The gravitational tug of the Sun and the Moon on Earth - a question

In summary, the two high tides on Earth are due to the Moon's gravitational pull. The rocks at point F are pulled away from the Sun, in the opposite direction of the Moon's gravitational pull.
  • #1
shirvanshah
3
0
Hi! When it comes to physics, I'm a total layperson (so, please, be kind ;-)), I actually study English, but recently my interest in physics has been growing more and more. So, yesterday I started watching the first of Feynman's Cornell University lectures. And that led me to the question: why there are two high tides each day? What's especially striking to me is that there are two high tides simultaneously, I mean, on both "sides" of the Earth at the same time. So, I tried to get some insight on that, and I've found the following paper: http://www.jal.cc.il.us/~mikolajsawicki/tides_new2.pdf
And what is quite perplexing here is the following passage:
Consider the point C on Earth closest to the Sun and the point F on a far side of Earth. The
Sun pulls harder on a unit mass at the point C, not as hard on a unit mass at Earth center O,
and weaker yet on a unit mass at point F. The acceleration as of Earth as a whole in free fall
towards the Sun is determined by the gravitational pull of the Sun on Earth’s center. Hence
the unit mass at C has a tendency to accelerate towards the Sun with acceleration as + as,
i.e. more than the center of Earth, while a mass at the far side F has a tendency to accelerate towards the Sun with acceleration as - as, i.e. to lag behind the center of Earth.
This difference in Solar gravitational pulls would have lead to a disintegration of Earth, had
Earth’s own gravity been to weak to hold Earth together. To an observer on Earth it would have looked like rocks at point C and F were lifted away from the surface of Earth.

And I believe it's a very similar case with the Moon's gravitational pull and this is why there are two high tides. So, my question is this - why the rocks at point F would be lifted away from the Sun and not pulled in the direction of Sun, that is, towards Earth's center? Why the direction of that force is not in the same direction as the gravitational pull of the sun (towards the Sun's center) but, as it seems, away from it?
I probably should have payed more attention to science in high school, but I would really appreciate a kind and an easy-to-grasp answer ;-).
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #3
Yes, but still I don't quite understand why the force of the Moon's gravitational pull on the side farthest from the moon is directed, as it seems, away from the moon, and not towards the moon and towards the Earth's center. It seems to me that on the side farthest from the Moon the force of the Moon's gravity and the force of the Earth's gravity have the same direction, so why they are subtracted rather than added?
I realize that there must be some profound misconception in what I wrote above, and I would be really glad to know what the misconception is exactly about.
 
  • #4
It's not that rock F is pulled away from the Sun, it's that Earth is pulled away from rock F.

Think of it this way:

Three rocks, a, B and c are resting together, 93 million miles from the sun:

(SUN) . . . . . . . . . . aBc

a is 1kg
B is 10^23 kg
c is 1kg

a is pulled most strongly toward the Sun;
B is pulled toward the sun but less strongly than a;
finally, c is pulled toward the sun but less strongly than B.

The net effect is that
aBc separate neatly and evenly to become a B c.

See?
 
  • #5
Hm... Is it really that simple? Well, it seems I get it now, thank you very much :D
 

What is the gravitational tug of the Sun and the Moon on Earth?

The gravitational tug of the Sun and the Moon on Earth refers to the pull of these celestial bodies on our planet due to their mass and distance. This pull creates a force that affects the Earth's rotation and causes phenomena such as tides.

How does the Sun's gravitational tug affect the Earth?

The Sun's gravitational tug is the primary force that keeps the Earth in its orbit around the Sun. It also causes the Earth to rotate on its axis, resulting in day and night. The force of the Sun's gravity also contributes to the tides, but to a lesser extent than the Moon's gravitational tug.

What is the role of the Moon's gravitational tug on Earth's tides?

The Moon's gravitational tug is the main force behind the tides on Earth. As the Moon orbits around the Earth, its gravitational pull creates a bulge in the Earth's oceans on the side facing the Moon, causing high tide. At the same time, on the opposite side of the Earth, there is a low tide due to the Earth being pulled away from the water.

How do the Sun and Moon's gravitational tugs affect each other?

The Sun and Moon's gravitational tugs affect each other through a phenomenon called tidal acceleration. This occurs when the Moon's gravitational pull on the Earth causes the Earth's rotation to slow down slightly, which in turn affects the Moon's orbit. This results in the Moon moving away from the Earth at a rate of about 3.8 centimeters per year.

How does the Earth's distance from the Sun and Moon impact their gravitational tugs?

The gravitational tug of the Sun and Moon on Earth is affected by the distance between these bodies. The closer the Earth is to the Sun, the stronger the Sun's gravitational pull will be, and the farther away the Moon is from the Earth, the weaker its gravitational tug will be. This can impact the intensity of tides and other phenomena on Earth.

Similar threads

  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
17
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
735
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
14
Views
9K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • Special and General Relativity
2
Replies
38
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
4
Views
4K
Back
Top