Should we have the right to kill animals?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sassenav22
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the ethical implications of humans killing animals simply because they dislike them. Participants explore the concept of 'rights,' noting that they are a human construct, often defined by societal norms and laws. While some argue against unnecessary killing, such as trophy hunting, others emphasize that individuals may act without societal interference. The conversation highlights that most people do not kill animals merely out of dislike, with common justifications for killing including food, disease control, or nuisance management. The dialogue also touches on deeper psychological motivations behind violence, drawing parallels between animal and human rights. A reference is made to Bernard Rollin's book on animal rights, which argues that animals deserve moral consideration and should not be treated merely as means to human ends. The discussion concludes with the legal aspects of killing animals, noting that certain animals can be hunted legally with a license, primarily for sport or sustenance.
Sassenav22
Messages
29
Reaction score
0
My teacher asked me an interesting question.

Do we as human have the right to kill animals just because we don't like them?


what do you think?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
'Rights' are a human concept. People have them only because some of our governments say so. I don't personally believe in unnecessary killing, such as trophy hunting, but it's not my place to say whether or not someone else can. Without societal interference, someone can do absolutely whatever s/he wants to.
 
note: moved to Philosophy from Biology forum.
 
Well ... we have the 'right' to protect them as well.
Depends on the individual's opinion.
 
Why do you say we don't like them? I certainly enjoy a good steak!
 
Sassenav22 said:
My teacher asked me an interesting question.

Do we as human have the right to kill animals just because we don't like them?what do you think?

The thing is, the great majority of humans just don't do this. There are a great number of reasons for killing animals (for food, disease control, because they are nuisances, etc), but "just because we don't like them" is not one that is seen very often. Even a psychopath who kills and tortures animals might have reasons other than hatred of them, such as the pleasure derived from power over something weaker.

The most common examples I can bring to mind of humans killing animals "just because they don't like them" are instances of humans killing other humans. Bigotry and homophobia come to mind. But scratch the surface and you might find even deeper reasons (however illogical) that are the rationale for this violence. You can think over for yourself all the reasons someone of a particular race, sexual orientation, [insert group membership here] might be perceived as a threat by someone who is not a member of that group.

I am reading an interesting book right now on "animal rights and human morality" by Bernard Rollin. If you want to dig into that topic, it is an excellent and clear read. What he argues regarding animal rights is that the single, logically defensable right that they have is to be "objects of moral concern" by those capable of making moral decisions. In other words, they have the right for some careful thought and decision about their treatment and should not be cavalierly used as "means to an end" to suit our purposes.
 
Last edited:
Well, that all depends upon your definition of "animal". Is an insect an animal? If not, then yes you have the "right" to kill them. Killing pretty much anything else will get you thrown in jail for cruelty... even your own dog if the right people find out about it. As far as hunting goes, you can buy the right to kill CERTAIN animals by buying a license. This is mostly for sport and food, though.
 

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
136
Views
9K
Replies
13
Views
6K
Replies
24
Views
2K
Replies
13
Views
2K
Replies
69
Views
5K
Back
Top