Why Does Sodium Pentobarbital Precipitate Dissolve with More HCl?

  • Thread starter Thread starter savagefarmer
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Sodium Titration
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the titration of a sodium pentobarbital solution with 0.1M HCl, where the formation and subsequent disappearance of a white precipitate is observed. Initially, the precipitate, identified as C11H18N2O3, forms when HCl is added. However, as more HCl is introduced and the pH decreases, the precipitate dissolves. Participants explore the underlying chemistry, particularly the behavior of imides and di-imides, and the role of additional H3O+ ions in the reaction. One participant suggests that the pentobarbital may react with another H3O+ ion, leading to a new reaction, but this is corrected to indicate that the correct reaction involves the formation of a protonated species, C11H19N2O3+. The discussion highlights the complexities of acid-base reactions and the specific behavior of sodium pentobarbital in acidic conditions.
savagefarmer
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
Hello everyone,

Today I witnessed the titration of a sodium pentobarbital solution with 0.1M HCl. At first, a lot of white precipitate was formed. When more HCl was added the white precipitate disappeared again completely.

Now I am trying to figure out what is going on. As I understand it the reaction is:

C11H17N2O3- + H3O+ -> C11H18N2O3 + H2O

And the white precipitate is C11H18N2O3. What I don't understand is why the precipitate disappears again when more HCl is added and the pH drops.

Thanks for any advice!

-sav
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
Seems to be start of a discussion at << link to CF discussion thread deleted by Mod >>
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Sorry, is there a policy against cross-posting on two entirely different forums?
 
Not per se, but many frequent both; so it may be wise to mention that you've also posted elsewhere
 
Ok sorry about that, I didn't realize that there would be a big overlap. I'll leave this up for now and hope for some pointers :)
 
You will note that this is a di-imide. Imides are generally fairly acidic so the proton attached to the nitrogen is easily replaced with alkali metals like sodium. You have the first step down but what might that second proton do?
 
I just read about imides and di-imides, but I'm still clueless about the role they play in this. My guess was that the pentobarbital reacted with another H3O+ ion when a lot of HCl was added and the pH dropped further:

C11H17N2O3- + H3O+ → C11H16N2O32- + H2O

Does that make sense?

Thanks,
sav
 
savagefarmer said:
I just read about imides and di-imides, but I'm still clueless about the role they play in this. My guess was that the pentobarbital reacted with another H3O+ ion when a lot of HCl was added and the pH dropped further:

C11H17N2O3- + H3O+ → C11H16N2O32- + H2O

Does that make sense?

Thanks,
sav

Sorry that reaction is wrong, it would be:

C11H18N2O3 + H3O+ → C11H19N2O3+ + H2O
 
Back
Top