News Which Candidate Aligns With Your Views?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Greg Bernhardt
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Fun Quiz
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a political survey that matches users with candidates based on their positions on various issues. Participants share their results, revealing unexpected alignments with candidates like Rudy Giuliani and Dennis Kucinich. Many express surprise at their rankings, particularly regarding Kucinich, and note that the survey's wording significantly influences outcomes. Concerns are raised about the relevance of candidates' positions, especially regarding the Iraq war and healthcare, with some participants feeling that their true opinions were not adequately represented. Bill Richardson is mentioned as a preferred candidate, though his debate performance raises doubts about his effectiveness. The conversation highlights the limitations of such surveys, emphasizing that they often provide a simplistic view of candidates rather than a comprehensive understanding of their policies and capabilities.
Messages
19,773
Reaction score
10,728
The following is an interesting exercise... You answer a few questions then click the "find your candidate button" and the program selects the candidate who's position on the issues is most like your own...

http://www.wqad.com/Global/link.asp?L=259460

My top three were:

Rudy - 31
Hillary - 25
Barack - 25
 
Physics news on Phys.org
my top was kucinich with 77 followed by dodd and clinton
 
Brownback and Kucinich are at a dead heat for me... Go figure.
 
wildman said:
Brownback and Kucinich are at a dead heat for me... Go figure.

Wow! What a bizarre combination. I'd never expect to hear both of those candidates in the same sentence.

Mine:
Biden: 26
Clinton: 21
Obama: 21
Kucinich: 19
Giuliani: 19

Surprising results (especially Kucinich), but the disaster in Iraq and how it affects so many other things (government spending, for example) make this race non-typical. Plus, the survey doesn't give choices that match my opinions particularly well - I just had to pick the best answer available.

The truth of the matter is that I don't agree with any of the Iraq positions listed, but the one I chose most closely aligned with Biden's positions. (Iraq is a lost cause and a non-issue in itself, but how we handle things in the Middle East post-Iraq is a huge issue facing the US.)

I'd normally be much more supportive of making tax cuts permanent, but this is sure a bad time to make tax cuts a priority when we're shelling out so much money for Iraq. That skews my ratings towards the Democrats. Changing that single answer would propel Giuliani to the top.

I'm not on the same page with Republicans on health care, either. While I may not agree completely with Dems on health care, it is a fact that we're paying for the medically uninsured one way or the other already. The more important issue is whether we're going to get the value we're paying for in the future. As medical costs skyrocket, it's naive to think insurance companies won't go after every loophole they can find to avoid paying out for claims. Something will have to give one way or the other.

The way the choices are worded make a big difference. On On the Issues website, my results were Biden, Richardson, McCain, and Clinton (seeing as how my top two candidates, Tommy Thompson and Jim Gilmore, both dropped out of the race).
 
Last edited:
I would put "line item veto" in the hands of Richardson, not Hillary or any republican.

I support Bill Richardson, but the survey said:

Dennis Kucinich
Score: 37

Bill Richardson
Score: 34

Mike Gravel
Score: 28

John Edwards
Score: 28
 
Giuliani/Dodd/Romney

BobG said:
Wow! What a bizarre combination.
Those were my thoughts.
The way the choices are worded make a big difference. On On the Issues website, my results were Biden, Richardson, McCain, and Clinton (seeing as how my top two candidates, Tommy Thompson and Jim Gilmore, both dropped out of the race).
Biden/Dodd/Paul. Giuliani is far down on the list, and Romney is dead last. My opinion: the "On The Issues" site does not word their issues well, has several replicated several issues, and omits several key issues.
 
kach22i said:
I would put "line item veto" in the hands of Richardson, not Hillary or any republican.

I support Bill Richardson, but the survey said:

Dennis Kucinich
Score: 37

Bill Richardson
Score: 34

Mike Gravel
Score: 28

John Edwards
Score: 28

On paper, I think Richardson is the best candidate, as well. He's failed to impress me in his debates and appearances, though. I'm beginning to think he'd be a pretty ineffective President - possibly as ineffective as Carter was.

Huckabee suffers the opposite problem. In character and persona, he's definitely the best candidate running ... except I have almost nothing in common with his views and priorities.

That's kind of the problem with any of these surveys. They only take a 2-dimensional look at a candidate.
 
BobG said:
On paper, I think Richardson is the best candidate, as well. He's failed to impress me in his debates and appearances, though. I'm beginning to think he'd be a pretty ineffective President - possibly as ineffective as Carter was.

This was my thought too. Ontheissue quiz Richardson came in 3rd for me, but in all the debates he's looked absolutely terrible as a speaker/communicator.
 
Weird, the following all tied at 40 - Clinton, Obama, Edwards, Richardson and Juliani.

Joe Biden got 45

No surprise - Ron Paul at 14 and Huckabee at 12
 
  • #10
I got Biden at 50, Obama at 44 and Clinton at 42. (I disagreed with Biden only on the Social security issue, it seems)

Does that make me a bad person?
 
Last edited:
  • #11
I got Dodd 54, Kucinich 49, Clinton 47, but then I'm not from the US so it doesn't really mean much!
 
  • #12
Dodd - 42
Obama - 41
Hillary - 41
Edwards - 41
Kucinich - 39
Gravel - 34
Richardson - 34
...
...
McCain - 7
Huckabee - 4
Thompson - 2

The top 8 are Democrats. The bottom 10 are either Republicans or Fred Thompson (who?)
edit: Ron Pual was at 14. He's a special case :wink:I retook the test and gave the most retarded answers possible. Top 5 are:
Thompson - 52
Hunter - 52
McCain - 51
Gilmore - 44
Huckabee - 44

That Thompson guy must be seriously retarded or something. Hurr let's waste a bunch of time with gay marriage amendments, stay in Iraq until the end of time, and make sure women can only have illegal abortions. Oh and stem cells are the next Hitler, pass it on.
 
Last edited:
  • #13
Kucinich at 58. Nobody else got over 48, where Gravel and Richardson were tied.
 
  • #14
I gave as retarted answers as I could and I got Romney. Interesting. A Republican won both when I was trying to be dumb and smart.
 
  • #15
Retarded answers, love it.
 
  • #16
Top 5

Dennis Kucinich
Score: 39

Chris Dodd
Score: 31

Barack Obama
Score: 26

Hillary Clinton
Score: 26

Ron Paul
Score: 25
 

Similar threads

Replies
21
Views
5K
Replies
65
Views
10K
Replies
183
Views
79K
Replies
2
Views
9K
Replies
2
Views
502K
Replies
6
Views
6K
Replies
5
Views
4K
Back
Top