Why Do Books Show More Than 3 Vibrational Modes for Water?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers around the vibrational modes of water and the apparent discrepancy between the expected number of vibrational degrees of freedom for angular molecules and the number of modes often cited in literature. Participants explore the nature of these vibrational modes, including symmetrical and asymmetrical stretching, scissoring, and other movements like rocking, wagging, and twisting.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • One participant notes that angular molecules have 3N-6 vibrational degrees of freedom but questions why water is said to have more than three modes of vibration, referencing various sources.
  • Another participant argues that the distinction between motions of parts of a molecule and the entire molecule is crucial, suggesting that in water (H2O), there are no additional bonds to allow for certain types of vibrations.
  • A participant expresses doubt regarding the classification of movements attributed to water, specifically questioning whether rocking movements change angles.
  • Further elaboration is provided on the counting of vibrational modes, explaining that the total possible motions include translational and rotational motions, leading to the conclusion of 3N-6 vibrational modes remaining.
  • Another participant reiterates the doubt about the rocking movement in water and its implications for vibrational modes.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the classification and nature of vibrational modes in water, with no consensus reached regarding the validity of the various modes cited in literature.

Contextual Notes

The discussion highlights potential limitations in understanding the vibrational modes, including the dependence on definitions of motion and the specific molecular structure of water compared to other molecules.

Talita
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
We all know that angular molecules have 3N-6 vibrational degrees of freedom.
So, why lots of books show that water has more than 3 modes of vibration, like rocking, wagging and twisting? Another example is -CH2 group.

You can see what I said here:
http://chemistry.ncssm.edu/watervibCS.pdf
http://chemwiki.ucdavis.edu/Physica...es/Number_of_vibrational_modes_for_a_molecule
http://mutuslab.cs.uwindsor.ca/eichhorn/59-330%20lecture%20notes%202004/59-330-L13-IR2-04%203-pack.pdf

Thanks! (:
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
Don't confuse the motions of part of a molecule with motions of an entire molecule.

In your first link, you'll notice that half of those six modes don't alter bond lengths or angles.
In the case of R=CH2, there is a double bond which can bend or twist to give the rocking, wagging, and twisting vibrations.

When the 3-atom group forms a free molecule like H2O, there is no third bond to bend or twist, and no restoring force when the atoms are displaced in the same manner--so instead of vibration you have three rotational modes.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Talita
Ok, but there's still a doubt.
The movements that are attributed to water are symmetrical and asymmetrical stretchings and scissoring. But the possible rocking movement in water doesn't change angle too?

Thanks again!
 
Talita said:
Ok, but there's still a doubt.
The movements that are attributed to water are symmetrical and asymmetrical stretchings and scissoring. But the possible rocking movement in water doesn't change angle too?

Thanks again!

The first part of the counting the types of motion is the first part: 3 * N. This can be imagined as coming about by taking all possible combinations of the three cartesian directions on each atom. Imagine one possible motion has atom 1 move in the x direction, atom 2 move in the y direction and atom three move in the z direction, etc. Now, amongst these 3*N possible motions, there are three motions for overall translational motion. (i.e. every atom moving in the x, y or z direction). There are also three motions that will give you rotational motion about each of the three rotational axes. So, what is left? 3*N - 6 motions that are not translation or rotation. These are the vibrational modes.

In the preliminary material shown in the first link that you provide, some of these motions for the -XY2 group bonded to the rest of a molecule would be rotation or translation in a free XY2 molecule. For example, if all of the atoms move away from the rest of the framework, this would be one of the translational motions in the free molecule, but this is the stretching of the bond to the X atom in the larger molecule.