Superpostion circuit analysis question

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
fatmoe
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
The problem I am having is determining what is in series and what is in parallel.

Now I am working with v1, so I1 has been removed and replaced with an open circuit and v2 has been replaced with a short.

So does that mean that r2 || r4? and if so, does that also mean that r2 || r4 which would then be in series with r3?



Circuit schematic with resistors R1 (4kΩ), R2 (8kΩ), R3 (12kΩ), R4 (6kΩ), R6 (100Ω), voltage sources V1 (48 V) and V2 (60 V), and current source I1 (30mA).
 
Attachments
  • Circuit schematic with V1 48 V, V2 60 V, current source I1 30 mA, and resistors R1 4kΩ, R2 8kΩ, R3 12kΩ, R4 6kΩ and R6 100Ω.
    Untitled.jpg
    17 KB · Views: 438
I think you should actually draw the circuit diagram replacing I1 with an open circuit and V2 with a short circuit.

Then, you should see there are two more components you can remove, because they don't have any current flowing through them. That should answer your question

does that mean that r2 || r4? and if so, does that also mean that r2 || r4 which would then be in series with r3?
 
AlephZero said:
I think you should actually draw the circuit diagram replacing I1 with an open circuit and V2 with a short circuit.

Then, you should see there are two more components you can remove, because they don't have any current flowing through them. That should answer your question

Well I have redraw it but I don't see two other components that I can remove.. R6 is in the middle so I can't combine it with anything.. I'm confused.. Already spent 4 hours on this questions..
 
AlephZero said:
I think you should actually draw the circuit diagram replacing I1 with an open circuit and V2 with a short circuit.
K
Then, you should see there are two more components you can remove, because they don't have any current flowing through them. That should answer your question

I think I see now.. You mean r1 and r6? Then that would in series with the equivalent.
 
You have an open circuit for I1 and a short circuit for V2. The current will always flow the easiest route from + to -.

As Aleph said, draw your new circuit and look at how the current would flow through it. In your above post, R6 is correct, however, there will flow current through R1. What happens with the current on the node to the right of R2? Where will it flow from there?