What is the difference between magnetic dipole moment and torque ?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the differences between magnetic dipole moment and torque, particularly in the context of a coil placed in a magnetic field. Participants explore the definitions and implications of these terms, focusing on their physical meanings and relationships in electromagnetic contexts.

Discussion Character

  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants propose that the magnetic dipole moment (Md) is defined as the product of electric current, area, and number of turns in a coil, while torque (τ) is related to the interaction of Md with a magnetic field.
  • Others argue that the term "moment" can refer to different concepts, such as mechanical moments and moments of inertia, which are not the same as torque.
  • A participant suggests that the magnetic dipole moment represents an intrinsic property of a magnet or loop that influences its alignment with an external magnetic field.
  • There is a discussion about the terminology, with some participants clarifying that the term "intensity" should refer to electric current, and that the understanding of "moment" may vary based on context.
  • One participant expresses confusion about the term "moment," indicating that they were taught it is synonymous with torque, and seeks clarification on whether the magnetic moment can be thought of as the "arm" of the magnet.
  • A later reply challenges the idea of equating the magnetic moment to the "arm" of the magnet, indicating that this analogy may not be correct.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus on the relationship between magnetic dipole moment and torque, with multiple competing views and interpretations of terminology remaining throughout the discussion.

Contextual Notes

There are unresolved issues regarding the definitions of terms like "moment" and "torque," as well as the implications of these definitions in different contexts. The discussion reflects varying levels of understanding and interpretations among participants.

B4ssHunter
Messages
178
Reaction score
4
imagine a door shaped circuit in the between a south and north pole
such that the long sides are perpendicular to the magnetic field created by the magnet , now
in my physics book , it says that the torque that rotates the door is equal to B * Md where Md is the magnetic dipole moment which equals Intensity * Area * Number of turns * for a coil *
now what is the difference between the magnetic dipole moment ? isn't moment the same thing as torque ?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
You have an equation that says: ##\tau=BMd## (making some assumptions about geometry) and you are asking if ##M## is not the same as ##\tau##? Doesn't the equation tell you?

You should be aware that words can be used to mean different things in different contexts.
A "torque" is a "mechanical moment" - when there is no risk of confusion, you get to leave off the "mechanical" part to save typing. Notice that there is also a "moment of inertia" or "inertial moment" - which is also a moment that is not the same as a torque.
 
B4ssHunter said:
Md is the magnetic dipole moment which equals Intensity * Area * Number of turns * for a coil

I think you mean (electric) current, not intensity. Perhaps the symbol I for current is confusing you.

now what is the difference between the magnetic dipole moment ? isn't moment the same thing as torque ?

Magnetic dipole moment is a property of the current loop which is independent of the presence of an externally-produced magnetic field. Because of that property, the loop experiences a torque when placed in an externally-produced magnetic field. That torque depends on both the magnetic dipole moment of the loop, and the strength of the magnetic field.
 
I think you mean (electric) current, not intensity. Perhaps the symbol I for current is confusing you.
The reason the symbol for electric current is "I" is that it used to be called "current intensity" or just "intensity". The use of an archaic term usually signifies someone who is self-taught from old textbooks found for free online.There are other uses for the word moment, for instance we can talk about an event turning or hinging on a particular moment of time. Also not a torque. There are lots of moments that are not torques. :)
 
Simon Bridge said:
You have an equation that says: ##\tau=BMd## (making some assumptions about geometry) and you are asking if ##M## is not the same as ##\tau##? Doesn't the equation tell you?

You should be aware that words can be used to mean different things in different contexts.
A "torque" is a "mechanical moment" - when there is no risk of confusion, you get to leave off the "mechanical" part to save typing. Notice that there is also a "moment of inertia" or "inertial moment" - which is also a moment that is not the same as a torque.

mr simon , i do understand the equation
but what was really bothering me is the word MOMENT , i have been taught that moment is the same as torque , so for me it was like saying
magnetic torque = magnetic * torque * X Magnetic flux density of the field
but now i understand that the the magnetic moment is somekind of an intrinsic property of a magnet * or loop* to align itself to another magnetic field , or to rotate to another magnetic field
more like the affinity or strength of a magnet to align to another magnet field , is that true ?
would it be correct if i think of it as the " arm " of the magnet ?
 
Last edited:
B4ssHunter said:
mr simon , i do understand the equation
but what was really bothering me is the word MOMENT , i have been taught that moment is the same as torque
Yeah - I got that, which is why I went to some trouble to point out that this is the wrong impression.

The lesson where torque and moment was the same was supposed to be taken in context of mechanical moments only. You are expected to figure this stuff out as you advance - definitions will change as you learn more stuff.

but now i understand that the the magnetic moment is some kind of an intrinsic property of a magnet *or loop* to align itself to another magnetic field , or to rotate to another magnetic field more like the affinity or strength of a magnet to align to another magnet field , is that true ?
That would be one way of thinking about it for now. Be aware that this understanding will have to change later depending on what you end up doing.

would it be correct if i think of it as the " arm " of the magnet ?
No.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
4K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 25 ·
Replies
25
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
1K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
997