What political persuasion are you?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Evo
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a political quiz that categorizes individuals into various political identities, including New School Democrats, Libertarians, Liberal Republicans, and Capitalist Republicans. Participants express their results and share their thoughts on the accuracy of the quiz, often finding discrepancies between their self-identification and the outcomes. Key themes include a preference for social liberalism, skepticism towards government intervention, and a mix of economic conservatism with social progressivism. Many participants critique the quiz for its limited questions and assumptions, suggesting that it fails to capture the complexity of their political beliefs. The conversation also touches on issues like education vouchers, government roles in personal lives, and the intersection of religion and politics, highlighting a general desire for a more nuanced understanding of political identities.
Evo
Staff Emeritus
Messages
24,029
Reaction score
3,323
You Are a New School Democrat

You like partying and politics - and are likely to be young and affluent.

You're less religious, traditional, and uptight than most Democrats.

Smoking pot, homosexuality, and gambling are all okay in your book.

You prefer that the government help people take care of themselves.

http://www.blogthings.com/political-persuasion.html
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Those 12 highly limited questions surely were able to help me identify who i am as a registered voter :)
 
You Are a "Don't Tread On Me" Libertarian

You distrust the government, are fiercely independent, and don't belong in either party.

Religion and politics should never mix, in your opinion... and you feel opressed by both.

You don't want the government to cramp your self made style. Or anyone else's for that matter.

You're proud to say that you're pro-choice on absolutely everything!

:cool:
 
Pengwuino said:
Those 12 highly limited questions surely were able to help me identify who i am as a registered voter :)
What was your result?
 
It says I'm a Republican, after I said I'd vote for Dean and identify most with Libertarians ! :eek:
 
Gokul43201 said:
It says I'm a Republican, after I said I'd vote for Dean and identify most with Libertarians ! :eek:
heheh I said I was against legalization of pot, it says I'm for it.
 
You are a Liberal For Life--

You've got a bleeding heart - and you're proud of it.

For you, liberal means being compassionate, pro-government, and anti-business.

You believe in equality for every person, and you consider yourself universally empathetic.

Helping others is not just political for you ... it's very personal too.

meh, not really
 
Last edited:
I got the whole christian republican thing. I didn't know i was for prayer in school
 
Pengwuino said:
I got the whole christian republican thing. I didn't know i was for prayer in school
Religious pirate penguin. :-p

http://img424.imageshack.us/img424/1905/piratepenguin5xv.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #10
Well, I don't associate with any of those parties in the last choice, so clicking through the list, I'm either a new school Democrat, a capitalist Republican, or a Don't Tread on Me Libertarian. I'd say it's a bit imprecise. :rolleyes:
 
  • #11
oh dear, not this again evo.....YARRR!
 
  • #12
You Are a Liberal Republican

When you tell people that you're Republican, they rarely believe you.

That's because you're socially liberal - likely pro-choice and pro-gay rights.

You're also not so afraid of big goverment, as long as it benefits people and not politicians.

You are the most likely of any Republican type to swing over to the Democrat side sometimes.

I must be getting soft in my old age.
 
  • #13
FredGarvin said:
I must be getting soft in my old age.
See, now that could be Russ.
 
  • #14
FredGarvin said:
I must be getting soft in my old age.
Was there even a gay rights question on there? This quiz seems to assign attributes to people it hasn't even asked questions about. :confused: Though, your description describes me well, so I have to wonder how I wound up in the categories I wound up in. :rolleyes:
 
  • #15
Moonbear said:
Was there even a gay rights question on there? This quiz seems to assign attributes to people it hasn't even asked questions about. :confused: Though, your description describes me well, so I have to wonder how I wound up in the categories I wound up in. :rolleyes:
There was an implied question when they asked about sex between consenting adults.
 
  • #16
Evo said:
Religious pirate penguin. :-p
Wait, I think that should look more like this... :biggrin:
 

Attachments

  • religiouspiratepenguin.jpg
    religiouspiratepenguin.jpg
    17.5 KB · Views: 520
  • #17
You Are a Liberal Republican
http://www.quizdiva.net/bt/liberal-repub.jpg
When you tell people that you're Republican, they rarely believe you.

That's because you're socially liberal - likely pro-choice and pro-gay rights.

You're also not so afraid of big goverment, as long as it benefits people and not politicians.

You are the most likely of any Republican type to swing over to the Democrat side sometimes.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #18
iansmith said:
You Are a Liberal Republican
http://www.quizdiva.net/bt/liberal-repub.jpg
When you tell people that you're Republican, they rarely believe you.

That's because you're socially liberal - likely pro-choice and pro-gay rights.

You're also not so afraid of big goverment, as long as it benefits people and not politicians.

You are the most likely of any Republican type to swing over to the Democrat side sometimes.
:smile: That's pretty funny coming from a Canadian. :biggrin:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #19
Moonbear said:
:smile: That's pretty funny coming from a Canadian. :biggrin:

Here's my Canadian result:

You Are a "Don't Tread On Me" Libertarian

You distrust the government, are fiercely independent, and don't belong in either party.

Religion and politics should never mix, in your opinion... and you feel opressed by both.

You don't want the government to cramp your self made style. Or anyone else's for that matter.

You're proud to say that you're pro-choice on absolutely everything!


I'll agree for the most part.
 
  • #20
That's pretty funny coming from a Canadian.
Where can I take the quiz to find out if I'm a Canadian?

I'm a Liberal Republican, unless I change answer #12 (which I was waffling on) -- then I'm a Don't Tread On Me Libertarian.
 
  • #21
Moonbear said:
Wait, I think that should look more like this... :biggrin:
Yes, much more religious. :approve:

Cyrus, have you read the pirate nerd thread? That was before your time, but it's in the Classics Thread.
 
  • #22
You Are a Capitalist Republican

Money makes your world go round - and it's no surprise that you always vote your wallet.

You're financially successful (or plan to be), and your agenda is low tax and pro business.

You don't get fired up about abortion... but mention capital gains tax, and you go crazy.

You want government to be as small as possible - and to stay out of the way of business.

Meh. Not really. I am a bit economically conservative, but I vote liberal because of social issues. I'd bet I would get different results by switching single answers around
 
  • #23
You Are a Liberal Republican
That's how I usually measure.
When you tell people that you're Republican, they rarely believe you.
In this forum? :smile: :smile: :smile: No, in today's political climate, people have little doubt what I'm registered as.
That's because you're socially liberal - likely pro-choice and pro-gay rights.
Pro choice yes, gay rights...ehhh...
You're also not so afraid of big goverment, as long as it benefits people and not politicians.
Ehh, that doesn't really match how I answered.
You are the most likely of any Republican type to swing over to the Democrat side sometimes.
It happens - so far not in a national election, though.

I do object to some of the questions, though. Vouchers, for example, don't have to be for religious purposes. In fact, they typically aren't.
 
  • #24
Fred said:
I must be getting soft in my old age.
Evo said:
See, now that could be Russ.
Excuse me, I'm only 30, and I work out on a regular basis, damnit!
 
  • #25
russ_watters said:
Excuse me, I'm only 30, and I work out on a regular basis, damnit!
Yeah, but once you hit 30, it's all downhill from there. :biggrin:
 
  • #26
russ_watters said:
I do object to some of the questions, though. Vouchers, for example, don't have to be for religious purposes. In fact, they typically aren't.
People don't usually promote them for that reason, but because it's often the case that the only nearby alternatives to public schools are parochial schools, that's one of the objections people raise regarding vouchers, that it's using tax money to subsidize religious education. So, that's where that question comes from.
 
  • #27
I'm mixing concepts a little (or, perhaps, the concepts should be combined), but I'm a really big fan of charter schools too.
 
  • #28
I seem to be a liberal republican...

(whatever that means...)
 
  • #29
I'm either a "don't tread on me libertarian" or "liberal republican" depending on the answer to the last question (what, no "none of the above" option? MIH, want to start a pirate platform?). I suppose all the statements in those two profiles are pretty accurate for me, except for the two in the liberal republican one involving being republican.
 
  • #30
I'm a Liberal for life, althou I chose Democrat for the last question! :bugeye:
 
  • #31
If I where an American, I'd be a bleeding hart liberal.

Not surprising, since over here liberals are considered to be RIGHT wing...and I vote socialist :biggrin: So the poll doesn't go enough to the left for me.
 
  • #32
vanesch said:
I seem to be a liberal republican...

(whatever that means...)

I think you can compare them to "dark blue" liberal democrats over here.
 
  • #33
Pengwuino said:
Those 12 highly limited questions surely were able to help me identify who i am as a registered voter :)


Heh... I had the same thought.

not only were the questions limited, but the questions and answers had a certain assumption of what was right built into them... not to mention, the conclusions were overly broad and I d not think that the government should take care of people, but it should be there to help and provide basic services for everyone. (see my point about making assumptions)
 
  • #34
Any one have the link to that good political test? you know the one that plots you on a graph between liberal and conservative in the horizontal axis and libertarian and authoritarian on the vertical axis?
 
  • #35
Moonbear said:
People don't usually promote them for that reason, but because it's often the case that the only nearby alternatives to public schools are parochial schools, that's one of the objections people raise regarding vouchers, that it's using tax money to subsidize religious education. So, that's where that question comes from.

Solution to the voucher issue: Public Charter Schools.
 
  • #36
You Are a New School Democrat

You like partying and politics - and are likely to be young and affluent.

You're less religious, traditional, and uptight than most Democrats.

Smoking pot, homosexuality, and gambling are all okay in your book.

You prefer that the government help people take care of themselves.

hmmm, I am not american so this is null and void ;)
 
  • #37
russ_watters said:
I'm mixing concepts a little (or, perhaps, the concepts should be combined), but I'm a really big fan of charter schools too.
I'm not a big fan of either. I think all it does is siphon money away from the poor (as in unfortunate, not necessarily in terms of wealth, although not necessarily unrelated) kids who are already handicapped by disinterested parents. As Chi Meson has pointed out here before, it's easy for the private schools to look good, because they can be choosy about who they admit, and the parents of those kids obviously consider education a priority, and when you pull out all the top students, and leave behind the bottom of the class and all the special needs students in public schools, the overall class averages look more and more disparate between private and public schools, with less resources for those who most need them. If I'm going to have to pay school taxes despite not having any children, then I want all children to have an equal chance for an education, not just hand lump sums to the rich so their kids can go off to a private school. If they want to send their kids to private school, do it with their own money, not mine.
 
  • #38
I gave up after the first three questions. I don't agree with any of the answers presented to me.

Bull****, really.
 
  • #39
Lisa! said:
I'm a Liberal for life, althou I chose Democrat for the last question! :bugeye:

Same thing wif me:smile:

I wonder what Che would think...:rolleyes:
 
  • #40
Moonbear said:
:smile: That's pretty funny coming from a Canadian. :biggrin:

I was suprised too. I also didn't vote conservative this election.
 
  • #41
You make up the conservative, Christian, dedicated core of the Republican Party.
You believe it's important for religious people to stand up for their beliefs in politics.
And for you, this means voting your conscience - which almost always means voting Republican.
Your pet causes include the sanctity of life, school vouchers, and prayer in school.

This is not acurate at all. I almost never vote republican: in my opinion they've betrayed their values and sunk to the lowest common deminator of only trying to get votes. I am strongly religious, love the sanctity of life, but deathly opposed to both democrats and republicans. This blog doesn't have a choice for people like me, its created with the status quo in mind.
 
  • #42
ComputerGeek said:
Any one have the link to that good political test? you know the one that plots you on a graph between liberal and conservative in the horizontal axis and libertarian and authoritarian on the vertical axis?
I bumped it up.

https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=82393
 
  • #43
You Are a Liberal Republican said:
When you tell people that you're Republican, they rarely believe you.

That's because you're socially liberal - likely pro-choice and pro-gay rights.

You're also not so afraid of big goverment, as long as it benefits people and not politicians.

You are the most likely of any Republican type to swing over to the Democrat side sometimes.
The first line is true and I do vote for Democrats occasionally (Ken Salazar is easily better than his Republican counterpart, Wayne Allard). Most of my friends find it hard to believe I'm Republican. But then again, I'm a defense contractor living in Colorado Springs - home to James Dobson, Focus on the Family headquarters, and five military installations. Most of the people I know are extremely conservative. This is the first place I've ever lived where I was considered a liberal.
 
  • #44
It said I was a "DOn't Tread on Me Libertarian". :smile: I don't think I'm anything close to that. I've seen what the Libertarian platform consists of and I don't think I'm not on track with hardly any of their ideals.

I wonder what I really am politically though. Here in MA I think I'm center or a little to the right. My wife is a little left. When we were in CA she was considered a little to the right and I might have well as been wearing a brown shirt and goose stepping everywhere :smile:
 
  • #45
The Political Compass

Economic Left/Right: -4.00
Social Libertarian/Authoritarian: -4.05

Wow I'm about 1/4 the way down into the lower left part of the chart. That's a little more detailed test than the first one so I guess it gets me closer to how I m politically (socio/economically).

I'm in the Dahli Lama Nelson Mandela section.
 
Back
Top