Python Which of these codes do you think is the simplest

179
6
Codes.JPG
Since i don't know how to write code here on forums i will upload a picture and explain whats it about.
In the picture there are three codes that define the same procedure of finding the biggest number out of three given. The first code in the picture is defining a procedure called ##biggest(x,y,z)## and my friend and i agree that its the simplest one but it defines a procedure that is used in the given procedure to help the calculation. The second code is made by me and the third by my friend. We're kinda arguing whose is simpler and more elegant to use xD, what do you think?
Codes.JPG
 
Last edited by a moderator:
15,178
4,836
I think if you only have 3 vars, it should be

biggest = max(max(x,y),z) or whatever construct is equivalent in whatever language you are using.
 
179
6
I think if you only have 3 vars, it should be

biggest = max(max(x,y),z) or whatever construct is equivalent in whatever language you are using.
Yeah i agree :-D, but the goal is to define a procedure and not use any built in, we are both beginners so that's why. We're using python :-D
 
32,571
4,301
Yeah i agree :-D, but the goal is to define a procedure and not use any built in, we are both beginners so that's why. We're using python :-D
Then use your bigger() function, following the idea that @phinds gave.

Since i don't know how to write code here on forums i will upload a picture and explain whats it about.
Posting an image of your code isn't very helpful. If you have an error, we can't insert a comment in your code. It's best to copy and paste the code directly into the page here, surrounding it with code tags.

Just like this:
[code=python]
Python:
def bigger(x, y):
   if (x >= y):
      return x
   else:
      return y
[/code]
(Since I have two sets of code tags, the outer set is not being rendered by the browser, due to some alterations I made. The inner set is causing the Python code to be displayed with different colors. When you do this, just use one set of tags.
 

A.T.

Science Advisor
9,559
1,467
The second code is made by me and the third by my friend. We're kinda arguing whose is simpler and more elegant to use xD, what do you think?
Python:
def biggest(x,y,z) : return x if x > y and x > z else y if y > z else z
 

wle

289
112
If you're writing a function to find the maximum of more than two numbers as an exercise then you might as well make it work for any number of numbers.

In Python if you put *args in a function's argument list then Python will collect all the extra arguments into a tuple called args that you can access and use in your function (more info here and elsewhere on the web). For example, this function simply prints all the arguments it is called with:
Python:
def print_args(*arguments):
  for arg in arguments:
    print(arg)
You could similarly write a biggest function that identifies and returns the biggest argument it is called with.

Python:
def biggest(number, *more_numbers):
  max_found = number
  for n in more_numbers:
    if n > max_found:
      max_found = n
  return max_found
 
10,690
4,248
Use your bigger function to define your biggest function:
Python:
def biggest(x,y,z):
    return bigger(x,bigger(y,z))
 
Last edited:
179
6
Thanks i tried all and i think i like using the bigger function as i find it the simplest..:-)
 

A.T.

Science Advisor
9,559
1,467
Thanks i tried all and i think i like using the bigger function as i find it the simplest..:-)
Also note that instead of 'x == False' you can write 'not x'.
 

.Scott

Homework Helper
2,338
782
Before I saw the Python label, I was thinking this (C):
#define biggest(x,y,z) ((x>y)?((x>z)?x:z):((y>z)?y:z))
 

jack action

Science Advisor
Insights Author
Gold Member
1,804
1,023
I prefer biggest2, based on a performance point of view. With 2 comparisons you get your answer.

With biggest you need at least 3 comparisons, worst case scenario 4 comparisons (+ a function call).

With biggest1, you need at least 4 comparisons, worst case scenario 8 comparisons, before getting an answer!
 

Want to reply to this thread?

"Which of these codes do you think is the simplest" You must log in or register to reply here.

Related Threads for: Which of these codes do you think is the simplest

Replies
10
Views
885
  • Posted
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
986

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving
Top