Who Sat Where in the 3rd Grade Girls' Movie Outing?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Alfi
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the seating arrangement of four individuals—Tory, Heather, Kara, and Donna—who attended a movie. Key points include that Heather took the first seat, Kara and Tory did not sit next to each other, and Donna only sat next to Tory. Several interpretations of "first seat" were debated, with some suggesting it could mean Heather sat down first without a specific seat number, while others insisted it meant she occupied the first physical seat. The final accepted seating order was Heather, Donna, Tory, and Kara (HKDT). The conversation also touched on the potential for misinterpretation of the question and the nature of trick questions, with some participants expressing frustration over the wording.
Alfi
Tory, Heather, Kara, and Donna went to see a movie. Heather took the first seat. Kara and Tory did not sit next to each other. Donna only sat next to Tory. In what order did the girls sit?



something not right here me thinks.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
methinks also
were there 5 seats? :D
 
all information is given.

I'm trying to find if this is from the tv show 'smarter than 5th grader'

I won't to see what answer was accepted.
 
K - H - D - T

Who said Heather had to be on the side? :-p
 
rx7_drifter said:
K - H - D - T

Who said Heather had to be on the side? :-p

But Heather has to be in the first seat. Maybe there's a zero seat?
 
lisab said:
But Heather has to be in the first seat. Maybe there's a zero seat?

"Heather took the first seat."

I think this can be interpreted in two ways.

-First way: Heather sat down in seat '1'. (Which makes this problem seem impossible.)
-Second way: Heather sat down first (no specific location) -- (Taking her seat first...)

That's how I see it anyways.
 
Who's to say that they all sat in a single row, or all on the same side of the aisle?
 
Quote:
Tory, Heather, Kara, and Donna went to see a movie. Heather took the first seat. Kara and Tory did not sit next to each other. Donna only sat next to Tory. In what order did the girls sit?

put a comma between Donna only, and sat next to Tory and it works

isle HKDT

might just be a typo
 
Tory, Heather, Kara, and Donna went to see a movie. Heather took the first seat. Kara and Tory did not sit next to each other. Donna only sat next to Tory. In what order did the girls sit?

answer: heather-donna-tory-kara
 
  • #10
mongstar said:
Tory, Heather, Kara, and Donna went to see a movie. Heather took the first seat. Kara and Tory did not sit next to each other. Donna only sat next to Tory. In what order did the girls sit?

answer: heather-donna-tory-kara

Donna only sat next to Tory.

donna-tory-kara - doesn't work
 
  • #11
K-h-t-d
 
  • #12
brads77 said:
K-h-t-d

Yes but that means the poster intentionally misguided the question. The "first seat" is not "sitting down first" in any dialect of English I've ever heard.

Feels less like a riddle and more like trying to interpret someone for whom English is their 4th language...

Is winning First Place the Bronze medal because its awarded before gold and silver?
 
  • #13
They were at a drive in movie. Heather and Kara sat in the two front seats, Donna and Tory sat in the back
 
  • #14
K.J.Healey said:
Yes but that means the poster intentionally misguided the question. The "first seat" is not "sitting down first" in any dialect of English I've ever heard.

Feels less like a riddle and more like trying to interpret someone for whom English is their 4th language...

Is winning First Place the Bronze medal because its awarded before gold and silver?

I would disagree...examples:
He shot the first soldier killed in the battle (doesn't imply any line-up of soldiers)
She ate the first cookie from the batch (again, no order implied)

I think the first seat can very well mean the one someone sat in first
 
  • #15
K.J.Healey said:
Yes but that means the poster intentionally misguided the question. The "first seat" is not "sitting down first" in any dialect of English I've ever heard.

Feels less like a riddle and more like trying to interpret someone for whom English is their 4th language...

Is winning First Place the Bronze medal because its awarded before gold and silver?


That's the point. It's a trick question. It's stupid and simple; no need for over-analysis.
 
  • #16
Answer: Imhotep is invisible.
 
  • #17
When they say "Donna only sat next to Tory" they mean "Donna is the only one who sat next to Tory." Alfi is right, it's HKDT.
 
  • #18
no, first place is first because the racer finished first, opposed to second or third. it is not related in any way to when the award is given.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top