Can Arcsin(i2x) be Simplified to iArcsin(2x)?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Gunni
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the simplification of Arcsin(i2x) to iArcsin(2x) in the context of deriving a formula for the length of a parabola. Participants clarify that sin(ix) equals i*sinh(x), not i*sin(x), indicating that the proposed simplification does not hold. The conversation also touches on the formula for arc length in calculus, which involves integrating the square root of the sum of the derivatives. One user expresses frustration at the complexity of the problem and acknowledges the teacher's initial assessment. Ultimately, the participants agree that the simplification is incorrect and explore alternative methods for calculating the arc length of a parabola.
Gunni
Messages
39
Reaction score
0
Quick question.

sin(-x) = -sin(x)

this can be seen as this example:

sin(i^2x) = i^2sin(x)

Does this then apply?

sin(ix) = isin(x) ?

I'm trying to derive a formula for the length of a simple parabola. Unfortunetly in my calculations I end up with Arcsin(i2x) along the way and it would make my life a lot simpler if that could be treated as iArcsin(2x). Then the i would be divided out and then I'd get a real number instead of a complex number.

It's sort of a dare, I'm taking the calculus course where we learn about complex numbers but I read the book during the christmas vacation so I've got most of the basics down. Right now we're learning about the length of functions and we asked if our teacher would give us an example using a parabola of the form Ax^2 + C, but she said it was too complex. Of course, once she says that we spend the rest of the week trying to do it by ourselfes. :wink:

Thanks a lot.
 
Last edited:
Mathematics news on Phys.org
Try plugging ix into the definition of the sin function (e^ix-e^(-ix))/2i. You'll find that you get sin(ix) = i*sinh(x) not i*sin(x).
 
Isn't that the definition of the sinh function? I always thought sin was defined as a/c in a triangle with one 90° corner.
 
Originally posted by Gunni
Quick question.

sin(-x) = -sin(x)

this can be seen as this example:

sin(i^2x) = i^2sin(x)

Does this then apply?

sin(ix) = isin(x) ?

absolutely not

I'm trying to derive a formula for the length of a simple parabola. Unfortunetly in my calculations I end up with Arcsin(i2x) along the way and it would make my life a lot simpler if that could be treated as iArcsin(2x). Then the i would be divided out and then I'd get a real number instead of a complex number.

It's sort of a dare, I'm taking the calculus course where we learn about complex numbers but I read the book during the christmas vacation so I've got most of the basics down. Right now we're learning about the length of functions and we asked if our teacher would give us an example using a parabola of the form Ax^2 + C, but she said it was too complex. Of course, once she says that we spend the rest of the week trying to do it by ourselfes. :wink:

Thanks a lot

What;s the length of a function?
 
L = \int_{a}^{b}\sqrt(1 + (f'(x))^2)dx

Anyway, thanks guys. Too bad that doesn't apply, seems the damn teacher was right. :smile:
 


Originally posted by matt grime

What;s the length of a function?

Since this is calculus I would guess that he's talking about the arclength. In complex analysis it's more likely to be a line integral.

Of course, the arc length of a parabola is IIRC not so bad except for the tricky integral:

\int_a^b \sqrt{\frac{dy}{dx}^2+1}dx
so
\int_a^b \sqrt{4x^2+1} dx
which leads to the naive substitution
x(u)=\frac{i\sin(u)}{2}
so
\int_a^b cos(u) dx
but it needs to be inverted to get the correct limits of integration:
\int_{-\sin^{-1}(2ia)}^{-\sin^{-1}{2ib}}<br /> (1+\frac{i}{2}) \cos(u) du
(1+\frac{i}{2}) |_{-\sin^{-1}(2ia)}^{-\sin^{-1}{2ib}} -sin u
so
(1+\frac{i}{2})(2b-2a)i
resulting in the arc length:
(a-b)+i2(b-a)

Unfortunately this is a less than ideal result. Perhaps he should try the substitution:
x=\frac{1}{2}\tan(u)
instead.
 
Last edited:
Originally posted by Gunni
L = \int_{a}^{b}\sqrt(1 + (f&#039;(x))^2)dx

Anyway, thanks guys. Too bad that doesn't apply, seems the damn teacher was right. :smile:

that isn't the 'length of a function'. it is the arc length. is your teacher really talking about lengths of functions?


as nate points out it is realtively easily to find in the case of a parabola.
 
I'm sorry, I'm from Iceland and math is tought in icelandic, so I don't know all the english names for functions.

I'll look over what NateG posted tomorrow (kind of late here at GMT), since I've run into trouble deriving it myself the least I can do is learn how to do it properly. Thanks guys.
 
Back
Top