Studying Want to learn Quantum Mechanics - How do I start?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on an engineering student's journey into quantum mechanics, seeking guidance on foundational resources and a structured learning path. The student has a solid background in multivariable calculus, differential equations, and basic linear algebra, along with physics knowledge in mechanics, dynamics, waves, optics, and electromagnetism. Recommendations for introductory texts include Sakurai and Shankar, though some participants suggest these may be too advanced, advocating for alternatives like Griffiths or Feynman's works, which provide different perspectives on quantum concepts.Key advice includes starting with Hamiltonian and Lagrangian mechanics to clarify concepts, and considering mathematical methods in physics to strengthen the necessary math skills. Participants encourage exploring multiple texts simultaneously to gain a well-rounded understanding. The student plans to take a modern physics class and aims to progress through various quantum mechanics resources, ultimately seeking clarity on the best path forward in their studies.
nishraptor
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
I am an engineering student with an interest in quantum mechanics : However, I really need to make a flowchart so I can understand where to proceed

What I know:
Math -
Multivariable calculus, Differential Equations including laplace and Fourier series, and Basic Linear Algebra (Spaces, Diagonalization, QR)

Physics- Mechanics, Dynamics, Waves, Optics, E&M and Maxwell's equations

I'm thinking of starting with an Introductory book - either Sakurai or Shankar(Any preference anyone?)

However, my main questions are A) With my given knowledge are those books a good place to start? and B) Can anyone give me a good path to proceed afterwards?

Thank you all so much!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
A light weight alternative would be Susskinds book Quantum Mechanics the Theoretical Minimum
 
nishraptor said:
I am an engineering student with an interest in quantum mechanics : However, I really need to make a flowchart so I can understand where to proceed

What I know:
Math -
Multivariable calculus, Differential Equations including laplace and Fourier series, and Basic Linear Algebra (Spaces, Diagonalization, QR)

Physics- Mechanics, Dynamics, Waves, Optics, E&M and Maxwell's equations

I'm thinking of starting with an Introductory book - either Sakurai or Shankar(Any preference anyone?)

However, my main questions are A) With my given knowledge are those books a good place to start? and B) Can anyone give me a good path to proceed afterwards?

Thank you all so much!

I would learn some Hamiltonian dynamics first. It's not necessary, but it will make a lot of things much clearer. Try also to do some dual spaces in linear algebra, and inner product spaces. Tensor products might be a good thing to know too.
 
It might be useful to see some classical mechanics that includes introductory material on Lagrangians and Hamiltonians, but maybe this isn't strictly necessary before beginning quantum mechanics.

In North America, Sakurai is a standard graduate textbook.

As a beginning book, one possibility is "Quantum Mechanics" by David McIntyre,

https://www.amazon.com/dp/0321765796/?tag=pfamazon01-20
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'd recommend to have a look at QMSE1 (and then at QMSE2) video course on https://lagunita.stanford.edu and/or at a book "Quantum Mechanics for Scientists and Engineers" by David A. B. Miller.
It addresses people with no advanced background in math and physics (introducing some math stuff where necessary) and yet is quite serious and covers pretty much.
 
  • Like
Likes dextercioby
nishraptor said:
I am an engineering student with an interest in quantum mechanics : However, I really need to make a flowchart so I can understand where to proceed

What I know:
Math -
Multivariable calculus, Differential Equations including laplace and Fourier series, and Basic Linear Algebra (Spaces, Diagonalization, QR)

Physics- Mechanics, Dynamics, Waves, Optics, E&M and Maxwell's equations
What level did you see these topics at? I'm guessing you took two years of calculus and the intro physics sequence. You don't mention any modern physics. You might want to start with going over the chapters on basic quantum mechanics in your intro physics book.

I'm thinking of starting with an Introductory book - either Sakurai or Shankar(Any preference anyone?)
These texts might be too advanced for you. As George noted, Sakurai is a text used in graduate school. You probably want to find a book suitable for an upper-division quantum mechanics course.

You'll probably need to learn some more advanced math as well, so I recommend getting a good book on mathematical methods in physics.
 
Thanks for the advice - I'm taking a class on modern physics next quarter.

My plan is now to
- Read up on Hamiltonians and Lagrangian Mechanics
- Start Griffith's Introductin to Quantum Mechanics/Read Feynman's Volume III
- Move to Shankar or Sakurai's Quantum Mechanics

Any comment's on this plan or Any suggestions on where to proceed afterwards?

Thank you everyone!
 
:welcome:

I would say that you should feel free to try and read a first few chapters of Griffiths/Feynman/Sakurai/Shankar simultaneously. Each offers a different perspective that complements each other.

Feynman's introduction is more conceptual and focuses on the double slit experiment. The first chapter of Sakurai is mostly finite dimensional linear algebra and a quick-and-dirty introduction to dual spaces and the infinite dimensional linear algebra. Shankar has a more thorough introduction to the math and Lagrangian/Hamiltonian mechanics. He also shows you how the infinite dimensional case is a continuum limit of the finite dimensional case. Griffiths immediately jumps into the Schrodinger equation in an infinite dimensions and tells you what to calculate.

After all that, you'll probably have a better idea of what you want to do afterward.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top