Static Equilibrium Pulley Problem

2 replies · 3K views · last reply
Sixth42
Messages
2
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Diagram of a pulley system: block M2 sits on block M1 on a 30° incline, connected by a rope over a pulley at the top-left and a pulley at the incline's lower corner, which hangs over a pulley to block M3.


The attachment above contains the diagram given in the problem

M1 = 25kg
M2 = 35kg
Friction coefficient between M1 and stucture = 0.15
Friction coefficient between M1 and M2 = 0.25
Friction on pulleys and mass on pulleys is negligible.

Find the minimum mass M3 for sliding to occur in the system (i.e. the maximum mass for which the system will remain in static equilibrium).

Homework Equations


∑Fx = 0
ΣFy = 0

The Attempt at a Solution


For the first mass:
Free-body diagram of block M1 on an inclined plane at 60 degrees, with forces Fn, T1, 0.15Fn, M1g and M2g labelled, and the note Left is positive.

The above attachment contains the diagram I used with the rotated coordinate system. My equations were:
∑Fy = 0
-M2g sin(60°)-M1g sin(60°) + Fn = 0
Fn = 509.7N

∑Fx = 0
-M2g cos(60°)-M1g cos(60°) - 0.15Fn + T1 = 0
T1 = 370.8N

For the second mass:
Free-body diagram of block M2 on an incline at 60 degrees, with forces Fn2 up, T1 left, T2 right, 0.25Fn2 right, and M2g down the slope; labelled Left is positive.

The above attachment contains the diagram I used with the rotated coordinate system. My equations were:
∑Fy = 0
-M2g sin(60°) + Fn2 = 0
Fn2 = 297.3N

∑Fx = 0
-M2g cos(60°) - 0.25Fn2 - T2 + T1 = 0
T2 = 124.8N

For the pulley attached to M3:
Free-body diagram of a pulley with two upward-left and upward-right tension forces labelled T2 and a downward force labelled M3 acting on the pulley.

∑Fy = 0
2T2 - M3 = 0
M3 = 249.6N

Therefore mass of M3 = 249.6/9.81 = 25.44kg

I managed to get a final answer of M3 = 25.44kg (or 249.6N) by working on each mass individually. Using a rotated coordinate system for M1 and M2. It would be nice if someone could confirm this answer for me but my main questions are:
Was I correct in adding M2 to the force diagram for M1?
In both diagrams, is the friction force in the correct direction?
Does this method look correct overall or did I miss something?

Thanks for the help.
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of two masses M1 and M2 on an inclined plane at 30 degrees, connected by a rope over pulleys to a hanging mass M3 on a lower pulley.
    upload_2016-6-16_21-55-23.png
    5.7 KB · Views: 625
Your force balance that you identify as M1 is really the force balance on the combination of M1 and M2, and should be identified as such. Also, M2 should be shown on this free body diagram.

You analysis inherently assumes that the static friction between M1 with the incline, and M2 with M1 will occur at the same value of M3. This is not necessarily the case. One of these static frictions may release first, then causing the other to release when the forces readjust.
 
Thank you very much Chester, I see where it went wrong