Schools Why are some of the oldest universities in the world ranked so poorly?

  • Thread starter Thread starter agrocadabra
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Universities
AI Thread Summary
The University of Vienna, established in 1365, ranks around 87th globally, raising questions about the impact of age and language on university rankings. Discussions highlight that older institutions do not necessarily equate to higher quality, as rankings often favor English-speaking universities. The choice of ranking system significantly influences perceptions, with some institutions like Oxford performing differently across various metrics. Historical context is also considered, noting that the U.S. lacked world-class universities in physics until the early 20th century. Comparisons between universities can be misleading due to differing focuses and resources, with concerns raised about funding disparities, particularly in German and Russian institutions. Overall, skepticism towards the validity of online rankings is prevalent.
agrocadabra
Messages
52
Reaction score
0
For example the University of Vienna (Austria) is ranked around 87th in the world yet it's the oldest institution in the german speaking world (1365), why is this? Is language a reason?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
agrocadabra said:
For example the University of Vienna (Austria) is ranked around 87th in the world yet it's the oldest institution in the german speaking world (1365), why is this? Is language a reason?

Being old doesn't necessarily mean good.
 
Yeah but it seems that the rankings are very skewed towards universities whose first language is english.
 
agrocadabra said:
Yeah but it seems that the rankings are very skewed towards universities whose first language is english.

Depends on which ranking system you use. For example Oxford isn't ranked very highly in physics in the official ranking system for research used here in the UK (RAE) but still does well in The Times ranking aimed at students.

Also, there is no reason to expect old to mean good. There was not a single world-class university in physics in the US before about 1920 or so (which is why Oppenheimer&co went to Germany etc for their PhDs), but now that has of course changed.
 
That list makes no sense whatsoever, at least not when it comes to the universities I am familiar with.

Moreover, who do you compare Johns Hopkins with MIT?
As far as I know there is almost no overlap, so it is really an apples and pears issue
 
Are not Russian Universities good though for example? What about german universities?
 
German universities suffer from a lack of funding.
 
Do not believe too much on website rankings...
 

Similar threads

Replies
12
Views
2K
Replies
14
Views
5K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
22
Views
2K
Back
Top