Startup Guide: How to Begin Your Business

  • Thread starter Thread starter trASHf
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    even
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around an ambiguous physics problem involving an object on a steel plank, where participants express confusion over the lack of clarity in the problem statement. The primary focus is on determining the coefficient of friction using Newton's Second Law, but the absence of specific details about force direction and acceleration complicates the analysis. Participants agree that the question is not open-ended but rather poorly defined, making it difficult to arrive at a solution. A suggestion is made to clarify the problem and provide a structured attempt at solving it for better assistance. Overall, the conversation highlights the importance of clear problem statements in physics discussions.
trASHf
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
Homework Statement
Unknown object has a mass of 3.2kg on steel plank.

Add forces:
magnitude of applied force =22.8N
magnitude of acceleration =3.02m/s^2

What is the material?
Relevant Equations
Newton's Second Law
idek
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I don't know either. Can you provide a better description of the problem, and maybe an attempt at the solution?
 
trASHf said:
Homework Statement: Unknown object has a mass of 3.2kg on steel plank.

Add forces:
magnitude of applied force =22.8N
magnitude of acceleration =3.02m/s^2

What is the material?
Homework Equations: Newton's Second Law

idek
Given the utterly ambiguous problem statement, I'd say the answer is clearly "something will happen"
 
I agree that it is a very open-ended question
DaveE said:
I don't know either. Can you provide a better description of the problem, and maybe an attempt at the solution?

Of course. This is a forces problem and I think one must find the coefficient of friction that exists between the two materials. Although it doesn't specify the direction the force is being applied or the the acceleration, I believe those may have to be hypothesized.
 
phinds said:
Given the utterly ambiguous problem statement, I'd say the answer is clearly "something will happen"

The question I believe is asking just to determine the material based off the information given by using Newton's Second Law to find the coefficient of friction between the two materials. I have attempted this question did not get a reasonable result. Sorry if the post was not clear, hopefully this makes it less ambiguous.
 
trASHf said:
I agree that it is a very open-ended question
No, it's not "open ended", it's utterly ambiguous. It's NOT that it has multiple possible answers ("open ended"), it's that it has no answer at all because you have not defined the problem.
 
  • Like
Likes berkeman and trASHf
Closed for Moderation...
 
trASHf said:
The question I believe is asking just to determine the material based off the information given by using Newton's Second Law to find the coefficient of friction between the two materials. I have attempted this question did not get a reasonable result. Sorry if the post was not clear, hopefully this makes it less ambiguous.

Please re-post your thread with a good thread start that includes a clear problem statement and your best attempt at working the problem. We need you to do that before we can offer our tutorial help.

Thank you very much.
 
Back
Top