Physics The right physics field for me

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the challenges faced by a recent master's graduate in cosmology who is seeking a PhD path that balances theoretical work with some computational elements. The individual expresses a preference for working primarily with pen and paper rather than extensive computer simulations, which are common in physics. They acknowledge the necessity of computational skills but wish to avoid a career heavily reliant on them. The graduate is interested in mathematical physics but feels uncertain about their mathematical maturity for rigorous proofs. They are currently exploring theoretical physics topics, particularly enjoying sophisticated mathematics, and are reading relevant texts. Recommendations include exploring fields like the AdS-CFT correspondence, which may align with their interests. The individual is considering pursuing a PhD in Europe, specifically in Germany, Sweden, or Ireland, and seeks guidance on suitable research areas that fit their preferences.
Figaro
Messages
103
Reaction score
7
I have finished my masters degree in cosmology and my research was on inflation, despite it being interesting, I'm not really fond of doing simulations/computations using a computer for a very long time. Don't get me wrong, I know that every physicists should know at least some computational tool (to some degree but not necessarily an expert) but I just don't want to work on computers most of the time. I've also thought of doing a PhD in mathematical physics but I realized that I want to be rigorous in what I do but not to the level of what mathematicians do (e.g. proving the existence of Navier Stokes theorem). So I think my intention is in between those two differing fields. I have a background on the standard undergraduate and graduate physics curriculum plus GR (Carroll) and cosmology (some basic books plus papers).

I just enjoy doing more sophisticated mathematics than the average physicist would enjoy (I enjoyed studying from Apostol, Lang, Edwards, etc) but I think it would also discourage me to do for example Papa Rudin's books. I'm currently reading Mathematical Physics by Szekeres and Hassani, and I think I like the flavor of it. Can anyone recommend the path I should take and what are the current fields/topics that I can look into if it will interest me. I'm planning on doing a PhD in Europe preferably in Germany, Sweden, or Ireland.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
What exactly do you want to do in terms of everyday work?

- most physicists use computers most of the time
- some physicists use pen and paper, but that is the mathematical physics part you didn't want.
- working on setups in a lab? That is far away from cosmology, and potential PhD supervisors will probably want some prior lab experience if that is the main part of the work.
- field work? See lab work, but even more removed from cosmology.
 
mfb said:
What exactly do you want to do in terms of everyday work?

- most physicists use computers most of the time
- some physicists use pen and paper, but that is the mathematical physics part you didn't want.
- working on setups in a lab? That is far away from cosmology, and potential PhD supervisors will probably want some prior lab experience if that is the main part of the work.
- field work? See lab work, but even more removed from cosmology.

Well, I think I'm more in the middle of the first and second choice. I want to work most of the time with pen and paper but a LITTLE BIT of computational side wouldn't bother me so much, what I'm not really into is using computers to simulate or do calculations the whole time. As for mathematical physics, it's not that I don't want it but I'm reluctant because I feel as though I'm not up to that level yet (in terms of mathematical maturity/sophistication) that is why I think I'm somehow in the middle of those two differing fields. I'm trying to do some searching on the latest topics on theoretical physics that would somehow fit my preference but I need some advice to enhance my view on this matter. I've worked on inflation, specifically doing computations for the temperature evolution, energy density evolution, gravitational wave intensity, etc.
 
Figaro said:
I just enjoy doing more sophisticated mathematics than the average physicist would enjoy (I enjoyed studying from Apostol, Lang, Edwards, etc) but I think it would also discourage me to do for example Papa Rudin's books. I'm currently reading Mathematical Physics by Szekeres and Hassani, and I think I like the flavor of it. Can anyone recommend the path I should take and what are the current fields/topics that I can look into if it will interest me. I'm planning on doing a PhD in Europe preferably in Germany, Sweden, or Ireland.

There is a community that works on the AdS-CFT correspondence, perhaps some branch of that would be interesting for you.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top