Small sphere or cylinder filled by a solvent

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the creation of a small glass sphere or closed cylinder filled with solvents like acetone or methanol, focusing on methods to avoid air bubbles and achieve a diameter of 2-4 mm. The conversation touches on practical techniques, safety concerns, and potential applications in NMR experiments.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Experimental/applied

Main Points Raised

  • One participant suggests hiring a professional glass-blower and using glass tubing and plates for construction.
  • Another participant expresses concerns about the compatibility of glass blowing with flammable solvents like acetone.
  • There are discussions about using liquid nitrogen to reduce solvent evaporation, but some participants warn that this could lead to dangerous explosions.
  • A participant with extensive experience in working with liquid nitrogen and helium discusses the risks of using nitrogen in this context.
  • Some participants propose using a hollow thin bore capillary needle for injecting acetone into the glass, discussing methods for sealing without air bubbles.
  • Concerns are raised about the decomposition of acetone at glass melting temperatures and the need for an inert gas medium during welding.
  • There are suggestions to consider alternative materials, such as fluoropolymer, for sealing the cylinder.
  • One participant mentions the potential for using SQUID technology instead of traditional methods for cooling and measuring.
  • A participant reports having created a prototype cylinder in PVC and plans to test its sealing capabilities.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a range of views on the feasibility and safety of using glass blowing techniques with flammable solvents, with some advocating for caution and others exploring various methods. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the best approach to safely create the desired glass structures.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight various assumptions about the properties of solvents, the risks associated with their use, and the technical challenges of creating small glass objects. There are also unresolved questions about the effectiveness of proposed methods and materials.

_maxim_
Messages
105
Reaction score
6
how can I create a spheric glass ball or a closed cylinder containing a solvent as acetone or methanol?
the ideal would be without air bubble inside and diameter in the range of 2-4 mm

thanx
max
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Engineering news on Phys.org
Maybe you could get a professional glass-blower to do it for you. Your liquid could be used instead of air in the blowpipe (if it doesn't catch on fire or evaporate so violently that it blasts the molten glass to pieces).

edit: Well, now that you've edited your question to include a cylinder as well as a sphere, there's nothing to it. Just buy some glass tubing, and some plate glass, then cut disks out of the plates to glue onto the ends of the tube.
 
Last edited:
thank you for your reply.

I surely have no experience in blowing / soldering small glass objects.
can you address me where to buy such glass pipe or cylinders, or where I can learn how to do that?
the solvent could be flammable or explosive so it could be necessary to reduce its evaporation by freezing into liquid nitrogen, but this is another history..

thanks in advance
max
 
maxim said:
it could be necessary to reduce its evaporation by freezing into liquid nitrogen

NO!
That's just inviting an explosion.
Let's back up a bit here. How old are you and what is your level of education? This is starting to seem dangerous.
 
Glass blowing and acetone seem a tad incompatible.
 
rollingstein said:
Glass blowing and acetone seem a tad incompatible.
I had my doubts about it as well, but figured that it might be possible if the glob is being formed in the wet newspaper as opposed to in the flame.
 
Danger said:
NO!
That's just inviting an explosion.
Let's back up a bit here. How old are you and what is your level of education? This is starting to seem dangerous.


I am 45 y old and I am working with liquid nitrogen and helium (-270 K) from 20 years to do maintenance of superconductive magnets.
 
maxim said:
I am 45 y old and I am working with liquid nitrogen and helium (-270 K) from 20 years to do maintenance of superconductive magnets.

So do you plan to store these balls in liquid nitrogen until you're ready to use them? If you form them under those conditions, they will pretty much explode once they warm up.
 
Last edited:
the idea was slowly filling the cilinder with acetone and refrigering the glass by using liquid nitrogen as external container; this is what one can do when a glass tube containing i.e. methanol has to be sealed for NMR experiments. The point here are the small dimensions... Today I will check with the phisical department if they can realize a small cyinder using PEK polymer.
 
  • #10
Okay. Well then... check around with your colleagues as to feasibility. I very well could be wrong, but my gut feeling is that nitrogen is a bad idea.
 
  • #11
maxim said:
the idea was slowly filling the cilinder with acetone and refrigering the glass by using liquid nitrogen as external container; this is what one can do when a glass tube containing i.e. methanol has to be sealed for NMR experiments. The point here are the small dimensions... Today I will check with the phisical department if they can realize a small cyinder using PEK polymer.

But, what is general idea? To do NMR experiments with various solutions? I would use long silica or ftorpolymer tube, connected to the pump and source of substances at one side. It would be cheaper for a set of experiments.
 
  • #12
Graniar said:
But, what is general idea? To do NMR experiments with various solutions?

Experiments? :confused:

I thought he was making party favours. :frown:
 
  • #13
Graniar said:
But, what is general idea? To do NMR experiments with various solutions? I would use long silica or ftorpolymer tube, connected to the pump and source of substances at one side. It would be cheaper for a set of experiments.

Yes, the idea is generally related to NMR applications. In particolar I am looking for a way to improve the field stability in home-built probeheads for custom measures. I have to design a RF circuit around the small cylinder containing a non-viscous deuterated solvent as Acetone-d6
 
  • #14
maxim said:
Yes, the idea is generally related to NMR applications. In particolar I am looking for a way to improve the field stability in home-built probeheads for custom measures. I have to design a RF circuit around the small cylinder containing a non-viscous deuterated solvent as Acetone-d6

How about using a hollow thin bore cappilary needle to inject in pre-degassed acetone? The needle can easily be embedded in by the glassblower. Then either snap off the needle and seal off the exposed end by heat / electric arc etc. That should be an instantaneous weld for such a thin bore. That is if you are ok with the leftover needle segment.

If not, post injection heat the needle segment externally and as soon as local glass melting occurs draw it out gently. Not easy.

With 3mm sized spheres the fire risk is pretty small.
 
  • #15
rollingstein said:
How about using a hollow thin bore cappilary needle to inject in pre-degassed acetone? The needle can easily be embedded in by the glassblower. Then either snap off the needle and seal off the exposed end by heat / electric arc etc. That should be an instantaneous weld for such a thin bore. That is if you are ok with the leftover needle segment.

If not, post injection heat the needle segment externally and as soon as local glass melting occurs draw it out gently. Not easy.

With 3mm sized spheres the fire risk is pretty small.

It sounds interesting. But I do not think I have fully understood the steps to fill a capillary tube and weld the two ends without creating air bubbles...

You have already successfully tested the method?

Is there something to view/read on internet?
 
  • #16
maxim said:
It sounds interesting. But I do not think I have fully understood the steps to fill a capillary tube and weld the two ends without creating air bubbles...

You have already successfully tested the method?

Is there something to view/read on internet?

Not at all. I was brainstorming.

It might be a total dud for all I know.
 
  • #17
maxim said:
Yes, the idea is generally related to NMR applications. In particolar I am looking for a way to improve the field stability in home-built probeheads for custom measures. I have to design a RF circuit around the small cylinder containing a non-viscous deuterated solvent as Acetone-d6

1. At the temperature of glass melting acetone will decompose. So, if you need to weld glass or especially bore capillary, you will need some gas medium, ie Ar.
Or use some other shell material, in example ftorpolymer analogue of epoxy resin. To form acetone bubbles in the non-cured resin.

2. solving probe substance in polar solvents like acetone may significantly widen spectrum via shifting energy levels.
May be better to use pure gas to reduce intermolecular interaction?

3. If those probeheads will be anyway cooled by liquid nitrogen, why not use SQUID instead?
 
Last edited:
  • #18
Graniar said:
1. At the temperature of glass melting acetone will decompose. So, if you need to weld glass or especially bore capillary, you will need some gas medium, ie Ar.
Or use some other shell material, in example ftorpolymer analogue of epoxy resin. To form acetone bubbles in the non-cured resin.

That's why I thought to use liquid nitrogen to cool down the cylinder containing the Acetone when the glass has to be sealed.

2. solving probe substance in polar solvents like acetone may significantly widen spectrum via shifting energy levels.
May be better to use pure gas to reduce intermolecular interaction?

In the cylinder there are no other mixed solutions/samples other than Acetone-d6, the source of deuterium for the 2H detector.

3. If those probeheads will be anyway cooled by liquid nitrogen, why not use SQUID instead?

The probes will work at room temperature and will use dry air rather than liquid N2.
 
  • #19
Today I have got a first prototype of such a cylinder in made PVC.
Going to test the sealing...
 

Similar threads

Replies
0
Views
2K
  • · Replies 24 ·
Replies
24
Views
4K
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 24 ·
Replies
24
Views
4K
Replies
7
Views
4K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
4K
  • · Replies 45 ·
2
Replies
45
Views
7K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 52 ·
2
Replies
52
Views
8K