • #13
Originally posted by eNtRopY
That's a damn good idea! But let's solve the energy crisis while we're at it. Let's make inmates ride exercise bikes connected to electrical generators all day long.
Hey ! That's a great idea ! Seriously ! :smile:
Of course, "normal" people, as ussual, will probably say it's
unethical - fools !
 
  • #14
Besides, think of all the tax-payers' money that will
be required to do this. :wink:
 
  • #15
Originally posted by drag
Hey ! That's a great idea ! Seriously ! :smile:
Of course, "normal" people, as ussual, will probably say it's
unethical - fools !

Actually, there's a fundamental techical problem with this solution. It's difficult to couple such an incoherent power source to the grid. You mostly get reflection off the transmission line since there is no single frequency to use for matching. There is currently research underway to figure out how make cheap, power efficient, solid-state switches that could be used for converting irregular power to single frequency AC power. The hope is that such an invention will allow us to better harness natural irregular energy sources like wind.

eNtRopY
 
  • #16
Originally posted by eNtRopY
That's a damn good idea! But let's solve the energy crisis while we're at it. Let's make inmates ride exercise bikes connected to electrical generators all day long.

Why not burn the inmates in a large furnace?
 

Similar threads

Back
Top