Show that P, Q and D are collinear in the vector problem

  • Thread starter chwala
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Vector
8 replies · 2K views · last reply
chwala
Gold Member
Messages
2,854
Reaction score
436
Homework Statement
See attached
Relevant Equations
Vectors
Geometry figure of triangle OAB with O at bottom left, A at top, B on a horizontal line; P lies on OA, Q lies on AB, and the line OB extends to D beyond B.


My interest is only on part (b),

For part (i), My approach is as follows,
##PB=PO+OB##
##PB=-\dfrac{2}{5}a +b##

##AD=AO+OD##
##AD=-a+\dfrac{5}{2}b##

Therefore, ##PB=\dfrac{2}{5}AD##

For part (ii), we shall have;

##QD=QB+BD##

##QD=\dfrac{2}{7}AB+\dfrac{3}{2}b##

##QD=-\dfrac{2}{7}a+\dfrac{2}{7}b+\dfrac{3}{2}b##

##QD=\dfrac{25}{14}b-\dfrac{2}{7}a##

also,
##PQ=PA+AQ##

##PQ=\dfrac{3}{5}a-\dfrac{5}{7}a+\dfrac{5}{7}b##

##PQ=\dfrac{5}{7}b-\dfrac{4}{35}a##

Therefore,

##PQ=\dfrac{1}{7}\left[5b-\dfrac{4}{5}a\right]##
&
##QD=\dfrac{1}{7}\left[\dfrac{25}{2}b-2a\right]##

It follows that,

##PQ=\dfrac{5}{7}\left[25b-4a\right]##

##QD=\dfrac{2}{7}\left[25b-4a\right]##

##OQ=\dfrac{2}{5} PQ## thus shown as there is a scalar connecting the two...seeking any alternative approach and i hope my working is correct as i do not have solutions to these questions...
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Delta2
for (b) (i) I find it correct
for (b) (ii) there seem to be some typos after the phrase "It follows that" please correct them. For example I think it should $$\vec{PQ}=\frac{1}{5\cdot 7}[25\vec{b}-4\vec{a}]$$ and the final equation should involve PQ and QD not OQ(?)
 
Last edited:
Delta2 said:
for (b) (i) I find it correct
for (b) (ii) there seem to be some typos after the phrase "It follows that" please correct them. For example I think it should $$\vec{PQ}=\frac{1}{5\cdot 7}[25b-4a]$$ and the final equation should involve PQ and QD not OQ(?)
Ok...I will check on that ...
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Delta2
The correct final equation should be ##\vec{PQ}=\frac{2}{5}\vec{QD}##, at least that's what i think.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: chwala
Delta2 said:
The correct final equation should be ##\vec{PQ}=\frac{2}{5}\vec{QD}##, at least that's what i think.
That should be correct...my working is fine, but the division part at the end was wrong...
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Delta2
chwala said:
Homework Statement:: See attached
Relevant Equations:: Vectors

View attachment 301993

My interest is only on part (b),

For part (i), My approach is as follows,
##PB=PO+OB##
##PB=-\dfrac{2}{5}a +b##

##AD=AO+OD##
##AD=-a+\dfrac{5}{2}b##

Therefore, ##PB=\dfrac{2}{5}AD##

For part (ii), we shall have;

##QD=QB+BD##

##QD=\dfrac{2}{7}AB+\dfrac{3}{2}b##

##QD=-\dfrac{2}{7}a+\dfrac{2}{7}b+\dfrac{3}{2}b##

##QD=\dfrac{25}{14}b-\dfrac{2}{7}a##

also,
##PQ=PA+AQ##

##PQ=\dfrac{3}{5}a-\dfrac{5}{7}a+\dfrac{5}{7}b##

##PQ=\dfrac{5}{7}b-\dfrac{4}{35}a##

Therefore,

##PQ=\dfrac{1}{7}\left[5b-\dfrac{4}{5}a\right]##
&
##QD=\dfrac{1}{7}\left[\dfrac{25}{2}b-2a\right]##

It follows that,

##PQ=\dfrac{5}{7}\left[25b-4a\right]##

##QD=\dfrac{2}{7}\left[25b-4a\right]##

##QD=\dfrac{2}{5} PQ## thus shown as there is a scalar connecting the two...seeking any alternative approach and i hope my working is correct as i do not have solutions to these questions...
Amended to ##QD##...I will amend division part later, using my android to type...
 
I find the expressions of PQ and QD wrong after the phrase "It follows that" regarding the multiplicative constant of each, please review and try to correct them.
 
Delta2 said:
I find the expressions of PQ and QD wrong after the phrase "It follows that" regarding the multiplicative constant of each, please review and try to correct them.
Yes I will...thanks for your input...
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Delta2
chwala said:
Homework Statement:: See attached
Relevant Equations:: Vectors

View attachment 301993

My interest is only on part (b),

For part (i), My approach is as follows,
##PB=PO+OB##
##PB=-\dfrac{2}{5}a +b##

##AD=AO+OD##
##AD=-a+\dfrac{5}{2}b##

Therefore, ##PB=\dfrac{2}{5}AD##

For part (ii), we shall have;

##QD=QB+BD##

##QD=\dfrac{2}{7}AB+\dfrac{3}{2}b##

##QD=-\dfrac{2}{7}a+\dfrac{2}{7}b+\dfrac{3}{2}b##

##QD=\dfrac{25}{14}b-\dfrac{2}{7}a##

also,
##PQ=PA+AQ##

##PQ=\dfrac{3}{5}a-\dfrac{5}{7}a+\dfrac{5}{7}b##

##PQ=\dfrac{5}{7}b-\dfrac{4}{35}a##

Therefore,

##PQ=\dfrac{1}{7}\left[5b-\dfrac{4}{5}a\right]##
&
##QD=\dfrac{1}{7}\left[\dfrac{25}{2}b-2a\right]##

It follows that,

##PQ=\dfrac{5}{7}\left[25b-4a\right]##

##QD=\dfrac{2}{7}\left[25b-4a\right]##

##OQ=\dfrac{2}{5} PQ## thus shown as there is a scalar connecting the two...seeking any alternative approach and i hope my working is correct as i do not have solutions to these questions...
We ought to have;

It follows that,

##PQ=\dfrac{1}{35}\left[25b-4a\right]##

##QD=\dfrac{1}{14}\left[25b-4a\right]##

##35 PQ=(25b-4a)##
##14QD=(25b-4a)##

##35PQ=14QD##
##PQ=\dfrac{14}{35} QD##
##PQ=\dfrac{2}{5} QD##
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Delta2