Trouble Determining Moment Arm (aka Lever Arm)

12 replies · 7K views · last reply
x2017
Messages
84
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


Free-body diagram of a rectangular frame with point P on its left edge, two forces F1 and F2 applied at angles A1 and A2 on top and bottom edges, with distances r1x, r1y, r2x and r2y labelled and XY axes shown.


Homework Equations


ΣM=Στ

The Attempt at a Solution


I know how to get the net torque about point P, but I am having difficulty determining where the moment arms for each force should be. I did 9 simpler questions before this no problem, but this diagram is a bit more complicated and I'm having trouble with it. The last three questions I have to do are all exactly the same (this one) with different numbers, so some help would be greatly appreciated!

I know the moment arm is the perpendicular distance from the line of action of the force to the point of rotation.

I am confused as how to find the length of the moment arms in this particular diagram. I think they should look like this (orange and blue lines)
Free-body diagram of a rectangle with point P at its left edge, forces F1 and F2 drawn at angles A1 and A2, with dimensions r1x, r1y, r2x and r2y labelled and the values listed below the diagram.


But I am lost as to how to get their lengths (if where I have them is even correct).
 
Hi,

Perhaps you could try to divide the forces F2 and F1 in the x and y directions.

Such that F2x = F2cos(A2), F2y = F2sin(A2), F1x = F1cos(A1), and F1y = F1sin(A1).

Hence, Your free body diagram would look a little like the attached picture.

Hope this answers your question!
 
Attachments
  • Hand-drawn free-body diagram of a rectangle with pivot point D on its top edge, showing red force arrows labelled F1x = F1cos(A1) and F2x = F2cos(A2) horizontally and F1y = F1sin(A1) and F2y = F2sin(A2) vertically at the left and right sides, with distances r1 and r2 marked along the top.
    P_20160304_123415.jpg
    20.3 KB · Views: 574
Look at the point where your blue line crosses the horizontal line at the bottom of the rectangle .

What do you know about the two acute angles there ?

What do you know about the sum of the angles in right angle triangles ?.
 
Last edited:
ShraZam said:
Hi,

Perhaps you could try to divide the forces F2 and F1 in the x and y directions.

Such that F2x = F2cos(A2), F2y = F2sin(A2), F1x = F1cos(A1), and F1y = F1sin(A1).

Hence, Your free body diagram would look a little like the attached picture.

Hope this answers your question!
I've tried this a few time and I haven't been able to get the correct answer :(
Do you spot a mistake I could have made?
If you can't read my writing I can type it out!
Handwritten torque calculation on lined paper with components F1x, F1y, F2x, F2y, F3x, F3y, F4x, F4y and sums of torques for four pivot choices, final result stated as -98.94 N·m.
 
Nidum said:
Look at the point where your blue line crosses the horizontal line at the bottom of the rectangle .

What do you know about the two acute angles there ?
I'm not sure, are they supposed to be the same?

Nidum said:
What do you know about the sum of the angles in right angle triangles ?.
They add up to 180 degrees.
 
This is messy, sorry, but I'm at this point in trying to figure the question out!
Hand-marked diagram of two forces F1 and F2 acting at different points on a rectangle, with position vectors r1x, r1y, r2x, r2y from point P, angles A1 and A2 labelled, and components F1x = F1 cos A1, F1y = F1 sin A1, F2x, F2y = F2 sin A2 with torque labels.
 
Last edited:
Yes - they are the same . So what is the angle between your blue line and the left vertical line of the rectangle at point P ?
 
Nidum said:
Yes - they are the same . So what is the angle between your blue line and the left vertical line of the rectangle at point P ?
38.3 degrees
 
Yes - that angle and angle A1 are the same . Quick bit of trig now will give you length of blue line ?
 
Hint : Work out the base length of the triangle below point P .
 
Nidum said:
Hint : Work out the base length of the triangle below point P .
Tried it this way, still not getting correct answer
Handwritten physics working on grid paper showing a lever-arm triangle diagram with forces F1 and F2, trig calculations for opposite and adjacent lengths, and a torque sum on a second sheet below.
 
Diagram of a rectangle with point P on its left edge, showing forces F1 and F2 applied at angles A1 and A2 and position vectors r1x, r1y, r2x and r2y, with axes X and Y marked.


This was your best diagram . Put in the actual dimensions and angles as given and add those that you have worked out so far .

Label all points where lines meet or cross . Simple a , b , c --- will suffice .
 
Last edited:
ShraZam said:
Hi,

Perhaps you could try to divide the forces F2 and F1 in the x and y directions.

Such that F2x = F2cos(A2), F2y = F2sin(A2), F1x = F1cos(A1), and F1y = F1sin(A1).

Hence, Your free body diagram would look a little like the attached picture.

Hope this answers your question!

Nidum said:
This was your best diagram . Put in the actual dimensions and angles as given and add those that you have worked out so far .

Label all points where lines meet or cross . Simple a , b , c --- will suffice .

I eventually solved it using the first method I tried (breaking into x and y components.
Thanks for your help.
Handwritten torque solution on a printed quiz sheet: a rectangular body with forces F1, F2, A1 and A2 at its edges, point P marked on the left, and dimensions r1x, r1y, r2x and r2y labelled, with the net torque about P written as -456.77.