Solve Logarithmic Equation: log9 (p) = log12 (q) = log16 (p+q)

  • Thread starter Thread starter JanClaesen
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Logarithmic
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around solving the logarithmic equation log9(p) = log12(q) = log16(p + q) and determining the ratio q/p. Participants explore the equation 9^x + 12^x = 16^x, leading to the relationship (4/3)^x = q/p. Various methods are suggested to solve the quadratic equation derived from the logarithmic relationships, with some participants expressing confusion about the steps involved. Ultimately, it is concluded that q/p can be expressed as (1/2)(1 + √5), and the discussion highlights the importance of understanding logarithmic properties in finding solutions. The conversation emphasizes the complexity of logarithmic equations and the need for clarity in mathematical communication.
JanClaesen
Messages
56
Reaction score
0
log9 (p) = log12 (q) = log16 (p+q)
What is q/p?

9^x + 12^x = 16^x
calculate x
(4/3)^x = q/p

I guess that would work if I'd know how to solve that equation (without using a calculator), unfortunately I don't...

3^(2x)+4^x*3^x = 4^2x
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
JanClaesen said:
3^(2x)+4^x*3^x = 4^2x

Divide by 4^x 3^x ... Can you solve a + 1 = 1/a ?
 
Thanks! :-)

(4/3)^-x + 1 = (4/3)^x

substitute (4/3)^x by y

y^-1 + 1 = y^1

multiply by y

1 + y - y^2 = 0

(1/2) * (1 + sq(5) ) = (4/3)^x = q/p
(1 - sq(5) < 0 , not a possible solution)
 
g_edgar said:
Divide by 4^x 3^x ... Can you solve a + 1 = 1/a ?


What the heck is a+1=1/a? I can't get an answer. I get to (a squared + a)=1, then I'm stuck.

Steve
 
nickto21 said:
What the heck is a+1=1/a? I can't get an answer. I get to (a squared + a)=1, then I'm stuck.

Steve
Try taking a factor of a out of the LHS ... :wink:
 
nickto21 said:
What the heck is a+1=1/a? I can't get an answer. I get to (a squared + a)=1, then I'm stuck.

quadratic equation
 
I do not understand what is the original task. Could you possibly rewrite it?
 
Sure :)
(p en q > 0) :
log9(p) = log12(q) = log16(p + q) :
What is q/p?
 
If log9*(p)=log12*(q) then 9p=12q and q/p = 9/12
 
  • #10
log9(p) = log12(q) = log16(p + q)
is
9^x + 12^x = 16^x
(9, 12 and 16 are the bases eh)

If you solve that equation you get:
q/p = (1/2) * (1 + sq(5) )

I'm wondering, if 9 and 12 were coefficients, would this be the solution?

9 log(p) = 12 log(q)
log(q) = 1 so q = 10
log(p) = 12/9 so p = 10^(12/9)

q/p = 10^(1-12/9) = 10 ^ (-1/3)
 
  • #11
JanClaesen said:
log9(p) = log12(q) = log16(p + q)
is
9^x + 12^x = 16^x
(9, 12 and 16 are the bases eh)

If you solve that equation you get:
q/p = (1/2) * (1 + sq(5) )

I'm wondering, if 9 and 12 were coefficients, would this be the solution?

9 log(p) = 12 log(q)
log(q) = 1 so q = 10
What reason would you have to think that log(q)= 1?
If 9 log(p)= 12 log(q) then log(p)/log(q)= 12/9= 4/3. You could then say that log(p)/log(q)= logq(p)= 4/3 so that p= q4/3 and p/q = q4/3. There are many possible values for p/q.

For example, if q= 8, p= 16, then 9log(p)= 9log(16)= 9 log(16)= 9log(2^4)= 9(4)log(2)= 36 log(2)= 12(3)log(2)= 12log(2^3)= 12log(8)= 12log(q). So 9 log(p)= 12 log(q) and p/q= 16/8= 2.

But if q= 27, p= 81, then 9log(p)= 9log(81)= 9log(3^4)= 36log(3)= 12(3)log(3)= 12log(33= 12 log(27)= 12 log(q). Again 9 log(p)= 12 log(q) but now p/q= 81/27= 3.

q/p = 10^(1-12/9) = 10 ^ (-1/3)
 
  • #12
If log_9(p)=log_{12}(q)=log_{16}(p+q) then

9^x + 12^x = 16^x

y=(\frac{4}{3})^x

y_{1,2}=\frac{1 \pm \sqrt{5}}{2}

If:

(\frac{4}{3})^x=\frac{1 \pm \sqrt{5}}{2}

Then what is x?

x=log_\frac{4}{3}{\frac{1 + \sqrt{5}}{2}}

You would tell me why y_2=\frac{1 - \sqrt{5}}{2} is not the solution for (\frac{4}{3})^x

Regards.
 
Last edited:
  • #13
Because it's a negative number, but I already figured out myself in post #3, thanks anyway ;-)
 
Back
Top