Who Controls American Carriers: The Navy or the Air Force?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Smurf
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Controls
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on a comparison between the U.S. Navy and the Air Force, with a strong preference expressed for the Navy. Participants argue that the Navy has superior control over aircraft, particularly those on aircraft carriers, and emphasize the leadership structure involving Navy captains and fleet admirals. The Air Force is characterized as weaker, despite possessing advanced aircraft like the B-2 bombers. The conversation touches on the challenges of landing on aircraft carriers and the potential career paths for Navy pilots, including opportunities with NASA. There is a playful banter about the strengths and weaknesses of various military branches, with some participants humorously downplaying the capabilities of the Army and Coast Guard while asserting the Navy's dominance. Overall, the Navy is portrayed as the more formidable force in this lighthearted debate.
Smurf
Messages
442
Reaction score
3
The navy or the air force?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
The Navy. They control the airplanes on them, too.

The USAF controls land based aircraft and air based tactical/strategic nuclear weapons (TAC and SAC, respectively).
 
Yah, US Navy.
 
Smurf said:
The navy or the air force?

The Air force is weak... Carriers have a US Navy Captain who is under orders from a fleet Admiral, IIRC. Of course they are all eventually under orders of the CINC, cheifs of staff and congress.

http://www.navy.mil/palib/people/secnav/secnav030929a.gif
This guy also has a lot to do with the control of carriers.

Regards,
 
Last edited by a moderator:
That would be the Navy. The pilots are Navy pilots, not Air Force.
 
Smurf said:
The navy or the air force?

You thinkin about a career in the US military? US Navy pilots have a good chance of becoming a NASA astronaut (although right now that might not look so appealing). A chance in a life time.

However, having racked up about 2 hours of simulation time I can tell you that landing on a carrier is not an easy thing to do.

Regards,
 
Is it just me or does that look like Donald Trump's right hand man George Ross?

http://www.theapprenticerules.com/images/george-ross.jpg
 
dduardo said:
Is it just me or does that look like Donald Trump's right hand man George Ross?

http://www.theapprenticerules.com/images/george-ross.jpg

I don't see it...
 
I guess it's just me then
 
  • #10
Townsend said:
The Air force is weak... Carriers have a US Navy Captain who is under orders from a fleet Admiral, IIRC. Of course they are all eventually under orders of the CINC, cheifs of staff and congress.

But the Air Force has the B-2's... hwo can you have those and be weak. Cost guards weak... army is weak... they don't have much cool stuff :D
 
  • #11
we have nuke power! :biggrin: i love my job
 
  • #12
Townsend said:
You thinkin about a career in the US military?
That was a joke.. right? Come on townsend, you know me better than that.
 
  • #13
what's wrong with the US military?
 
  • #14
1. It's a military
2. It belongs to the US.

(hense the name: US Military :biggrin: )
 
  • #15
Smurf said:
That was a joke.. right? Come on townsend, you know me better than that.

Yep, mostly...
 
  • #16
Smurf said:
1. It's a military
2. It belongs to the US.

(hense the name: US Military :biggrin: )
what is wrong with either of those?
 
  • #17
Why don't you https://www.physicsforums.com/search.php?searchid=215730
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #18
...nothing?
 
  • #19
Pengwuino said:
But the Air Force has the B-2's... hwo can you have those and be weak. Cost guards weak... army is weak... they don't have much cool stuff :D
Coast Guard, yes. Army NO! Bite your tongue. Black boxes and whiz bang gadgets do not make a force strong.
 
  • #20
FredGarvin said:
Coast Guard, yes. Army NO! Bite your tongue. Black boxes and whiz bang gadgets do not make a force strong.

pff, weeeeeak :D. Crazy army guys and there tanks. What tank ever had a chance against an F-15 :D
 
  • #21
Smurf said:
Why don't you https://www.physicsforums.com/search.php?searchid=215730

... does this mean there's nothing wrong?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #22
Pengwuino said:
pff, weeeeeak :D. Crazy army guys and there tanks. What tank ever had a chance against an F-15 :D
As long as that F-15 left from a fortified air base with a paved runway and the pilot's have airconditioned quarters with hot food...
 
  • #23
FredGarvin said:
As long as that F-15 left from a fortified air base with a paved runway and the pilot's have airconditioned quarters with hot food...

And since they do, they rule :cool:
 
  • #24
Nu-uh. Do not.
 
  • #25
Do to! My mommy said so
 
Back
Top