What Causes the Weakening of Magnetic Strength When Two Magnets are Joined?

  • Thread starter Thread starter scott_sieger
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Riddle
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the mechanics of magnetic strength when two magnets are joined. Participants analyze a diagram illustrating a design involving two cylindrical magnets, questioning the validity of the proposed attraction and rotation. Key points include the symmetry of the magnets, which leads to no net gravitational or magnetic force, and the misconception that the bottom of the rings experiences greater attraction. It is clarified that when two magnets are joined, their combined strength does not exceed their individual strengths when apart. Overall, the consensus is that the design does not function as intended due to these principles.
scott_sieger
Hi guys,
Attached is a diagram design in principle i drew some time ago

It's pretty self explanitory

I was wondering if some one can tell my why it is invalid and doesn't work.
 

Attachments

Physics news on Phys.org
Perhaps I need some explanation after all. Your picture looks completely symmetric. I can so no reason why either ring should turn. The inner ring is already resting on a point below its center of gravity, so there is no net gravitational force.
The outer ring is symmetric about the inner so there is no net magnetic force.
On your picture you have a section that is NOT symmetric labeled "Horizon of greatest attraction". Why is that region not symmetric about the two rings?
 
'Tis indeed a perpetual riddle, 'cos I'll be damned if I can figure out what you're trying to say Scott
 
The rimgs are in fact cylinders that are poled magbets as shown.

The join of the two rings offers a greater attraction than the top of the rings there fore the bottom of the rings is attracted more strongly to the large attractor (magnet) to the right thus rotation is possible.
 
Originally posted by scott_sieger
The rimgs are in fact cylinders that are poled magbets as shown.

The join of the two rings offers a greater attraction than the top of the rings there fore the bottom of the rings is attracted more strongly to the large attractor (magnet) to the right thus rotation is possible.

The problem is the the bottom of the rings aren't attracted more strongly to the exterior magnet. Your assumption that they are is where you are making your mistake.
 
so when two magnets are joined the combined strength is not more than when apart?
 
Originally posted by scott_sieger
so when two magnets are joined the combined strength is not more than when apart?
No.
 
Back
Top