Thought signatures had been done away with in the new version

  • Thread starter Thread starter phinds
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the confusion regarding the visibility of signatures in a forum after a version update. Users initially believed signatures had been removed but later discovered they still exist, albeit inconsistently displaying only in new posts. It was clarified that signatures are stored with post information, meaning they will show the current signature if activated for a post. Some users expressed concerns about their signatures not appearing, suspecting it might be linked to membership status, specifically for Gold members. The conversation highlights the differences in how various forum engines handle signatures and avatars.
phinds
Science Advisor
Insights Author
Gold Member
2024 Award
Messages
19,336
Reaction score
15,483
I thought signatures had been done away with in the new version but I just noticed that some folks have them so I checked and mine was blank in the "edit signature" place, so I put one it but it does not show up.

Why is that? Does the forum not love me any more?

EDIT: well, that's embarrassing. My signature just showed up, so ignore this post. Or, as they say in New Jersey, fuggedaboutdid.

EDIT: EDIT: Even weirder --- it shows up in SOME posts (only new ones?) and not others.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
phinds said:
I thought signatures had been done away with in the new version but I just noticed that some folks have them so I checked and mine was blank in the "edit signature" place, so I put one it but it does not show up.

Why is that? Does the forum not love me any more?

{{{hug}}} In fact we adore you :smile:!

EDIT: well, that's embarrassing. My signature just showed up, so ignore this post. Or, as they say in New Jersey, fuggedaboutdid.

EDIT: EDIT: Even weirder --- it shows up in SOME posts (only new ones?) and not others.

I sent your question to the Admins, they might have some insight into this.
 
Thanks
 
Honestly - no idea.
 
Apparently my signature only shows up on new posts. Does this mean that, for example, if I changed my avatar the new avatar would only show up on new posts and all my old posts would still have the old avatar?

I mean, I assume (and it IS just an assumption) that the avatar and signature are created as the thread is displayed and are based on their current value. Are they actually stored with the old threads? This seems unlikely (VERY inefficient) but I guess it COULD be the way it works.
 
phinds said:
Apparently my signature only shows up on new posts. Does this mean that, for example, if I changed my avatar the new avatar would only show up on new posts and all my old posts would still have the old avatar?

I mean, I assume (and it IS just an assumption) that the avatar and signature are created as the thread is displayed and are based on their current value. Are they actually stored with the old threads? This seems unlikely (VERY inefficient) but I guess it COULD be the way it works.

Avatars are generated on each page view, signatures are stored with the post information.
 
Greg Bernhardt said:
signatures are stored with the post information.
To expand this: the setting "Show signature yes/no" is stored with the post information. If the signature is activated for a post, the post will always show your current signature.

Avatars are always shown, if they exist (and if the user did not choose to deactivate them).
 
Thanks, guys. That completely explains what I'm seeing.
 
mfb said:
To expand this: the setting "Show signature yes/no" is stored with the post information.

Do you know if it was always this way under vB?

I am dealing with three forums, each using different engine, each using slightly different rules for such things. Now and then I try to apply vBulletin logic to SFM, or I am surprised by the fact vBulletin doesn't work the way phpBB does
grumpy_borek.png
 
  • #10
It is like that in vB2, vB3 and vB4. I did not test vB5 yet.
 
  • #11
Borek said:
Now and then I try to apply vBulletin logic to SFM,

What is SFM?
 
  • #12
mfb said:
To expand this: the setting "Show signature yes/no" is stored with the post information. If the signature is activated for a post, the post will always show your current signature.

Avatars are always shown, if they exist (and if the user did not choose to deactivate them).

hmm, mine never shows.
i assumed the signatures and avatars were for gold members, but as i read this it appears i must have change my settings of such.
i'm not sure how i did this.

edit-

hmm. for me it's not the disable/able function, they are all check for enable,
so for me it has to be another reason.
 
Last edited:
  • #13
krash661 said:
hmm, mine never shows.
i assumed the signatures and avatars were for gold members, but as i read this it appears i must have change my settings of such.
i'm not sure how i did this.

They are in indeed reserved for Gold members.
 
  • #14
Greg Bernhardt said:
They are in indeed reserved for Gold members.

ok thanks for confirming this.
 
  • #15
LCKurtz said:
What is SFM?

Sorry, SMF. Simple Machines Forum.
 
  • #16
My sig. still appears below my posts, so I must be persona to some extent grata.:angel: But there seems to be no mechanism for modifying it. :oldfrown:
 
  • #17
epenguin said:
My sig. still appears below my posts, so I must be persona to some extent grata.:angel: But there seems to be no mechanism for modifying it. :oldfrown:
Greg has a fondness for penguins? Watch your back.:-p
 
  • #18
epenguin said:
My sig. still appears below my posts, so I must be persona to some extent grata.:angel: But there seems to be no mechanism for modifying it. :oldfrown:
The problem is you are not gold any more :(
 
  • #19
Greg Bernhardt said:
The problem is you are not gold any more :(

If it's a matter of a slight monetary sweetener in the right hands, just say the word a nd I'll see how I am situated, though the times are hard.
 
  • #20
epenguin said:
If it's a matter of a slight monetary sweetener in the right hands, just say the word a nd I'll see how I am situated, though the times are hard.
Yes, gold buys gold, that's the rule :)
 

Similar threads

Replies
13
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
15
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
610
Replies
67
Views
5K
Replies
20
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Back
Top