The Wonders of the Internet: Discovering the Winchcombe Meteorite

  • Thread starter Thread starter phinds
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Internet
AI Thread Summary
The discussion highlights the remarkable accessibility of information today compared to the past, emphasizing how resources like Google, Wikipedia, and YouTube have transformed the way people find answers to questions. Participants express nostalgia for the days when research required physical trips to libraries, contrasting it with the instant access available now. While many appreciate this convenience, there are concerns about the potential for misinformation online and the decline of traditional research skills. The conversation also touches on the societal impacts of technological advancements, noting that while the internet benefits the public, it can disrupt certain jobs and industries, leading to challenges for those affected. Overall, the dialogue reflects a blend of appreciation for modern resources and a recognition of the complexities they introduce.
phinds
Science Advisor
Insights Author
Gold Member
2024 Award
Messages
19,353
Reaction score
15,537
DaveE said:
google search is helpful for questions like this :wink:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winchcombe_meteorite
+1 on that.

I'm an old guy and I'm constantly amazed in a wonderfully pleasant way by the plethora of readily accessible information that we have today, and almost as equally amazed in a less pleasant way at the fact that there are still people who don't automatically take advantage of it. In my youth a question like that would have required a trip to the library and/or newspaper archives and finding an answer would not have been guaranteed. Now, it takes seconds to find out.
 
  • Like
Likes nsaspook, Fervent Freyja, russ_watters and 8 others
Physics news on Phys.org
phinds said:
+1 on that.

I'm an old guy and I'm constantly amazed in a wonderfully pleasant way by the plethora of readily accessible information that we have today, and almost as equally amazed in a less pleasant way at the fact that there are still people who don't automatically take advantage of it. In my youth a question like that would have required a trip to the library and/or newspaper archives and finding an answer would not have been guaranteed. Now, it takes seconds to find out.
Indeed. This archive is actually what I miss the most if off-line, and be it to help my parents with a crossword puzzle. It is incredibly convenient to look up things. Maybe not enough for a study of a certain field, but always to get a quick overview. And if Wikipedia doesn't help, then look for lecture notes! Many universities publish them on their servers nowadays.
 
  • Like
Likes Astronuc
fresh_42 said:
Indeed. This archive is actually what I miss the most if off-line, and be it to help my parents with a crossword puzzle. It is incredibly convenient to look up things. Maybe not enough for a study of a certain field, but always to get a quick overview. And if Wikipedia doesn't help, then look for lecture notes! Many universities publish them on their servers nowadays.
Between Wikipedia, youtube, and Google, we live in a miraculous time.
 
  • Like
Likes 2milehi and phinds
FactChecker said:
Between Wikipedia, youtube, and Google, we live in a miraculous time.
People who trade on the stock market would definitely add instantaneous stock quotes and stock information to that list.
 
fresh_42 said:
In my youth a question like that would have required a trip to the library and/or newspaper archives and finding an answer would not have been guaranteed. Now, it takes seconds to find out.
In my local library, the research desk is staffed by a person with a degree in library science. She is professionally trained for the job. Sadly, day after day she is asked to do nothing more than collect fees, 10 cents per page, for use of the printers. Her training and her mental health must atrophy with time.

Stories like that are sad, but the world benefits. The Internet is highly disruptive. Frequently, the result is that the public benefits but a small minority suffers. We have no good system for compensating the victims. Andrew Yang says that job retraining has proven to be 0% up to 10% effective. Right now, post peak of the pandemic, very many employers have found that they can make record profits if they have fewer employees.

My daughter in law works in the back office for a big bank. She fears rumors that the bank is considering a transition from 250,000 employees to 25 employees. No doubt that is an exaggeration, but plausible in the modern world.

Edit: I quoted @fresh_42 's text but incorrectly and labeled it as @phinds . I just corrected that.
 
Last edited:
  • Sad
Likes Astronuc
anorlunda said:
The Internet is highly disruptive. Frequently, the result is that the public benefits but a small minority suffers.
That is hardly unique to the internet. It IS, I believe, true in the aggregate that "a rising tide lifts all boats", but as systems change in areas of employment there are always winners and losers. Think of all those poor buggy whip manufacturers in 1910 in addition to the knowledge worker you mentioned in recent times. The list goes on and on.

Our society usually does not do a good job of alleviating the pain of such transitions for some (although modern unemployment insurance and such make things better than they used to be).
 
  • Like
Likes russ_watters
phinds said:
+1 on that.

I'm an old guy and I'm constantly amazed in a wonderfully pleasant way by the plethora of readily accessible information that we have today, and almost as equally amazed in a less pleasant way at the fact that there are still people who don't automatically take advantage of it. In my youth a question like that would have required a trip to the library and/or newspaper archives and finding an answer would not have been guaranteed. Now, it takes seconds to find out.
No worries; I will direct this comment back to meteors.

The access to so much information online, so easily obtained, may also lead to more credulous users. Having to track down published books in libraries and extract useful information probably helped us develop critical thinking and learning skills. Internet users face a daunting task to determine fact from fiction, standards from opinion, and useful information from popular nonsense.

I lied about the meteors. :smile:
 
  • Haha
Likes Vanadium 50, phinds and berkeman
fresh_42 said:
Some old dudes dreaming how it was in their childhood ...
Hey, I didn't even get started on the log cabin and stuff
 
phinds said:
the log cabin and stuff
Thought it was cave.:wink:
 
  • Haha
Likes atyy
  • #10
Bystander said:
Thought it was cave.:wink:
Oh, come on. I'm not THAT old

It WAS a very primitive dirt-floor log cabin though. :oldlaugh:
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes atyy
  • #11
My mother had a summer job as a calculator for an insurance company in the early 60s - simple but intensive statistical computations that we take for granted were delegated to rooms of women (cheaper due to pay disparities) prior to mainframe computers becoming commercially available later in the 60s
 
  • Like
Likes Fervent Freyja
  • #14
I will never forget the first time I sent a message in binary.

I used a campfire and a wet blanket.

FactChecker said:
Between Wikipedia, youtube, and Google, we live in a miraculous time.
I have often thought back to the 2001 movie, AI. Even then it wasn't obvious that Dr. Know was just around the corner... and soon to be available on our phones.
 
  • Haha
Likes Astronuc
  • #15
Ivan Seeking said:
I will never forget the first time I sent a message in binary.

I used a campfire and a wet blanket.
Jeez, you had blankets? Lucky guy. We had to just wave our hand over the fire to create the zeroes.
 
  • #16
The thing I occasionally love to do is revisit places I have resided using Google Maps. In particular it is so astoundingly detailed that I can situate myself exactly on the back porch of the tenement on Eddy St overlooking downtown Ithaca, for instance, or the see the exact view of the Blue Ridge from our house on Pantops Mountain in Charlottesville. It transports me immediately back!
Of course today I also discovered the obit of yet another friend I hadn't seen in too long...to quote Vonnegut "so it goes".
 
  • Like
Likes Astronuc and russ_watters
  • #17
Ivan Seeking said:
I will never forget the first time I sent a message in binary.

I used a campfire and a wet blanket.

phinds said:
Jeez, you had blankets? Lucky guy. We had to just wave our hand over the fire to create the zeroes.

Jeez, you had ZEROES?

Dilbert - four Yorkshiremen  GEEKS -- .gif
 
  • Like
Likes BillTre and Keith_McClary
  • #18
NTL2009 said:
Jeez, you had ZEROES?

View attachment 286401
Yeah, I've seen that one several times. It's a classic.
 
  • #19
phinds said:
Yeah, I've seen that one several times. It's a classic.
I tend to think this classic was the inspiration for that comic:

 
  • Like
Likes hutchphd
  • #20
phinds said:
there are still people who don't automatically take advantage of it
I usually do, but if everyone always did, we wouldn't have cool threads like this.
 
  • #21
True story: The first high-resolution image I downloaded on my computer was a photo of Saturn taken by the Hubble scope. I was using a 2400 baud modem and it was a long distance phone call. The download was a direct dial connection from a University and took over 4 hours. It may have been close to 6 hours. It cost me something like $40 in long distance charges - for ONE image.
 
  • Like
Likes hutchphd
  • #22
Ivan Seeking said:
True story: The first high-resolution image I downloaded on my computer was a photo of Saturn taken by the Hubble scope. I was using a 2400 baud modem and it was a long distance phone call. The download was a direct dial connection from a University and took over 4 hours. It may have been close to 6 hours. It cost me something like $40 in long distance charges - for ONE image.
Our computer club finagled a connection to the University of Calgary, which had a 128k (=2 phone lines) to the UofA, and then to UBC. We were told to use the shared resource sparingly. I remember feeling guilty downloading 100k all the way from the UK when I probably had it on a floppy somewhere.
When other ISPs came to Calgary there was no local connection, so a "traceroute" to a Calgary site would go UofC>UofA>UBC>Denver>LA>NYC>Toronto>Calgary.
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Likes Ivan Seeking
  • #23
Jeez, you guys had phones? Lucky guys. We had to use semaphores. Took freekin' FOREVER just for one fuzzy image.
 
  • #24
And the semaphore operators always hated sending binary: up down up down down up who could blame them?
 
  • #25
Ivan Seeking said:
I was using a 2400 baud modem
2400 baud? You were lucky! The first modem I owned was a 300/1200, and I actually used an acoustic coupler.
 
  • Like
Likes Ivan Seeking, Klystron, phinds and 2 others
  • #26
I can get scientific articles that in the old days I would have had to go to a good University library. Even then it would have taken 30 times longer. In short, I couldn't have done it.
 
  • Like
Likes Klystron and hutchphd
  • #27
phinds said:
In my youth a question like that would have required a trip to the library and/or newspaper archives and finding an answer would not have been guaranteed. Now, it takes seconds to find out.
My parents had an Encyclopedia Britanica, which I'm pretty sure cost $1000+ in 1980s money. Sitting around the dinner table, talking about...Pompeii - what year was that? Go grab volume P. That was our "Google it".
 
  • Like
Likes BillTre and Klystron
  • #28
russ_watters said:
My parents had an Encyclopedia Britanica, which I'm pretty sure cost $1000+ in 1980s money. Sitting around the dinner table, talking about...Pompeii - what year was that? Go grab volume P. That was our "Google it".
Just for nostalgia's sake I still have my own set that I bought in the late 1960's. Haven't opened it in lots of years.
 
  • #29
Vanadium 50 said:
2400 baud? You were lucky! The first modem I owned was a 300/1200, and I actually used an acoustic coupler.
You had a coupler? Lucky guy. We had to just yell really loudly.

(Actually, yeah I had one of those too.)
 
  • Like
Likes Vanadium 50
  • #30
Yelling hadn't been invented yet.
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Likes Mondayman, atyy and phinds
  • #31
russ_watters said:
That was our "Google it"
Still cannot bring myself to pitch either them or the old N. Geos.; seems a waste of craftsmanship and pride in products/goods/services.
 
  • Like
Likes Astronuc, BillTre and russ_watters
  • #32
My parents downsized last year and offered them. No takers.
 
  • Sad
Likes Astronuc and Bystander
  • #33
So, in the 2000’s, there were still salesman knocking door-to-door selling PC packages. One got my mom on an impulse buy. I think I was around 11. It was unusual that she made the down payment for me that day, because we never had much money and no one ever did anything for me. We had only just afforded a color TV. He probably hit up the impoverished neighborhoods right after income tax time. I recall begging her that day while the salesman was there. Begging, on my knees. She likely made the purchase because I never asked her for much- I cannot recall ever asking for even a single toy. We were very poor, and I always omitted my needs as to not be a burden, but in that moment I didn’t care. I wanted it. I needed information. Best thing she ever did for me- I had been so happy.

There were no real books in my home (and I had burned through the decor/readers digest early on) and the only books that were ever given to me had been an incomplete encyclopedia. I made deals with adults to drop me off at the library to get my fix during summers. My teachers always sent me to the library by myself for a few hours everyday and when I would get bored or frustrated with the material during class- that helped. But the information that the PC churned out was like a drug for me. What I wanted to know was immediately brought to me. I could investigate whatever topic I was on at the time. I did my chores and everyone’s homework as soon as I came in from school so that I could escape to that world.

From my understanding, the PC package had been bought with an installment plan. We were evicted not long after. Go figure.
 
  • Sad
  • Wow
  • Like
Likes Astronuc, Keith_McClary and BillTre
  • #34
hutchphd said:
I can situate myself exactly on the back porch of the tenement on Eddy St overlooking downtown Ithaca
My 90 year young mother tells me she and my father (& my brother) lived on Williams St (down off the end of Eddy) when I was born. My brother told me last time he went by, there was an Indian restaurant in that spot.
 
  • Like
  • Informative
Likes Astronuc and hutchphd
  • #36
russ_watters said:
My parents downsized last year and offered them. No takers.
I picked up an encyclopedia from 1930 or so. Somehow the black and white photos looked 3D. I couldn't figure out how it was done. A lost technology.

If I could I would own an encyclopedia. They are far superior for browsing. Wikipedia has a random browsing feature but all I got was the histories of small organizations such as high schools.
 
  • Like
Likes Klystron, Astronuc and collinsmark
  • #37
hutchphd said:
The thing I occasionally love to do is revisit places I have resided using Google Maps. In particular it is so astoundingly detailed that I can situate myself exactly on the back porch of the tenement on Eddy St overlooking downtown Ithaca, for instance, or the see the exact view of the Blue Ridge from our house on Pantops Mountain in Charlottesville. It transports me immediately back!
Of course today I also discovered the obit of yet another friend I hadn't seen in too long...to quote Vonnegut "so it goes".
I do the same. The first house in which my family lived still exists, as does the third, and fifth. The second house I lived in is gone and has been replaced by a parking lot. The fourth house I lived in has been replaced by a larger house. In 1988, when I visited those old places, the fourth house was still intact. It was only in the last couple of decades that the old house was replaced. I wouldn't have known that without the internet.

The sixth house (one story) I lived in was demolished and replaced by a big box house (two story with skylights) about three or four times the size, and the new owner bought the house next door, and demolished it for a side yard.

I'm beginning to see a trend.

As for the internet, it is marvelous in terms of access to information. On the other hand, the internet is cluttered with a lot of nonsense and garbage.

Growing up, my dad had a library, mostly of the humanities. We had a Random House dictionary and the 1963 edition of The Columbia Encyclopedia. I asked my dad recently about the Encyclopedia, since he is downsizing in preparation of selling his house and moving in with my brother, and unfortunately, he got rid of it. He thought it was too old and I had no use for it. Growing up, I found it invaluable because it had a lot of historical and biographical information, and it reflected the knowledge (a perspective) of the time. It was in that book, I discovered the periodic table, chemistry, physics, radiation, sub-atomic particles, . . . as well as articles of American, World and Ancient history.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Columbia_Encyclopedia

We could not afford a set like the Encyclopedia Brittanica. However, one of the neighbors was a teacher, and she had the full set of EB, so I'd visit and spend time reading through it, while other kids from the house would play or watch TV.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes hutchphd
  • #38
I never was brought up in an environment that was very intellectually stimulating although education was encouraged perhaps because they both had limited educations themselves. They, however, were avid readers of the newspapers and a few periodicals. The only books we ever had in the house other than my school books were a cheap set of encyclopedias from a grocery store purchased one volume at a time. But still, I eventually discovered libraries which my father would often chauffer me to when walking was not an option. You had to work a little harder to find out about something. Back then books tended to be austere compared to those of today with their glitzy graphics, pictures, and overly highlighted text which does not leave much for the mind to grapple with, leaving me to wonder how students today learn. I am curious if our experience in obtaining information by "hand and foot" so to speak has not made us savvier in the way we use the internet.
 
  • Like
Likes Klystron and Astronuc
Back
Top