Voltage Divider vs Voltage Regulator?

6 replies · 6K views · last reply
Vishera
Messages
72
Reaction score
1
I have two questions.

1. A lot of voltage dividers are wired up like this:

Circuit schematic of a voltage divider with a battery on the left, series resistors R1 and R2 on the right branch, and a load resistor RL in parallel with R2.


Is there any reason why they can't be wired up like below?

Circuit schematic of a battery with its positive terminal marked, connected in series to a resistor labelled R1 and a second resistor labelled RL, forming a single loop.


2. When should a voltage regulator be used instead of a voltage divider?
 
Voltage regulators should be used whenever economically viable because all power going through R2 in fig 1. is completely wasted. But if you are just using the voltage as a signal, say for digital logic, and there isn't any significant current flow, then voltage dividers are perfectly fine.
 
Vishera said:
I have two questions.

1. A lot of voltage dividers are wired up like this:

Circuit schematic of a voltage divider: a battery with positive terminal at top feeds series resistor R1, then a node with R2 in series below and a load resistor RL in parallel with R2.


Is there any reason why they can't be wired up like below?

Circuit schematic of a battery with its positive terminal on the left, feeding two resistors in series labelled R1 and RL on the right side of a rectangular loop.


2. When should a voltage regulator be used instead of a voltage divider?

i think voltage regulator is way better than voltage divider. although linear regulators burn a lot of energy.
 
linear regulators are actually very efficient.
A regulator should be used wherever possible

Vishera said:
1. A lot of voltage dividers are wired up like this:

Circuit schematic of a battery in series with R1, then R2 and RL in parallel, with the battery's positive terminal marked +; R1, R2 and RL are labelled as resistors.


Is there any reason why they can't be wired up like below?

Circuit schematic of a battery in series with two resistors, R1 and RL, forming a single loop; the battery's positive terminal is marked with a plus sign on the left.

RL=Resistance of the load.
many times it is a variable value.
If your divider was setup in the topology you suggested in your second picture, the voltage across RL would change a lot as RL changed. If it was setup as suggested in the first picture, It would not change as much.

Also when you get to transistors, you will see why it can be advantageous to use the first topology.
 
Both of the diagrams in the OP will work but the voltage across the load is very dependent upon the value of RL. That could be very embarrassing for the function of the circuit being supplied (RL). A voltage regulator will produce the correct voltage at the output by altering the current it supplies, (using a transistor - or equivalent) effectively as a variable R1, to keep the ratio of resistances right for the required output volts. That's a dynamically adjusted voltage divider - if you like.
 
donpacino said:
linear regulators are actually very efficient.
.....

no, linear regulators are quite inefficient

hence its always better to use buck or boost regulator topology, efficiency is substantially improved

to the OP...
circuit 1 is a voltage divider, circuit 2 isn't
voltage divider circuits DONT provide any regulation and as sophiecentaur said ...
voltage across the load is very dependent upon the value of RL.



Dave