When a photon is created, it instantly achieves the speed of light -- How?

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Start your own thread to ask a follow-up.
5 replies · 2K views
zuz
Messages
100
Reaction score
36
I've been told that when a photon of light is created it instantly achieves the speed of light without having to 'speed up". How is this possible?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Pedantically, photons are just light, so whatever speed they go is the speed of light.

To answer the question you are asking, however, the photons are emitted with a certain amount of energy. The process which goes into the photon being created requires the energy that makes it go as fast as it does.
 
zuz said:
I've been told that when a photon of light is created it instantly achieves the speed of light without having to 'speed up". How is this possible?

When you drop a pebble onto the surface of water, do you notice the ripple being created speeding up, or do you see it immediately moving at the a particular speed?

There is also no "why" or "how" in this case, the same way we do not have the why's and how's for light having a fix, constant speed in vacuum.

James Chase Geary said:
Pedantically, photons are just light, so whatever speed they go is the speed of light.

To answer the question you are asking, however, the photons are emitted with a certain amount of energy. The process which goes into the photon being created requires the energy that makes it go as fast as it does.

This is false, or misleading at best. It somehow implies that its speed depends on its energy, which is wrong. There is nothing to indicate light having a lower energy limit to make it go at c. All light, no matter how low its energy, moves at c.

Zz.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: davenn and russ_watters
zuz said:
I've been told that when a photon of light is created it instantly achieves the speed of light without having to 'speed up". How is this possible?
Just to add to what others have said, emitted light is not a photon, it's a wave. That is, there are no photons in a beam of light. The wave only creates a photon when it interacts with something. This is important because a lot of people, I think possibly including you, think that the emitted "photon" is like a little tiny billiard ball that goes shooting off at the speed of light.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: davenn
My apologies for my lack of rigor. I wasn't trying to be misleading, just trying to get at the concept in an intuitive way. But yes, of course, the speed doesn't depend on the energy. I just meant to imply that photons were created by a some kind of process already moving at light speed.
 
James Chase Geary said:
I just meant to imply that photons were created by a some kind of process already moving at light speed.

which also is not good
what do/did you think was already moving at c ?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: phinds