Some questions about capacitor discharging

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the behavior of capacitors during the discharging process, specifically addressing why the voltage across a capacitor decreases to zero. Participants explore the relationship between current, charge, and voltage, as well as the physical mechanisms involved in discharging a capacitor.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants question how current flow during discharging leads to a decrease in voltage, referencing the equation I = C * dV/dt.
  • Others suggest that the opposite charges on the capacitor plates neutralize each other when discharging, which contributes to the reduction in voltage.
  • There is a discussion on the relationship between charge (Q), voltage (V), and capacitance (C), with some participants noting that discharging reduces charge, thus lowering voltage.
  • One participant mentions that electrons flow from the negatively charged plate to the positively charged plate, leading to voltage reduction.
  • Some participants inquire about the necessity of grounding the capacitor during discharge, with differing views on whether it is required.
  • A mathematical model is introduced that describes the voltage decay over time as an exponential function, relating voltage to resistance and capacitance.
  • Clarifications are sought regarding the terminology of voltage as "Potential Difference" to enhance understanding of circuit behavior.
  • There is a discussion about the path electrons take during discharge, with some participants affirming that they travel through the circuit rather than between the plates.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express various viewpoints on the mechanisms of capacitor discharging, with no clear consensus on all aspects of the discussion. Some agree on the basic principles of charge flow and voltage reduction, while others raise questions and propose alternative interpretations.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight the importance of understanding the relationship between current, charge, and voltage, but some assumptions and definitions remain implicit. The discussion includes mathematical formulations that may depend on specific circuit conditions not fully explored.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be useful for students and enthusiasts of electrical engineering, physics, and electronics who are interested in the principles of capacitors and their behavior in circuits.

Milotic
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
  1. why does the voltage of the capacitor eventually go to 0 when discharging the capacitor? I heard that's because "current starts flowing when discharging", but how exactly does that lead to V going down? I know that I = C * dV/dt, but that doesn't seem to help me understand why V goes down (which is equivalent to dV/dt < 0).
  2. Alternatively, I heard this is due to Q = VC; discharging capacitor means reducing the charge on capacitor, so V must decrease as well. Okay, in that case, where does the charge go?
  3. should the capacitor be connected to the ground node in both directions if it's to be discharged?I saw a diagram/circuit with a short circuit and pre-charged capacitor only (), which would apparently lead to V decreasing, but the circuit didn't have any ground nodes labelled. Is it possible to discharge a capacitor without having a ground node?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Milotic said:
why does the voltage of the capacitor eventually go to 0 when discharging the capacitor? I heard that's because "current starts flowing when discharging", but how exactly does that lead to V going down? I know that I = C * dV/dt, but that doesn't seem to help me understand why V goes down (which is equivalent to dV/dt < 0).

Because there are opposite charges on each side of the capacitor, and discharging allows the charges to flow and cancel each other out.

Milotic said:
Alternatively, I heard this is due to Q = VC; discharging capacitor means reducing the charge on capacitor, so V must decrease as well. Okay, in that case, where does the charge go?

Electrons flow from one plate of the capacitor to the other plate. Specifically they flow from the negatively charged plate to the positively charged plate and the charges cancel out, making the voltage zero.

Milotic said:
should the capacitor be connected to the ground node in both directions if it's to be discharged?

No, as there are equal but opposite charges on each side of the capacitor. It is sufficient to let them neutralize each other.

Note that the circuit as a whole isn't charged. So there's no need to connect it to ground to get rid of excess charge. We're only moving charges around within the circuit (specifically the capacitor).
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: etotheipi and vanhees71
You can make this excellent answer also quantitative with what you already wrote. The wires of your circuit have some resistance ##R##, and that implies from Kirchhoff's rule that
$$U(t)=R I(t).$$
On the other hand you know that ##I=-\mathrm{d} Q/\mathrm{d} t=-C \mathrm{d} U/\mathrm{d} t## (where ##Q## is the charge on the positively charged plate; think about why there's a - sign!). So you get a differerntial equation for the voltage:
$$R C \dot{U}(t)=-U(t)$$
or
$$\frac{\dot{U}}{U}=-\frac{1}{RC}.$$
Integrating this from ##t'=0## to ##t'=t## you get
$$\ln \left (\frac{U(t)}{U_0} \right)=-\frac{t}{R C} \; \Rightarrow \; U(t)=U_0 \exp \left (-\frac{t}{R C} \right).$$
This means the voltage decreases exponentially to 0. The current indeed is
$$I(t)=-C \dot{U}(t)=\frac{U_0}{R} \exp \left (-\frac{t}{R C} \right)=\frac{U(t)}{R}.$$
 
@ Drakkith thank you for your explanations! I was wondering if you could still explain
(1) if or how the equation I = C * dV/dt relates to discharging
and
(2) you said that "electrons flow from the negatively charged plate to the positively charged plate and the charges cancel out". Since no current is allowed to flow in between the capacitor plates, would that mean the electrons go the "long way" around the rest of the circuit to balance out the charges? And is the reason why the electrons start flowing again (in the absence of voltage source) because the electrons are attracted to the positive charge on the + plate / repelled by the many other electrons on the - plate?
 
@vanhees71 I'm following through your explanations right now—just to confirm, are all those "U(t)"'s referring to voltages?
 
Yes, ##U(t)## is the voltage across the capacitor. To understand the relation with the current, just remember that the current is the charge ##\mathrm{d} Q## flowing through the wire from the positively charged capacitor plate in a time interval ##\mathrm{d} t## devided by this time interval. There's a negative sign, because the decrease of the charge on the positively charged plate, i.e., ##\dot{Q}<0## corresponds to a positive current, i.e., you have ##I(t)=-\dot{Q}(t)=-C \dot{U}(t)## (where finally I used ##Q(t)=CU(t)##).
 
Milotic said:
why does the voltage of the capacitor eventually go to 0
It can be a big help if, when you want a deeper understanding of circuit 'situations', you use the term "Potential Difference" instead of Voltage. That will constantly remind you that there are two terminals connected to your mental Voltmeter. Also PD is only two characters!
 
Milotic said:
Since no current is allowed to flow in between the capacitor plates, would that mean the electrons go the "long way" around the rest of the circuit to balance out the charges?

That's right.

Milotic said:
And is the reason why the electrons start flowing again (in the absence of voltage source) because the electrons are attracted to the positive charge on the + plate / repelled by the many other electrons on the - plate?

That's also right. In electrical engineering terms, the charged capacitor has a potential difference between its two plates, and this PD causes current to flow through the circuit.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Milotic

Similar threads

  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
2K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
1K
Replies
152
Views
7K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 50 ·
2
Replies
50
Views
14K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
2K
  • · Replies 28 ·
Replies
28
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K