Understanding Op Amps: Confusion About Current Flow in Circuits Explained

  • Thread starter Thread starter jtucker
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Amp Op amp
Click For Summary
The discussion centers on the confusion surrounding current flow in operational amplifiers (op amps) for a mechanical engineering student. It clarifies that while op amps have infinite input impedance and zero output impedance, the current flows from external power supplies, not from the input. The conversation highlights that op amp diagrams often omit power supply connections to reduce clutter, which can lead to misunderstandings about how the amplifier operates. Feedback in circuits allows for the assumption of ideal op amp behavior, despite real-world limitations. Understanding these concepts is essential for effectively analyzing and designing circuits involving op amps.
jtucker
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
Hello folks,
This is my first post here, I hope I am posting my question in the correct place/manner? I am a mechanical engineering student taking an electrical class. We are studying op amps. The thing that is confusing me is current flow in the circuits. I understand that there is infinite input impedance going into the op amp, and zero impedance out. I wonder how current can flow out of the op amp if none flows in? Am I correct in understanding that inside of an amplifier there is some sort of dependent voltage source? If there is no current flowing into the op amp how can the source inside depend on anything? Thanks in advance for any help somebody can give me in understanding op amps, I will appreciate it.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Some diagrams of Op Amps leave out the voltage source (Vs+,Vs-). That is where the output current flows from.

180px-Op-amp_symbol.svg.png
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
jtucker said:
Hello folks,
This is my first post here, I hope I am posting my question in the correct place/manner? I am a mechanical engineering student taking an electrical class. We are studying op amps. The thing that is confusing me is current flow in the circuits. I understand that there is infinite input impedance going into the op amp, and zero impedance out. I wonder how current can flow out of the op amp if none flows in? Am I correct in understanding that inside of an amplifier there is some sort of dependent voltage source? If there is no current flowing into the op amp how can the source inside depend on anything? Thanks in advance for any help somebody can give me in understanding op amps, I will appreciate it.

A real OpAmp, of course, has a finite input current and a finite gain. (And a non zero output impedance). But, when incorporated into a suitable circuit, (using feedback) the circuit characteristics can be calculated by assuming that the OpAmp is 'ideal'. The results are 'near enough' for the purpose in a good design.
As in all electronics, there is an accepted tolerance (depending on the spec of the requirement) for all component values and that includes amplifier characteristics. So 'near enough' is not a cop-out; it's a way of achieving a result with (as always) finite resources.

If you are starting on a course on OpAmps, you will soon get involved with the idea of feedback and with the formulae involved. You find that there is (usually) negligible difference in performance in a feedback circuit with a real amplifier unit or an idealised one and the gain or other characteristics of the circuit are pretty well independent of the detailed performance of the amplifying component.

If you are a Mech Eng, you will be familiar with the idea of assuming some parts of structure are 'ideal' and you will identify the critical elements and use only them in calculations. It's similar with electronics.
 
jtucker said:
Hello folks,
This is my first post here, I hope I am posting my question in the correct place/manner? I am a mechanical engineering student taking an electrical class. We are studying op amps. The thing that is confusing me is current flow in the circuits. I understand that there is infinite input impedance going into the op amp, and zero impedance out. I wonder how current can flow out of the op amp if none flows in? Am I correct in understanding that inside of an amplifier there is some sort of dependent voltage source? If there is no current flowing into the op amp how can the source inside depend on anything? Thanks in advance for any help somebody can give me in understanding op amps, I will appreciate it.

This is probably your 3rd answer at least, but anyway the answer is the current emanates from either or both power supplies.
 
rude man said:
This is probably your 3rd answer at least, but anyway the answer is the current emanates from either or both power supplies.

Ah yes - I now see what the OP was confused about.
The basics of all amplifiers is that they control the flow of power out, supplied by a power supply, by a small amount of input signal power. I always think that the first amplifying devices were given a good name - Valve. That implies controlling the flow through something with a control input. All amplifiers have at three or more connections for this reason.
On OpAmp schematic circuits, they tend to leave out the Power Supply connections. Confusing but it reduces the 'clutter' on the diagram.
 
Thanks for the replies everyone. I had seen the diagram with the Vs (+ and -) going into the sides, but it is confusing how usually they are left out. I guess I have been confused in that I have been thinking the V+ and V- input's are essentially voltage sources? But I guess maybe not. In fact my professor has given op amp homework problems where he included voltage sources that are connected directly to the V- and V+ terminals but the Vs terminals shown on the diagram above are left out. This confuses me, and I guess brings me back to my original question. I have actually been able to solve several of these circuits for gain and or resistor values, etc. using voltage and current division but none the less I find it confusing. I will go talk to my professor about it tomorrow I suppose.
 
A voltage source means it will supply enough current to maintain it's specified voltage. Like a big battery.
 
jtucker said:
Thanks for the replies everyone. I had seen the diagram with the Vs (+ and -) going into the sides, but it is confusing how usually they are left out. I guess I have been confused in that I have been thinking the V+ and V- input's are essentially voltage sources? But I guess maybe not. In fact my professor has given op amp homework problems where he included voltage sources that are connected directly to the V- and V+ terminals but the Vs terminals shown on the diagram above are left out. This confuses me, and I guess brings me back to my original question. I have actually been able to solve several of these circuits for gain and or resistor values, etc. using voltage and current division but none the less I find it confusing. I will go talk to my professor about it tomorrow I suppose.

The +V and -V power supply contacts are often left out of a diagram, the assumption being that, in conjunction with appropriate feedback, the op amp is operating linearly. Their value becomes important only in dc analysis when inputs come close to, or result in, saturating the amplifier.
 
There are integrated circuits with multiple operational amplifiers in one package. e.g. this dual-in-line package (DIP) of the LM324.

lm324.jpg


When drawing a schematic of a circuit that uses more than one op-amp from a package, you really only need to show the power input pins on one. e.g. this circuit using two amps of the quad op-amp package (each labeled as 1/4 LM324 with power pins 4 and 11 shown on only one).

figure_02.gif
 

Similar threads

Replies
15
Views
2K
Replies
21
Views
3K
Replies
34
Views
4K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 44 ·
2
Replies
44
Views
5K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
4K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
5K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
2K