Simply Supported Beam Homework Clarification

  • Thread starter tsukuba
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Beam
In summary, the conversation is about a homework question involving calculating deflection using the center deflection formula. The question states "19 inches from one end" and the person is unsure if they used the correct formula. They mention using the maximum deflection formula and having trouble understanding the "deflection at anysection in terms of x" formula. They ask for clarification on how to determine the values for x and b in the formula. The expert clarifies that they should refer to the diagram attached to the formula and use the longer distance for b. The conversation ends with the person stating their final answer.
  • #1
47
0

Homework Statement


Hello, I did the question but would like for someone to clarify if its right. The question states " 19 inches from one end" but I used the center deflection formula and I am not sure if its right.
It is question 2 of the picture
IMG_20141210_09375_edit_1418222343023.jpg


Homework Equations


equation is in the picture

The Attempt at a Solution


My solution is in the picture
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
tsukuba said:

Homework Statement


Hello, I did the question but would like for someone to clarify if its right. The question states " 19 inches from one end" but I used the center deflection formula and I am not sure if its right.
It is question 2 of the picture
IMG_20141210_09375_edit_1418222343023.jpg


Homework Equations


equation is in the picture

The Attempt at a Solution


My solution is in the picture

Unless 19 inches is half of 6 feet 4 inches, no, you did not use the correct formula to calculate the deflection of this beam. Why did you think they put that box with a different beam formula right under the title of the problem?
 
  • #3
I thought so, since I used the maximum deflection one. I am having a little trouble understand the formulas for "deflection at anysection in terms of x"
I think I am supposed to use y = Pbx / 6LEI ( L2-x2-b2 but I am not sure weather x is 19 and b is 57 or
x is 57 and b is 19
How would I know this?
 
  • #4
tsukuba said:
I thought so, since I used the maximum deflection one. I am having a little trouble understand the formulas for "deflection at anysection in terms of x"
I think I am supposed to use y = Pbx / 6LEI ( L2-x2-b2 but I am not sure weather x is 19 and b is 57 or
x is 57 and b is 19
How would I know this?

Look at the diagram attached to the formula. That should tell you what to use for a and what to use for b. Notice that one distance is longer than the other.
 
  • #5
okay, so If you look at the picture I used the first formula of the middle column where 0<x<a
I made b = 19 and from the formula to calculate x I got 42.5
My final answer is 2.289 lbs
 

Suggested for: Simply Supported Beam Homework Clarification

Replies
2
Views
759
Replies
0
Views
612
Replies
32
Views
526
Replies
11
Views
3K
Replies
6
Views
850
Replies
3
Views
778
Replies
6
Views
1K
Back
Top