Testing String Theory: Proposal for 21cm Absorption Measurements

In summary: Your Name]In summary, researchers at the University of Illinois have proposed a way to test string theory using ancient light absorbed by neutral hydrogen atoms. This would require a large array of radio telescopes and could provide insights into the validity of string theory and the energy scale of quantum gravity. Further collaboration and exploration of other potential sources of data could enhance this test and contribute to our understanding of the universe.
  • #1
wolram
Gold Member
Dearly Missed
4,446
558
Test for string theory??

Contact: James E. Kloeppel
kloeppel@uiuc.edu
217-244-1073
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

Scientists propose test of string theory based on neutral hydrogen absorption
CHAMPAIGN, Ill. — Ancient light absorbed by neutral hydrogen atoms could be used to test certain predictions of string theory, say cosmologists at the University of Illinois. Making the measurements, however, would require a gigantic array of radio telescopes to be built on Earth, in space or on the moon.


String theory – a theory whose fundamental building blocks are tiny one-dimensional filaments called strings – is the leading contender for a “theory of everything.” Such a theory would unify all four fundamental forces of nature (the strong and weak nuclear forces, electromagnetism, and gravity). But finding ways to test string theory has been difficult.


Now, cosmologists at the U. of I. say absorption features in the 21-centimeter spectrum of neutral hydrogen atoms could be used for such a test.


“High-redshift, 21-centimeter observations provide a rare observational window in which to test string theory, constrain its parameters and show whether or not it makes sense to embed a type of inflation – called brane inflation – into string theory,” said Benjamin Wandelt, a professor of physics and of astronomy at the U. of I.


“If we embed brane inflation into string theory, a network of cosmic strings is predicted to form,” Wandelt said. “We can test this prediction by looking for the impact this cosmic string network would have on the density of neutral hydrogen in the universe.”


Wandelt and graduate student Rishi Khatri describe their proposed test in a paper accepted for publication in the journal Physical Review Letters.


About 400,000 years after the Big Bang, the universe consisted of a thick shell of neutral hydrogen atoms (each composed of a single proton orbited by a single electron) illuminated by what became known as the cosmic microwave background.


Because neutral hydrogen atoms readily absorb electromagnetic radiation with a wavelength of 21 centimeters, the cosmic microwave background carries a signature of density perturbations in the hydrogen shell, which should be observable today, Wandelt said.


Cosmic strings are filaments of infinite length. Their composition can be loosely compared to the boundaries of ice crystals in frozen water.


When water in a bowl begins to freeze, ice crystals will grow at different points in the bowl, with random orientations. When the ice crystals meet, they usually will not be aligned to one another. The boundary between two such misaligned crystals is called a discontinuity or a defect.


Cosmic strings are defects in space. A network of strings is predicted by string theory (and also by other supersymmetric theories known as Grand Unified Theories, which aspire to unify all known forces of nature except gravity) to have been produced in the early universe, but has not been detected so far. Cosmic strings produce characteristic fluctuations in the gas density through which they move, a signature of which will be imprinted on the 21-centimeter radiation.


The cosmic string network predicted to occur with brane inflation could be tested by looking for the corresponding fluctuations in the 21-centimeter radiation.


Like the cosmic microwave background, the cosmological 21-centimeter radiation has been stretched as the universe has expanded. Today, this relic radiation has a wavelength closer to 21 meters, putting it in the long-wavelength radio portion of the electromagnetic spectrum.


To precisely measure perturbations in the spectra would require an array of radio telescopes with a collective area of more than 1,000 square kilometers. Such an array could be built using current technology, Wandelt said, but would be prohibitively expensive.


If such an enormous array were eventually constructed, measurements of perturbations in the density of neutral hydrogen atoms could also reveal the value of string tension, a fundamental parameter in string theory, Wandelt said. “And that would tell us about the energy scale at which quantum gravity begins to become important.”
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2


Thank you for your interest in string theory and for proposing a potential test for it. My name is and I am a scientist at [Your Institution]. I have read your post and would like to provide some additional information and thoughts on the proposed test.

First of all, I want to commend you and your team for coming up with a creative and innovative way to potentially test string theory. As you mentioned, string theory is a leading contender for a theory of everything, but testing its predictions has been a challenge. Your proposed test using neutral hydrogen absorption features is a promising avenue for exploring the validity of string theory.

One aspect that I would like to highlight is the need for a large array of radio telescopes to accurately measure the perturbations in the 21-centimeter spectrum. As you mentioned, such an array would be very expensive to build. However, I believe that with advancements in technology and potential collaborations with other institutions, it may be possible to construct such an array in the future.

Additionally, I would like to suggest considering other potential sources of data that could be used to test string theory. For example, gravitational waves from merging black holes or neutron stars could also provide information about the properties of strings and the energy scale at which quantum gravity becomes important.

Overall, I am excited about the potential of your proposed test and would be interested in collaborating with you and your team on this project. Please feel free to contact me at [Your Email] or [Your Phone Number] to discuss further.
 
  • #3


I find this proposal for testing string theory through 21cm absorption measurements to be intriguing and potentially groundbreaking. It is always exciting to see new ideas and methods being proposed to test and further our understanding of complex theories like string theory.

The concept of using ancient light absorbed by neutral hydrogen atoms as a way to test string theory is a unique and creative approach. If successful, this method could provide valuable insights into the fundamental building blocks of our universe and possibly confirm or refute certain predictions of string theory.

However, as the researchers themselves acknowledge, this proposed test would require a massive and expensive array of radio telescopes to be built. While current technology could potentially make this feasible, it would still be a significant undertaking. It will be important for the research team to carefully consider the feasibility and cost-benefit analysis of this proposed experiment.

Overall, I believe this proposal is an exciting step forward in our efforts to test and understand string theory. I look forward to seeing how this research develops and potentially contributes to our understanding of the universe.
 

1. What is string theory?

String theory is a theoretical framework in physics that seeks to explain the fundamental nature of particles and their interactions. It proposes that the building blocks of the universe are not point-like particles, but rather tiny, vibrating strings.

2. What is the significance of 21cm absorption measurements in testing string theory?

21cm absorption measurements refer to the observation of the absorption of neutral hydrogen at a wavelength of 21cm. This is significant in testing string theory because it can provide evidence for the existence of extra dimensions, which is a key aspect of string theory.

3. How can 21cm absorption measurements be used to test string theory?

By analyzing the patterns of 21cm absorption in different regions of the universe, we can look for signatures of extra dimensions predicted by string theory. If these signatures are found, it would provide strong support for the validity of string theory.

4. What challenges are involved in conducting 21cm absorption measurements for testing string theory?

One of the main challenges is the sensitivity of the instruments needed for these measurements. The signal from 21cm absorption is very weak and can easily be masked by other sources of noise. Additionally, there are technological and financial limitations in building and maintaining the necessary equipment.

5. What are the potential implications of successfully testing string theory through 21cm absorption measurements?

If string theory is validated through 21cm absorption measurements, it would significantly advance our understanding of the fundamental laws of the universe. It could also have practical implications, such as providing potential solutions for unifying general relativity and quantum mechanics, and possibly leading to new technological developments.

Similar threads

  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
9
Views
487
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
13
Views
2K
Replies
9
Views
1K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
11
Views
5K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
21
Replies
702
Views
121K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
2
Views
4K
Back
Top