Understanding Complex Solutions and Plotting on a Function Graph

AI Thread Summary
When solving quadratic equations with a negative discriminant (D<0), the solutions are complex and do not appear on the traditional x-y plot, as they lack real roots. For the equation 5x² + 2x + 1 = 0, the complex solutions are x1 = -0.2 - 0.4j and x2 = -0.2 + 0.4j. While the parabola does not intersect the x-axis, it has a minimum point at (-0.2, 0.8). To visualize complex solutions, one must consider a three-dimensional graph where the z-axis represents the imaginary part, creating a hyperbolic paraboloid. This approach allows for a representation of complex roots in a spatial context, illustrating their relationship to the real function.
usermath
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
When I solve a quadratic equation I need to find a Discriminant. If D>0 I have no problem. I can find x1 and x2. And when I draw a parabola I can see the x1 and x2 on a X-line.

But when D<0 I don't understand where I can find x1 and x2 on a plot of function.

For example for 5x2+2x+1=0
I have complex solutions: x1 = -0.2-0.4j and x2 = -0.2+0.4j

Ok. It's the answer, but what I can do with one? Where can I find this points on the plot of function?

It's a plot of funciton y=5x2+2x+1
GPryzOC.png


Coordinates of a Minimum Point is X = -0,2 Y = 0,8.

What does (y=0; x=-0.2+0.4) mean? How can I use this expression? Where I can find the point with coordinates y=0; x=-0.2+0.4j ?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
usermath said:
When I solve a quadratic equation I need to find a Discriminant. If D>0 I have no problem. I can find x1 and x2. And when I draw a parabola I can see the x1 and x2 on a X-line.

But when D<0 I don't understand where I can find x1 and x2 on a plot of function.

For example for 5x2+2x+1=0
I have complex solutions: x1 = -0.2-0.4j and x2 = -0.2+0.4j

Ok. It's the answer, but what I can do with one? Where can I find this points on the plot of function?

It's a plot of funciton y=5x2+2x+1
GPryzOC.png


Coordinates of a Minimum Point is X = -0,2 Y = 0,8.

What does (y=0; x=-0.2+0.4) mean? How can I use this expression? Where I can find the point with coordinates y=0; x=-0.2+0.4j ?
Not on the Real Plane, unfortunately.

Since the parabola shown does not intersect the x-axis, it has no real roots.

Because the discriminant D < 0, it does have a pair of complex conjugate roots which satisfy the equation.

Applying the Quadratic formula should give you:

x = {-2 ± √[(-4)2-4(5)(1)]} / (2)(5)

or x = -0.2 ± 0.2 i [Note: you made an arithmetic error when you took the square root of D]
 
I think traditionally "i" is used instead of "j" for complex numbers but that doesn't matter for your question.

The graph you are showing is a 2-dimensional graph of the x-y plane. x and y are real numbers so this is the "real" plane. Graphically there are no real values for x where y=0.

However, if you were to create another plane perpendicular to the x-y plane where you now use j as the "z"-axis then this is the "complex" plane. If you now plot the values of y for different values of x+zj you would get something in 3-dimensions that looks like a series of inverted parabolas that look like a saddle (called a hyperbolic paraboloid). Graphically you would see that the saddle intersects the y=0 plane on two lines: x = -0.2+0.2zj and x = -0.2 - 0.2zj.

image007.gif


In the picture z has taken the place of y and vice versa.
 
Thanks a lot. It was very useful answers for me.
 
I picked up this problem from the Schaum's series book titled "College Mathematics" by Ayres/Schmidt. It is a solved problem in the book. But what surprised me was that the solution to this problem was given in one line without any explanation. I could, therefore, not understand how the given one-line solution was reached. The one-line solution in the book says: The equation is ##x \cos{\omega} +y \sin{\omega} - 5 = 0##, ##\omega## being the parameter. From my side, the only thing I could...
Back
Top