What Was the #1 Song on Your Birthday?

[Jimmy Snyder]

"Mr. Custer" by Larry Verne. Never heard of it.

It was a novelty song.

 

[Jimmy Snyder]

And the birthday paradox is confirmed!

It's unrelated. In the birthday paradox, the birthyear is irrelevant.

 

[Redbelly98]

Turning 50 this year? Such a young one!

Next year

 

[Bel_Oubli]

"Blame It on the Rain" by Milli Vanilli

I've never heard of that before...

 

[LowlyPion]

It's unrelated. In the birthday paradox, the birthyear is irrelevant.

But it is a birthday paradox type of calculation, though far more complicated by the observation that Billboard Chart Toppers may be there for varying lengths of weeks. And the weeks are taken over some number of decades and that distribution is further complicated by potential lumpiness in PF demographics.

 

[mcknia07]

It's my long lost twin, qspeechc!

 

[Moonbear]

Ooh, I'm special. I got two songs! I guess there was a tie.
"Maggie May/ Reason to Believe" by Rod Stewart

 

[Ouabache]

Novelty song that happened to hit the pop charts...

Winchester Cathedral by The New Vaudeville Band.

Never heard of it...

obodiodo

... born when "Come Softly to Me" by the Sevilles was #1

"The Happy Organ" by Dave "Baby" Cortez was #1 just after the Sevilles hit..

 

[myxomatosii]

1985 ... "Shout" by Tears for Fears

haha sweet i love that song.

 

[Moonbear]

This thread is making me feel really old. I know most of the membership here is considerably younger than I am, but seeing you all born with songs at the top of the charts that I remember coming out while I was in high school is really rubbing it in!

 

[Gnosis]

I can hardly believe that so many individuals on this board who consider themselves intelligent are so naïve as to divulge their BIRTHDATE to some unknown website. For all you know, it could simply be a front for Identity Thieves! After all, they HAVE managed to get YOU to submit YOUR BIRTHDATE, and while connected to their website, they may have also gotten your IP.

Additionally, anyone who views THIS thread could potentially derive YOUR birthdate simply by the #1 song that YOU revealed per your birthday! If you give identity thieves your birthday and IP, it’s almost like handing them a credit card.

Of course, there's always a chance that website is harmless, but how can YOU be sure? Reality: You don’t typically get anything for free in this world. Since they don’t charge for their service, who typically wants to pay the cost to keep a server up and running unless it’s making them some $$$.$$?

Advice: It’s best not to give out your birthdate and it pays to use a fictitious birthdate when you sign up on public message boards as well. Naturally, you can do as you desire, but you'd NEVER catch me giving out vital information such as my birthdate, e-mail, SSN, etc…

 

[Borek]

I can hardly believe that so many individuals on this board who consider themselves intelligent

Speaking about intelligence...

After all, they HAVE managed to get YOU to submit YOUR BIRTHDATE

..you don't have to submit your birthdate to check what was played.

Have you actually visited the site, or do you know it is wrong, wrong, wrong beforehand?

 

[Redbelly98]

This thread is making me feel really old. I know most of the membership here is considerably younger than I am, but seeing you all born with songs at the top of the charts that I remember coming out while I was in high school is really rubbing it in!

Ha ha, if it makes you feel any better I was in middle school when Maggie May came out.

 

[turbo]

Ha ha, if it makes you feel any better I was in middle school when Maggie May came out.

I was in college.

 

[Jimmy Snyder]

I can hardly believe that so many individuals on this board who consider themselves intelligent are so naïve as to divulge their BIRTHDATE to some unknown website. For all you know, it could simply be a front for Identity Thieves! After all, they HAVE managed to get YOU to submit YOUR BIRTHDATE, and while connected to their website, they may have also gotten your IP.

I thought that they could only get your ISP's IP, not your own. However, I'm not sure. Last night I came home expecting a surprise birthday party, but to my surprise there was none. When I asked my wife about it she said it wasn't my birthday. I said it was, it always has been. When she insisted, I pulled out my birth certificate and sure enough, the date had been stolen. I was frantic as I need this birthday to count towards my receiving a social security check when I retire. I started looking around the net to see if I could catch these birthday thieves. Luckily I traced it to that Nigerian princess that sent me $20 million last year. It cost me most of that money to track her down, but I succeeded. It turns out she had stolen thousands of birthdays, including many of those hard to get Feb. 29 ones. She was so fat from eating all that cake that she couldn't get away from the police. I got my birthday back, but I will certainly be more careful in the future.

 

[Borek]

 

[Ouabache]

This thread is making me feel really old. I know most of the membership here is considerably younger than I am, but seeing you all born with songs at the top of the charts that I remember coming out while I was in high school is really rubbing it in!

Ha ha, if it makes you feel any better I was in middle school when Maggie May came out.

when this song came out, I remember working on intermediate algebra problems while my white mice were running in wheels in their cages.

"Sugar Shack" by Jimmy Gilmer & the Fireballs.

I won't ask if you remember the day President Kennedy was shot. But I am guessing you saw The Beatles on Ed Sullivan.

Did you have a microscope and telescope? I find this is quite common among PF members when they were little.

I had a small light microscope with three obj. lenses (including oil immersion). One fun use was to view the world of small organisms in a drop of pond water. I wanted a telescope, but couldn't afford one. I did get to know friends who let me look through their telescopes. I found the moons of Jupiter quite fascinating

 

[Danger]

I won't ask if you remember the day President Kennedy was shot. But I am guessing you saw The Beatles on Ed Sullivan.

Yes to both. I sulked all night about the Kennedy thing because they pre-empted 'Popeye' for news coverage of it.

 

[Gnosis]

Speaking about intelligence...



..you don't have to submit your birthdate to check what was played.

Have you actually visited the site, or do you know it is wrong, wrong, wrong beforehand?

Where birthdates are a key factor, I simply resist the temptation to visit such a website. I actually practice what I preach, but of course, you're free to divulge any personal information about yourself as you desire.

However, YOU missed a key point that I previously made in thinking yourself so clever.

I also previously stated that YOU are openingly revealing your BIRTHDATE per this completely public physics forum per this thread by replying in this thread with the #1 song that coincides with YOUR birthdate! If anyone can simply go to that website and visually locate the #1 song per a birthdate, then it is a simple matter to link YOUR birthdate by the #1 song that you've openly provided here on this public forum.

 

[Kurdt]

I don't think the charts were updated daily anyway. Even if they were, number ones can often last several weeks.

 

[jobyts]

I thought that they could only get your ISP's IP, not your own. However, I'm not sure.

That's correct. The ISP gateways NAT (Network Address Translation) the actual address. Also, mostly the IP addresses would be dynamically allocated (eventhough, practically they never change it).

 

[Ouabache]

Yes to both. I sulked all night ... they pre-empted 'Popeye' for news coverage of it.

 

[Gnosis]

I don't think the charts were updated daily anyway. Even if they were, number ones can often last several weeks.

Naturally, songs will typically remain #1 for various lengths however, history has also typically recorded the day that they were declared #1, in which case, THAT'S the day that would be used for the website, not the span of time in which it remained #1.

The ingenuity of identity thieves should never be underestimated. Some are top notch in digging and retrieving personal data and they have all the time in the world to burrow.

For instance, by doing a simple web search, identity thieves can easily find posts on public forums such as this physics forum, where the joshhosler web link was posted and/or used. Since most of you have openly revealed the #1 song per YOUR BIRTHDATE here on THIS physics forum, they can easily link your user name with your birthdate and continue to burrow for additional data.

I’ve done a bit of homework here. I performed a search and found the link that would steer identity thieves right back to this thread.

The following link is the result of that search for the joshhosler web link…

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=http://www.joshhosler.biz/&start=90&sa=N



Then, from the above search results page, the link below steers them right back to this forum where they begin to link user names with the birthdates via the #1 song that YOU people openly stated was #1 on YOUR birthdate. So you see, you NEVER have to provide ANY info directly at the joshhosler website…

https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?p=2121786



As I stated previously, that website just may be harmless, but I would never simply assume such. I am only trying to spare the wise any potential "identity thief" grief. Naturally, those who think themselves so damn clever and invulnerable will pay this no mind. So be it, as it's no skin off my nose if they incur such an issue.

 

[Borek]

That's correct. The ISP gateways NAT (Network Address Translation) the actual address. Also, mostly the IP addresses would be dynamically allocated (eventhough, practically they never change it).

My current ISP changes my IP every 24 hours.

 

[Kurdt]

Naturally, songs will typically remain #1 for various lengths however, history has also typically recorded the day that they were declared #1, in which case, THAT'S the day that would be used for the website, not the span of time in which it remained #1.

No, they are posted for the span that they are number 1. I have checked. You couldn't pinpoint my birthday to within a month on that website for example. I think most people on this site are well aware of the danger of online identity theft.

 

[rootX]

Naturally, songs will typically remain #1 for various lengths however, history has also typically recorded the day that they were declared #1, in which case, THAT'S the day that would be used for the website, not the span of time in which it ////
As I ...

potential "identity thief" grief. Naturally, those who think themselves so damn clever and invulnerable will pay this no mind. So be it, as it's no skin off my nose if they incur such an issue.

Do you know that your computer can also be hacked and all your computer activities can be traced by hacker? Then do you:
1) do online shopping
2) share personal information with known friends
3) use email for official or personal purposes
4) do online banking
5) fill government online forms
?

 

[Jimmy Snyder]

Naturally, songs will typically remain #1 for various lengths however, history has also typically recorded the day that they were declared #1, in which case, THAT'S the day that would be used for the website, not the span of time in which it remained #1.

You are simply wrong on this point.

The ditty that the site says was #1 on my birthday, "The Third Man" theme, it also says was #1 each day from April 23 until July 8, a period of more than 20% of a year.

By the way, the site does not say anything at all about birthdays. It just says "Look up the Number One Song on Any Date in History". Birthdays come to mind, but also wedding day, first date, first kiss, you name it. If the site was set up for the purpose of stealing identities, I doubt it has met with enough success to justify the time and expense of creating it.

 

[Borek]

As someone selling software on the web I am obliged by Polish law to publish my address and tax identity number on my site. To allow people pay for my programs I have to give them my bussiness bank account number.

I was born on 29.12.1962.

Do you really think I just got more vulnerable?

 

[Ivan Seeking]

As someone selling software on the web I am obliged by Polish law to publish my address and tax identity number on my site. To allow people pay for my programs I have to give them my bussiness bank account number.

I was born on 29.12.1962.

Do you really think I just got more vulnerable?

Yes, and anyone who studies this sort of thing would say so. Identity theft is a huge problem in the US. It is said that someone's identity is stolen something like every fifteen seconds.

One should never give out specific identity information on the internet.

 

[Ivan Seeking]

The FBI, Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and Earthlink have jointly issued a warning on how the growing ranks of Internet crooks are using new tricks called "phishing" and "spoofing" to steal your identity.

In an FBI press release, Assistant Director of the agency's Cyber Division, Jana Monroe says, "Bogus e-mails that try to trick customers into giving out personal information are the hottest, and most troubling, new scam on the Internet...

http://usgovinfo.about.com/cs/consumer/a/aaspoofing.htm