Thermopile, let extract some electricity from heat without steam

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the construction and efficiency of thermopiles and thermocouples for generating electricity from heat sources, such as candles or small fires. Participants explore various aspects of thermoelectric generation, including the limitations of current designs and the potential for using Peltier devices.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • One participant reports generating only 1 mA and a small voltage from their thermopile, expressing frustration with its performance under high temperatures.
  • Another suggests calculating the heat output of a candle and the power requirements of a DVD player to assess feasibility.
  • A participant clarifies that a thermocouple generates voltage based on the temperature difference between its ends, noting that ambient temperature affects the output.
  • Discussion includes the source impedance of K type thermocouples and the need to connect multiple units in series to achieve higher voltages.
  • Some participants propose exploring Peltier devices as an alternative for solid-state electricity generation, emphasizing the importance of temperature difference across the unit.
  • Concerns are raised about the efficiency of thermoelectric devices, with one participant noting that they typically do not return the same amount of energy input.
  • Participants discuss the voltage output characteristics of different thermocouple types, such as K type and J type, and their respective sensitivities.
  • One participant shares links to resources on Peltier units, while another suggests purchasing a Peltier device for experimentation.
  • There is a cautionary note regarding the first law of thermodynamics in relation to energy conversion efficiency.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a range of views on the effectiveness of thermopiles and Peltier devices, with no consensus on the best approach or the feasibility of generating sufficient power for devices like DVD players. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the optimal methods for enhancing electricity generation from heat.

Contextual Notes

Participants acknowledge limitations in the efficiency of thermoelectric devices and the challenges in achieving high wattage outputs. There is also mention of the dependence on specific materials and configurations for thermocouples.

Jacquesl
Messages
136
Reaction score
1
I want to build a Thermopile to generate usable electricity with a heat source, like a small fire or something,
I can build something like this but, I only get 1 mA and an ant of a volt. And it subjected to 1700C blow torch, it sucks.

So does anyone have some info about that, would be nice, to light a candle and then your able to watch a DVD :smile:
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
Find out how much heat a candle produces.
Then find out how much power a DVD player and TV take to run.

Finally, find out the efficiency of your thermopile. Factor that into the power of your candle, and you'll see whether or not you can run your TV and DVD player off it.
 
Lmao, it’s just a joke about that TV and DVD part. I just want to find a way to get more electricity out of heat
 
brewnog said:
...Factor that into the power of your candle, and you'll see whether or not you can run your TV and DVD player off it.

Not quite. A thermocouple develops a voltage based on the DIFFERENCE between the ends of the thermocouple wire. So if you live in a climate where the temp is 50 below zero you could put the open end of your thermocouple wire outside and the joined end of the thermocouple wire inside your house held in a candle. You will have more voltage than if you had the open end at room temperature. I know it's not much, but I did say 'not quite', I didn't say 'not even close'. Obviously then the ambient inside air temp is contributing to the temp of the thermocouples heated junction. The ambient temp of course gets its energy from the furnace or whatever heating system you have in the house.
-
I know a K type thermocouple junction seems to have a source imedance of around 25 ohms if I recall the testing that I did correctly. It is not very suitable for a power supply because to get any voltage out of it you have to series them up and of course you are also adding the source imepance as well. I believe a reachable voltage out of a K type thermocouple is .025 volts and to get 2.5 volts you would have enough in series to produce a source imedance of around 2500 ohms.
-
Look into other thermocouple junctions. This sort of thing has always interested me. I know it's not much power, but sometimes we don't need much.
 
You can also look into Peltier Devices.
These are used for solid state cooling and electrical generation.

You can probably get enough power out a few units to run a portable DVD player.

As Averagesupernova notes the temp difference acrost the unit is important.
 
I’ve already checkout “Peltier effect” but it doesn’t seem to give any usable info, like building plans


I’m looking something solid state device and for something with a high wattage output.
How I see it, it sucks up a lot of watts to heat up n heating element, say like 1000W heater. But if you apply 1000W heat source to some thermocouples, you will newer get that 1000W back, It’s the same with a spotlight, 150W flood light aimed at solar panels, I wonder how many watts will you get back, solar panels have developed more efficiently than thermopiles. In wattage outputs
I belief if you can covert something to another thing, then you can surely convert it back with at least 100% back in theory, but mostly we strive near, like in transformers example.

The K type works with (Chromel (Ni-Cr alloy) / Alumel (Ni-Al alloy))
And give out approximately 41 µV/°C

But the Type J (Iron / Constantan)
Constantan is an alloy usually consisting of 55% of copper and 45% of nickel

Type J's have a sensitivity of ~52 µV/°C, it’s a little bit more, So how just with Iron/Copper and how do you know then a certain metal will give a higher voltage than an other metal?
 
Jacquesl said:
I’ve already checkout “Peltier effect” but it doesn’t seem to give any usable info, like building plans
Just buy one on ebay to play with - they're like 5 bucks.
I’m looking something solid state device and for something with a high wattage output.
They're solid state, but high wattage, uh...
How I see it, it sucks up a lot of watts to heat up n heating element, say like 1000W heater. But if you apply 1000W heat source to some thermocouples, you will newer get that 1000W back, It’s the same with a spotlight, 150W flood light aimed at solar panels, I wonder how many watts will you get back, solar panels have developed more efficiently than thermopiles. In wattage outputs
I belief if you can covert something to another thing, then you can surely convert it back with at least 100% back in theory, but mostly we strive near, like in transformers example.
At least? Careful witht that first law of thermo...

In any case, no, peliter devices are only single-digit efficiency afaik, and they are about the best you can do.
 
Jacquesl said:
I want to build a Thermopile to generate usable electricity with a heat source, like a small fire or something,
I can build something like this but, I only get 1 mA and an ant of a volt. And it subjected to 1700C blow torch, it sucks.

So does anyone have some info about that, would be nice, to light a candle and then your able to watch a DVD :smile:

Hey Jacquesl i too was thinking of making a thermocouple running device for electricity generation! can you tell me if you were able to make any device cause i too faced the same problem of low voltage generation.
thanks please do reply back
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
4K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
4K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
9K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
12K
Replies
14
Views
5K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
6K