Understanding Force During a Crash: Solving as a Multiple of Weight

  • Thread starter Thread starter Brin
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the force exerted by the ground on a capsule during a crash, expressed as a multiple of the capsule's weight. The capsule, weighing 210 kg, crashed at a speed of 311 km/h, penetrating the ground by 81 cm. Participants struggle with the concept of expressing force as a multiple of weight, leading to confusion over calculations and formulas. One user ultimately arrives at a force of 470 times the weight of the capsule, but questions the accuracy of this result based on feedback from an online physics program. Clarifications on the calculations and concepts of force and weight are sought throughout the exchange.
Brin
Messages
73
Reaction score
0
It's 2:30 AM and I'm doing some Physics online, and I can't wrap my brain around the this question:

What force did the ground exert on the capsule during the crash? Express the force as a multiple of the capsule's weight.

Specifically, I don't understand what the force as a multiple of the capsule's weight is. I've tried a long list of nonsensical answers, all of which fail.

Some of the ones I tried are:
Note: Fn = Force in Newtons, Fg = G-Force, g = gravity, w = weight
Fn/w
Fn/g
Fn/Fg

None of them work! (which sort of makes sense in my head...)

If you're curious, here is the problem as it is presented:

On September 8, 2004, the Genesis spacecraft crashed in the Utah desert because its parachute did not open. The 210-kg capsule hit the ground at 311 km/h and penetrated the soil to a depth of 81.0 cm.

I've solved all the other problems relating to the g-force upon impacting, the acceleration of the capsule during the crash, and the force in Newtons of the crash. Also, the length of time in which the crash occurred. I just have no idea of what solving as a multiple of the capsule's weight means.

Thank you for any help!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
If weight of the capsule is W, and the force to find is F, you have to write in terrms of W, like 2W or 3.5 W. So, just write as F/W times W.
 
Hm, this confuses me more.

So maintaining that F is force in Newtons that the capsule exerted on the Earth (using Newton's 3rd law, I assume the Earth is exerting the same force back on the capsule) and that W is the weight of the capsule in Newtons:

F/W * W = F?

I still am not understanding (And I'm feeling particularly dense at the moment), could you maybe explain it again? Thanks.
 
Suppose the wt of the capsule is W=100 N and the force F which you have to find is 200 N, then how will you express the force F in terms of W? How many times of W is F? Just think for a second.
 
Okay, so here is what I have
The force in Newtons that the capsule exerts on the Earth is 9.7 * 10^5 Newtons. - Note that this is the effect of the capsule on the earth, and the question is about the force of the Earth on the capsule, using Newton's third law, I assume they are the same. So, as I proceed using your idea that F/W = Answer.

I take 9.7 * 10^5 Newtons divided by the weight of the capsule,( 210kg * 9.8(gravity) = 21.43 Newtons) = 45263.65 --- This isn't the answer.

Your example is as the following
W= 100N
F = 200N
Your question is How many times of W is F? 2 Right?!
Then shouldn't the above be the right answer? (it isn't according to this online physics program).

I'm honestly trying to think, but man I'm feeling frustrated! Thank you for your help thus far, I'm sure I'll get it.
 
I got an answer of 470 times the wt of the capsule.
 
Brin said:
Okay, so here is what I have
The force in Newtons that the capsule exerts on the Earth is 9.7 * 10^5 Newtons. - Note that this is the effect of the capsule on the earth, and the question is about the force of the Earth on the capsule, using Newton's third law, I assume they are the same. So, as I proceed using your idea that F/W = Answer.

I take 9.7 * 10^5 Newtons divided by the weight of the capsule,( 210kg * 9.8(gravity) = 21.43 Newtons) = 45263.65 --- This isn't the answer.
Then you had better check your calculator! 210 * 9.8 is NOT 21.43!

Your example is as the following
W= 100N
F = 200N
Your question is How many times of W is F? 2 Right?!
Then shouldn't the above be the right answer? (it isn't according to this online physics program).

I'm honestly trying to think, but man I'm feeling frustrated! Thank you for your help thus far, I'm sure I'll get it.
 
Woops - I don't know how I didn't even catch that mistake.

None the less I got the answer of 470 times the weight of the capsule for my answer as well - which is the same answer as the "g force" of the capsule on the Earth - which isn't the answer either (according to the physics program).

What the heck!?
 
Brin said:
On September 8, 2004, the Genesis spacecraft crashed in the Utah desert because its parachute did not open. The 210-kg capsule hit the ground at 311 km/h and penetrated the soil to a depth of 81.0 cm.

What acceleration did the object experience that resulted in it going from 311 kph to 0 kph in 81.0 cm?

Use this formula:

a\Delta{x}=\frac{1}{2}(v^2-v_0^2)

Solve for a.

Then figure out what force it took to decelerate a given mass at that rate.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top