Theory Q: "Persistence of Light Inside an Impenetrable Sphere?

  • Thread starter Thread starter shoook
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Light
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on whether light emitted from within a perfectly reflective and impenetrable sphere would remain lit indefinitely. Participants agree that while theoretically possible, perfect reflection does not exist, and even highly reflective materials lose light quickly due to absorption. The conversation highlights that reflectivity varies by wavelength, with specialized mirrors achieving over 99.999% reflectivity for specific wavelengths. Additionally, the time it takes for light intensity to diminish significantly depends on the number of reflections and the specific properties of the materials used. Ultimately, while light can persist for a time, it will not remain indefinitely due to inherent material limitations.
shoook
Messages
23
Reaction score
0
Hey guys, I have a theory question for you that may have been posed before but I can't find an answer to (not a school question):

There is a sphere with a completely impenetrable and reflective interior surface. A light in the visible spectrum is emitted from within this sphere. Because no light can escape from the spherical container, does the interior of this sphere stay lit forever?

Thanks for any help.
 
Last edited:
Science news on Phys.org
Yup.
 
Perfectly reflective and within the visible region I would say sure.
 
Except there is no such thing as perfect reflection. And even if it is 99.99%, light only stays there for nanoseconds because of its great speed, if it's a human-scale sphere.
 
Thanks for the input guys! Is there a known material that is "most reflective" to light? Is there a known material that is "most impenetrable" by light? Thanks again.
 
mirror.
 
shoook said:
Thanks for the input guys! Is there a known material that is "most reflective" to light? Is there a known material that is "most impenetrable" by light? Thanks again.

It depends on the wavelength. If you choose a specific wavelength, a mirror can be designed to be as reflective as one can afford, for that wavelength, but it may be absorptive or transmissive to other wavelengths.

On the other hand, if you want a mirror that can reflect many wavelengths, metals are usually best for the visible range, but they all have some level of absorption, and reflection is not equal for all wavelengths.

As for most "impenetrable", again, this fundamentally depends on wavelength. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attenuation_coefficient
 
One online company claims to produce mirrors with better than 99.999% reflectivity in the 800 nm region of the spectrum. Going with the 99.999% number, it will take about 100,000 reflections for the energy to be reduced to 37%.

Put the mirrors in vacuum making a cavity 15 cm long having a round-trip time of one nanosecond, the storage time to 37% is 50 milliseconds. –that's longer than I expected.
 
Back
Top