Why Do Rain Clouds Produce Lightning While Normal Clouds Don’t?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Protonic
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
Rain clouds produce lightning due to their ability to build up sufficient electrical charge, which is facilitated by the presence of rain that helps carry the charge between the cloud and the ground. Normal clouds typically lack the necessary properties to generate this charge, as they do not reach the required size or intensity. While lightning can occur without rain in rare conditions, such as when raindrops evaporate before reaching the ground, it still requires precipitation within the cloud itself. The collision of ice particles in clouds can also contribute to charge buildup, functioning similarly to static electricity. Overall, rain plays a crucial role in the formation of lightning.
Protonic
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
Why doesn't it lightning on a cloudy day? I mean lightnings when there are rain clouds but normal clouds on a sunny day don't yeild lightning. Is it rainwater's conductivity?
 
Science news on Phys.org
It depends on the type of clouds. Different clouds have vastly differing properties, and the majority of them simply don't build up enough charge. It takes a fairly large and violent cloud to build up enough charge to cause lightning, and most of these types of clouds also cause rain.
 
Rain carries the charge between cloud and ground, allowing the clouds to become charged. So yes, rain is instrumental in causing lightning.

You can have lightning without rain in some rare situations. When air is sufficiently dry and warm at low altitude, you can have rain drops that evaporate before they reach the ground. In that case, the charge is carried between two clouds, and you can see lightning between these clouds without there being any rain at ground level. But it still has to be raining up there.
 
K^2 said:
Rain carries the charge between cloud and ground[b/], allowing the clouds to become charged. So yes, rain is instrumental in causing lightning.

You can have lightning without rain in some rare situations. When air is sufficiently dry and warm at low altitude, you can have rain drops that evaporate before they reach the ground. In that case, the charge is carried between two clouds, and you can see lightning between these clouds without there being any rain at ground level. But it still has to be raining up there.


U mean the charge going up into the cloud or the lightning itself?
 
Before you can get lightning, the cloud must be charged relative to ground. To get that, you must have charge flow from cloud to ground. Rain allows for that.
 
What about collisions between ice particles in the clouds?

Like a giant static charge, no charge flow between cloud and ground necessary.
 
Thread 'Simple math model for a Particle Image Velocimetry system'
Hello togehter, I am new to this forum and hope this post followed all the guidelines here (I tried to summarized my issue as clean as possible, two pictures are attached). I would appreciate every help: I am doing research on a Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) system. For this I want to set a simple math model for the system. I hope you can help me out. Regarding this I have 2 main Questions. 1. I am trying to find a math model which is describing what is happening in a simple Particle...
I would like to use a pentaprism with some amount of magnification. The pentaprism will be used to reflect a real image at 90 degrees angle but I also want the reflected image to appear larger. The distance between the prism and the real image is about 70cm. The pentaprism has two reflecting sides (surfaces) with mirrored coating and two refracting sides. I understand that one of the four sides needs to be curved (spherical curvature) to achieve the magnification effect. But which of the...
Back
Top