Taking stat mech before quantum?

  • Thread starter Thread starter proton
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Quantum Stat mech
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on course selection for a physics student who has completed analytic mechanics and is currently studying upper-division electromagnetism (E&M). The student plans to take the second half of E&M, along with quantum mechanics and abstract algebra next fall, and is considering either statistical mechanics or solid state physics. While quantum mechanics is a prerequisite for statistical mechanics at their school, solid state physics has no prerequisites and is an elective. The student expresses enthusiasm for statistical mechanics, citing a positive experience in a previous modern physics class that covered quantum and statistical mechanics.Responses suggest that while prerequisites are typically emphasized, they may not be strictly necessary for understanding statistical mechanics. Some contributors argue that it's possible to grasp the material without a deep understanding of quantum mechanics, while others emphasize the importance of foundational knowledge. The student is encouraged to consult with the professor regarding the necessity of quantum mechanics for statistical mechanics. Overall, the conversation highlights the balance between following academic requirements and personal interest in course content.
proton
Messages
349
Reaction score
0
i just finished my analytic mechanics and am halfway done with upperdiv E&M. Next fall, i plan on taking the 2nd half of E&M and the 1st quarter of Quantum and Abstract Algebra, for sure. Along with that, I'm thinking of taking either Statistical Mechanics or Solid State Physics.

at my school, quantum is a prereq for stat mech, but there are no prereqs for solid state. solid state is an elective at my school. i really look forward to taking stat mech because my school offered a lowerdiv modern physics-like class, with multivariable calc involved, that only focused on quanum and stat mech, and it was one of the best classes I've taken.

i don't know if i want to focus on math or physics yet, however. so far, analytic mechanics was only interesting in the 2nd half of the course. E&M so far was mostly a review of the lower div class.

should i take stat mech and if i enjoy, stick with physics. or take solid state, since i heard its really important for physics. or be patient, and not take either yet. I'm leaning towards option 1 or 3
 
Physics news on Phys.org
proton said:
at my school, quantum is a prereq for stat mech

Then you should take quantum before stat mech.
 
In my experience, prerequisites are meaningless.
 
I took statmech before Quantum, but that's the way my school's program was, it wasn't a choice of mine. Statmech certainly requires many results from quantum mechanics, but often you can take them at face value without having too much about where they came from. You should maybe talk to the professor of the class, to see really how much quantum is needed.
 
Cincinnatus said:
In my experience, prerequisites are meaningless.

Yeah, so let's learn nuclear physics before we know E&M.

You don't need QM for lower stat mech, it is only briefly alluded to. What you did in second year should suffice.
 
Hey, I am Andreas from Germany. I am currently 35 years old and I want to relearn math and physics. This is not one of these regular questions when it comes to this matter. So... I am very realistic about it. I know that there are severe contraints when it comes to selfstudy compared to a regular school and/or university (structure, peers, teachers, learning groups, tests, access to papers and so on) . I will never get a job in this field and I will never be taken serious by "real"...
Yesterday, 9/5/2025, when I was surfing, I found an article The Schwarzschild solution contains three problems, which can be easily solved - Journal of King Saud University - Science ABUNDANCE ESTIMATION IN AN ARID ENVIRONMENT https://jksus.org/the-schwarzschild-solution-contains-three-problems-which-can-be-easily-solved/ that has the derivation of a line element as a corrected version of the Schwarzschild solution to Einstein’s field equation. This article's date received is 2022-11-15...

Similar threads

Back
Top