The speed of molecules and a machine that sorts them

In summary, a cyclone separator can sort particles by velocity, but it needs to be done quickly to avoid thermal equilibrium.
  • #1
Vrbic
407
18
Is there any device that can sort the particles of some medium according to the speed at which they move in the medium or something like that? As far as I know, there's a machine that can sort particles by charge through a magnetic field. Is there such a thing for speeds and charged / uncharged particles?

Sorry if I'm in the wrong section, I wasn't sure where exactly to ask.

Thank you for your answers, opinions.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
Vrbic said:
Is there any device that can sort the particles of some medium according to the speed at which they move in the medium or something like that? As far as I know, there's a machine that can sort particles by charge through a magnetic field. Is there such a thing for speeds and charged / uncharged particles?

Sorry if I'm in the wrong section, I wasn't sure where exactly to ask.

Thank you for your answers, opinions.
Electrophoresis gel sorts proteins and bases by size, not sure about particles. Where have you searched?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrophoresis
 
  • Like
Likes Vrbic
  • #3
Might you mean a cyclone separator?
http://www.asmemetsection.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/NYC-ASME_2013.pdf

The basic principle is pretty universal. If you force a stream of particles to bend around a curve, then the fastest or heaviest particles are moved more to the outside of the radius.

A mass spectrometer is similar, but it is designed to separate particles with different masses but similar velocities. If I understand your question, you have particles with the same mass but different velocities. If it is a gas, it is non-equilibrium.
 
  • Like
Likes pinball1970
  • #4
The average kinetic energy of free molecules is proportional to the temperature. But there is a thermal distribution of the kinetic energy of individual molecules. Every time one molecule collides with another, the KE and velocity will change. Because the time between collisions is so short, given time, the individual molecules in a gas or liquid approach that average KE.

Since KE = ½⋅m⋅v2 the velocity of a molecule will be proportional to 1/√mass. Gas and liquid chromatography techniques are spectrometers that race molecules against each other to sort molecules by their mass or molecular weight.

If you want to sort molecules by velocity, independent of mass or species, it will need to be done quickly with a shutter or door, before thermal equilibrium is reached, probably by Maxwell's Demon in a rarefied gas where collisions are unlikely.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Likes pinball1970 and Tom.G
  • #5
@Vrbic

Now we have guesses ranging all the way from a cyclone dust separator to a chromatograph. We need context. What kind of particles are you trying to separate.
 
  • #6
Add 'Maxwell's Demon' to the guess list.
 
  • Like
Likes Vrbic and anorlunda
  • #7
anorlunda said:
Might you mean a cyclone separator?
http://www.asmemetsection.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/NYC-ASME_2013.pdf

The basic principle is pretty universal. If you force a stream of particles to bend around a curve, then the fastest or heaviest particles are moved more to the outside of the radius.

A mass spectrometer is similar, but it is designed to separate particles with different masses but similar velocities. If I understand your question, you have particles with the same mass but different velocities. If it is a gas, it is non-equilibrium.

I understand. Thank you. It is exactly what I was thinking about.
 
  • #8
Thank you all for the discussion.
 

FAQ: The speed of molecules and a machine that sorts them

1. What is the speed of molecules?

The speed of molecules varies depending on factors such as temperature and molecular weight. On average, molecules in a gas move at speeds of around 500-1000 meters per second.

2. How does a machine sort molecules?

A machine that sorts molecules uses various methods such as centrifugation, chromatography, and electrophoresis to separate molecules based on their size, charge, or other properties.

3. What is the purpose of sorting molecules?

Sorting molecules is important in many scientific and industrial processes, such as purifying substances, identifying and analyzing different molecules, and creating specific mixtures for experiments or products.

4. Can the speed of molecules be controlled?

In some cases, the speed of molecules can be controlled through external factors such as temperature, pressure, or electric fields. However, the natural speed of molecules is primarily determined by their kinetic energy.

5. Are there any limitations to sorting molecules with a machine?

While machines can efficiently sort molecules based on physical properties, they may not be able to distinguish between molecules with similar properties or complex mixtures with many different types of molecules. In these cases, additional methods or techniques may be needed for accurate sorting.

Similar threads

Back
Top