quZz
- 123
- 1
Hi everyone,
I don't fully understand what is the regular method to state and solve problems in GR when no handy hints like spherical symmetry or homogeneity of time are assumed. If I find myself in arbitrary reference frame with coordinates x^0, x^1, x^2, x^3 the meaning of which is unknown beforehand (or known only locally), how do I proceed with boundary conditions and stress-energy tensor?
Consider the following simple problem: two point masses m_1, m_2 are separated by distance a. Obviously T_{\mu\nu} is a sum of two delta functions. Suppose the first mass is at the origin but where then is the second mass? Should I write \delta(x^1 - a) or \delta(\sqrt{(x^1)^2 + x^1 x^2} - a) or ...? You may say - OK, choose the coordinates in such a way that \delta(x^1 - a) would be valid. But there are only 4 possible coordinate transformations, what if I had thousands of point masses?
So it seems that in general a statement of a problem in GR is interconnected with its very solution, which is confusing: are all problems solvable? uniquely? what would a "real mccoy" equation look like?
I don't fully understand what is the regular method to state and solve problems in GR when no handy hints like spherical symmetry or homogeneity of time are assumed. If I find myself in arbitrary reference frame with coordinates x^0, x^1, x^2, x^3 the meaning of which is unknown beforehand (or known only locally), how do I proceed with boundary conditions and stress-energy tensor?
Consider the following simple problem: two point masses m_1, m_2 are separated by distance a. Obviously T_{\mu\nu} is a sum of two delta functions. Suppose the first mass is at the origin but where then is the second mass? Should I write \delta(x^1 - a) or \delta(\sqrt{(x^1)^2 + x^1 x^2} - a) or ...? You may say - OK, choose the coordinates in such a way that \delta(x^1 - a) would be valid. But there are only 4 possible coordinate transformations, what if I had thousands of point masses?
So it seems that in general a statement of a problem in GR is interconnected with its very solution, which is confusing: are all problems solvable? uniquely? what would a "real mccoy" equation look like?