News Tony Blair's Defiance Over the European Rebate

  • Thread starter Thread starter Andy
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around the UK’s EU rebate, a financial adjustment that has allowed Britain to receive a portion of its contributions back since the Thatcher era. Currently, the rebate is under scrutiny, with proposals to fix its amount from 2007 to 2013, potentially costing the UK around £20 billion while still contributing significantly more than countries like France. Tony Blair opposes this proposal, suggesting that Britain will only consider renegotiation if France agrees to cut its farm subsidies. The debate highlights long-standing tensions between the UK, France, and Germany regarding financial contributions to the EU, with historical context provided about Thatcher's negotiation tactics. The conversation also reflects a lighter tone, with participants joking about the ongoing political rivalry and its entertainment value.
Andy
Messages
73
Reaction score
14
Howdy people, as some of you have hopefully seen on the news Tony Blair is defying Europe about this Rebate watchamacallit. I think it must be good if gerhard schroder and good old jacques don't want the british to have it. But i still don't know what it is, so can anyone explain what it is and what the reason for the big argument is?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Andy said:
I think it must be good if gerhard schroder and good old jacques don't want the british to have it. But i still don't know what it is,
Oh nice logic there sparky.
 
lol, well's everyone already knows I am a fool so why pretend any different.
 
Basically, since Thatcher faffed about with the EU in 1984, the UK has been pouring a shedload of money into the EU, and doesn't get as much back. Instead, we've been getting this rebate, which gives us some of our money back. It's something to do with farmers.

Anyway, it's been proposed that the amount of this rebate is to be fixed for the period from 2007-2013. This could mean that we lose out on something like £20 billion, and still be paying a third more than France does.

Tony doesn't like this plan, so he's saying "no thanks".

http://politics.guardian.co.uk/eu/story/0,9061,1506172,00.html#article_continue
 
Andy said:
Howdy people, as some of you have hopefully seen on the news Tony Blair is defying Europe about this Rebate watchamacallit. I think it must be good if gerhard schroder and good old jacques don't want the british to have it. But i still don't know what it is, so can anyone explain what it is and what the reason for the big argument is?
All member countries make a donation to the EU based on the size of their economy. Britain's nett contribution was the biggest (money paid in vs subsidies received) and so under Margaret Thatcher's leadership Britain demanded and got an annual rebate currently worth £3.5 billion. Basically M. Thatcher blackmailed them at the time by vetoing all new legislation until they gave her what she wanted. Ever since the French and the Germans have wanted this rebate stopped. France will shortly be paying more than Britain in nett terms and are increasingly incensed by the rebate. Britain meanwhile is threatening to veto this years budget if the French and Germans don't get off their case. This will hurt the French particularly as their farmers are major recipients of EU subsidies. T. Blair has offered that Britain will renegotiate on the rebate if France will renegotiate on the farm subsidies (as in a major reduction) and so the fun continues.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Art said:
T. Blair has offered that Britain will renegotiate on the rebate if France will renegotiate on the farm subsidies (as in a major reduction) and so the fun continues.

And to say that this kind of fun wouldn't take place anymore with the European Constitution (R.I.P.) :cry:
 
Thanks people, kinda cleared it up but think i will stay out of politics for a while.
 
vanesch said:
And to say that this kind of fun wouldn't take place anymore with the European Constitution (R.I.P.) :cry:
lol personally I'd miss it. Watching France and Britain going at it 'hammer and tongs' is the best free entertainment available.
 
Art said:
lol personally I'd miss it. Watching France and Britain going at it 'hammer and tongs' is the best free entertainment available.

You're right: it would be the end of a millennium-long tradition :-p
Some things, you just have to keep them I guess :biggrin:
 
  • #10
Andy said:
Howdy people, as some of you have hopefully seen on the news Tony Blair is defying Europe about this Rebate watchamacallit. I think it must be good if gerhard schroder and good old jacques don't want the british to have it. But i still don't know what it is, so can anyone explain what it is and what the reason for the big argument is?

I think because its a mail-in rebate instead of an instant rebate
:smile: :smile:
 
  • #11
vanesch said:
You're right: it would be the end of a millennium-long tradition :-p
Some things, you just have to keep them I guess :biggrin:

Yeah, when the French voted "no" last week, I was almost worried that we'd actually start to get along!

But now, it's business as usual, then...
 
  • #12
brewnog said:
Yeah, when the French voted "no" last week, I was almost worried that we'd actually start to get along!

But now, it's business as usual, then...

lol "ok back to plans for WW3"
 
  • #13
Pengwuino said:
lol "ok back to plans for WW3"

Nahh, it's more friendly than that. I reckon it's like hating your little sister or something.
 
  • #14
brewnog said:
Nahh, it's more friendly than that. I reckon it's like hating your little sister or something.
Yes, but which one of you is the little sister? :-p
 
  • #15
jma2001 said:
Yes, but which one of you is the little sister? :-p

It doesn't matter, the contempt is mutual!
 

Similar threads

Back
Top